Rated 3.97 out of 5 stars
Most Helpful Positive Review Excellent Quality Eyeliner
So far I own 6 of these Stila eyeliners & I love them! They are high quality, long lasting, easy to apply and stay on all day for me. I also love that they have many shades to choose from. My 3 favorites that I use right now are Damsel(very dark brown)Lionfish(bronze brown) and Stingray(black.)
I have seen reviews saying that they don't crank up and are broken, but I have not found this to be true. They are slow to start cranking up when you first use them, but keep slowing turning the base counterclockwise and they will come up. Just one important thing to note though is that they are not retractable as of yet, so be careful because once you crank them up they are not able to go back down.
I love mine and will continue to purchase!
Most Helpful Critical Review BIG DISAPPOINTMENT
It look amazing on the make up artist that recommended it to me, So me and my mom bought it instantly, then a week later she went to the doctor, and guess what?, the eye liner stopped her production of tears! then she tells me about it and I was feeling the same irritation in the morning after taking it of in the nights, like a cold sensation in the eye all day long. And the waterproof promise (not runny) was sad too 3 hours after I put it on, I had it all over my lids! I thought it was great but it just didn't worked out.
Reviewed by 2364 customers Yes ma'am...
TayHumble from Clarksville TN
I'm so in love with this eyeliner. I first received it in a BoxyCharm box. I would have never picked out a color like this on my own. I fell in love with it. It makes my green eyes pop without the harshness of a black pencil. It goes on so smooth. It's pricey but I will pay it over and over again. I love it.
No, Not This One.
MarSwit from Gilbert, Arizona
An Ulta sales associate recommended this pencil (normally I use Bare Minerals or Mac). My favorites were out of stock, so I bought it.
I am completely satisfied with this product!
Disney from Bismarck, ND
I love how easy application is -how well it remains in place - and how easily it removes when I decide it's time!
I will definitely buy this product again!
A happy camper from TX
As a long-time user of Smashbox's Always Sharp, I've been searching for a better liner. The Smashbox liner breaks easily and has begun to irritate my eyes. This liner is exactly what I've been looking for. Glides on smooth, can retract so the product doesn't break, and most importantly, doesn't irritate my eyes.
Emma from massachusetts
I have never used eyeliner before but this eyeliner is so good! It has a smooth/ creamy texture. I take a shower twice a day and the only down side is it takes a while for the eyeliner to come off because it is waterproof. Even makeup wipes its a little hard, but it stays exactly as if u had just put it on so it really is amazing! And once its on no smudging!
keithenia from fort walton beach
applies very well.
Amazing eye liner
Stephanie from Paulden, AZ
Goes on so smooth and perfect. Best eye liner I have ever used.
Have had better quality with one that costs $5.00
MomOfFive from Nevada
My daughter bought this for me for Christmas and after literally only using it three times, it is either out, or it's defective! This is way too expensive to have so many reviews about the very small amount you actually get and about it being defective. The only reason I gave it one star was because I like the color and how easy it goes on, but it definitely does not stay on. The girl who helped her made it sound like you need some special eye wash to take it off but by the end of the day, it disappears on its own.
Sandi A. from Chicagoland
The color is good and it goes on nicely. The tip stays pointy, better than most. Didn't smudge too badly and stayed on for hours.
The problem was the amount. It comes in a long stick and looks like a lot is in it, but I didn't use it very much before it was all gone, maybe 30 times at most. It would cost me over $20 a month. The MAC is a much better value and is at least as good except for the tip staying pointy. Value isn't really a goal with prestige cosmetics, but this was ridiculous.
I think I bought a DUD!
DebbieJ from IL
I have bought 3 of these now and I love how it stays on all day, but for being in a regular length container, it is only 3/4 an inch long so it gets used up real quick. Not worth the money for the amount you get. Others are at least 2 inches long on the stick itself. I am sure there are other brands that last long and give you more in the container.
Jeannie from Altoona, PA
This product is to be waterproof but did not stay on the water line and was starting to wear off the top lid by mid morning.
Chris from Buffalo ny
I love this eyeliner, but......
ChickFeed from Memphis TN
I love this eyeliner, I use the black and it is a true black, not a blue-black. You can smudge it a little before it dries, it stays on very well, and is not too difficult to remove with my eye makeup remover lotion. It does not leave any 'raccoon eyes'. The only issue I had was that either the container was broken after the first couple of twists or there was not much product in there. For the price, it did not last very long at all..... I'm talking about 2 weeks of daily use and I don't use much, just upper lid lash line. I will try this again and I hope it was just a one-time thing. I have tried this and the liquid lipstick and have been pleased with the quality of the brand so far.
Sorry but this is not waterproof for water line.
Linda from Westchester County NY
Used it for waterline under eyes and it was gone in an hour
My go to.
Sunshine from Florida
Love it works & lasts.
Kimi from At Paul mn
Everyday all seasons!
Best one I've found so far
legs from MT
Best I've found so far. Still some running when swimming, but not bad.
I love this
Carly d from maple shade nj
I pump gas in NJ and this will stay on my eye without smudging all day!
I would buy again
Possy from Nc
Love the product!
I have bought this again and again!
Momof1 from Charleston SC
I do not use this on my water line. I use on the top and bottom of eye lids. This is the only liner that stays on me. All of the others are gone by the end of the day. My only con?? There NEEDS to be more colors! ;D
Difficult to use
Not a decorator from Utah
Very difficult to apply; doesn't glide smoothly, and creates a jagged line on the eyelid.
I'm returning it 😡
Beene from Tampa, Florida
Used twice. Tip broken off. Will not ttwist up. Unusable 😡
Not sure about the negative reviews...
Chanel from Texas
I have been using this for years now. Lionfish is my favorite shade, since I have extremely fair skin, and some browns can be too light, but love this color and slight sheen it gives. It stays on all day and doesn't smear (even when I cry or have watery eyes). This usually last me 3 months and that is with daily use - not sure on some of the other reviews... been using for 5 years and will not use anything else!
This pencil gives too little product for the money.
Kristin from Detroit
There was barely any product in this pencil. Very disappointing.
love love it
kiki from roseville mn
i will only use this!!!