Product Reviews Rated 3.28 out of 5 stars
266 Reviews
Most Helpful Positive Review Yes yes yes yes yes I could not be more thrilled with this eyeliner! I was skeptical as most felt eyeliners always seem to bleed when I try to do wings or my eye shadow clumps up on it and renders the tip useless but this eyeliner holds up!
I live in Florida home of humidity and thunderstorms and work outside no matter the weather every single day. My first day wearing it to work I sweated my butt off as usual, got caught in the rain, felt the sweat and water run down my face, and feared for the worst. Checked in a mirror a few hours later and you'd think I had just reapplied it was still so crisp!
Gotta say I don't do smokey eyes just a classic wing every day but if you want precision this is your savior.
Not sure what unicorn blood this is made of but it's totally worth a cursed life.
Most Helpful Critical Review Great Eyeliner....but gave me an allergic reaction I love this eyeliner for the price, it glides on and stays put. Very good for a 3 dollar liner, however I sadly cannot use it. This first time I washed it off with my regular neutrgena makeup wipes I noticed tiny red flecks around my eyes. But I didn't pay attention to them bc after about a day they were gone. I didn't use the eyeliner for some time and I recently used it again and this time the spots covered my eyelid and the area surrounding my eyes. IF YOU HAVE SENSITIVE SKIN DO NOT BUY. Just a warning because the flecks around my eyes are itchy and are taking forever to go away.
Reviewed by 266 customers so good!!! 5
alexaaah from california
this is by far the most inexpensive and good quality eyeliner i have ever used. I've been using this for yearsss now and i always go back to it. Ive used kat von d, stila, pur, urban decay, and gone through maybelline and loreal as well and honestly this one never fails. I have allergies daily and this stays put despite watery eyes. Don't get me wrong, its not as pigmented as high end but if you're a top liner every day kind of girl, this is great for daily use and the price is unbeatable. I can't believe theres so many negative reviews because this is such a slept on product!!
Don't get this if you want BLACK eyeliner! 1
Frances from Maryland
This eyeliner is the worst liner I've ever used, the tip is a good shape and I can easily make a wing with it but it's super watery and it's not even black, it's a bit transparent actually.
It's OK 3
Angel from Chicago, IL
I tried this eyeliner with a few luxe and it was easier to work with but if you're not careful you can touch it to the word and it doesn't dry as quickly as others
I prefer a crayon like liner - will not buy again. 3
Lucy from Michigan
I bought this product thinking it was a waterproof crayon like liner. It was not it was a slim line liquid
liner. Now, it does seem to stay on so if a liquid does not bother you it might be a good product for youl
I would buy this again 5
Aubs from Pembroke Pines Florida
The best eye liner I have ever owned
Not great 3
Alexis from MO
There was very little product in it. I store my liners upside down and maybe got 10 uses out of it. Not worth the money.
You get what you pay for 1
Kai from NC
I love liquid liners but even when I swatched it there was very little product that came out. I won't be buying this again
So good for the price!! 4
Anne from Los Angeles
Really great for such a cheap price, but if you are looking for an actual waterproof eyeliner, this would not be for you. It works great but is not waterproof
OK PRODUCT 3
Retired from La Crosse, WI
I use eye liner every day and this is ok- it is not as superfine as I would like or intense color but for the price it does what i need it to do !!
Easy to use 5
N/A from Clovis, CA
It's easy to apply and stays on all day.
Do not recommend 2
Desi from Beaumont, CA
The tip dries too quickly. I can't get the precision right without ruining it. If I don't get it done on the first swipe, forget it. When you try to go over it again to correct anything, it rubs off what you already did.
Good eyeliner 4
Onerymae01 from Brighton Colorado
This eyeliner goes on very precise and lasts for hours and hours. Really like it especially for the price!
no 3
skitso from Mississippi
still ran with my watery eyes
I would buy this again 3
Emma from TX
I like this eyeliner but I wouldn't say it's waterproof at all, also the felt tip is too long so it's kinda flimsy and can't be very precise. But it is super black. But for the price it's decent.
Dries out quickly 1
ash from md
If you're going to use this liner you beter hope you can get your liner right in under 10 seconds. After that the pen does more harm than good. When trying to do my liner I went back in to darken the line and the pen was so dry it erased my previous work.
Not the best 1
moonlindz from Texas
So it does have a fine tip which makes a pretty cat eye but it's not waterproof and if you accidentally touch your eye, it wipes away quickly. It's not jet black and looks more or like a light black/almost grayish color. I won't be buying again.
Not the best 2
stonloy18 from CA
Not the best goes on like it looks like its running out and definitely not water proof
accidentally got this 2
mnr from va
i meant to get the regular waterproof liner which is great but accidentally grabbed this and it's awful. i could only get one eye done before it was dry. the brush is nice and i was able to create a decent wing but just go with the not superfine liner and you'll be much happier
So Bad 1
JanaeE from California
Not waterproof, not opaque, dried out quickly.
Would not buy again!! 1
Jen from CA
Hate this product!!!
Really not great. 1
Cbrochu from OK
I have tried this twice, and it's more like a watercolor. I had to swipe several times to see anything. It's not waterproof at all.
waste of money 3
j from n
it came dry! not even 1 good use from it !
please take this off the site its not worth the money.
i has to use another eyeliner on top ... will never buy again and don't recommend it !
That's a no from me 2
Lenzielew85 from Peoria AZ
I've been looking for a liquid liner with a longer application tip (hopefully that makes sense) it helps me to line up my eyeliner easily. This was perfect in that aspect but, literally used it once and didn't work on the second eye! I thought maybe it was the eyeshadow underneath but, it didn't make a difference.
Dried up + Patchy 1
Amy from Miami, Florida
It came like dried up and it pisses me off because it's brand new. I thought I was the only one with this issue, but seeing that other people had the same problems means that the company messed up with their formulas.
Dry 3
Norma from Arizona
It seems like the ink doesn't travel all the way down to the tip therefore it's super patchy, I had to cut half of the tip for it to actually work. I had this eyeliner a while back and it was super juicy and awesome. They might of changed the packaging or formula
