Rated 4.45 out of 5 stars
Most Helpful Positive Review The Best Eyeliner Ever
The best eyeliner I have ever used. My eyes get irritated easily, and this eyeliner does not irritate my eyes at all. It lasts and lasts and does not run or smudge. I hope that tarte never discontinues this gem.
Most Helpful Critical Review In a pinch...
Was headed to buy Urban Decay Inner Rim liner, when the gal at Ulta, told me she really liked Tart's Sex Kitten. So instead of just buying what I came there for, I caved and bought the Tart liner. I wanted liner specifically for the eye inner rim. It goes on nice and looks good...nice deep black color. It just didn't stay...at all. So I returned it and got the Urban Decay. As a side note, the Urban Decay was ok, but my niece uses MUFE XL liner and loves it, so I bought that today. It stays better than either the Tart or UD.
Reviewed by 177 customers Holy Grail Eyeliner
Mama P from Alabama
This eyeliner is my holy grail black eyeliner for the waterline. It last all day, which I need. It withstands the tears produced by my contacts. Excellent product!
Allie from Dallas, TX
This goes on so smooth, very pigmented, and does not move, even in the waterline. I wear contacts and getting eyeliner on my contacts from my waterline used to be daily before I found this eyeliner. This is the best eyeliner ever and I always have extras in my drawer because I know I will never change this staple in my makeup bag. Just buy it now. You won't regret it
Goes on smooth!
Steff in Saint Paul from Minnesota
Bought this for the second time - this is a favorite of mine because it's easy for every day wear.
I would buy this product again. Although it does smear.
M from Arizona
I've said it all above.
Super black & stays in waterline
Kymmie87 from Mountain Home, AR
I use this eyeliner on my waterline. It stays in place and doesn't turn into raccoon eyes!! Love it!
Terri from Dalton Ga
I have bought this kind since,Ulta opened up in my town.It was always perfect,but this time I'm very disappointed. When I started using the new this time it started breaking in about 2 wks I had already threw one in the garage.I bought 2 at a time the 2nd one is not far from being thrown in the garage. I will never buy this kind again. I was ripped off
Clarissa from Minneapolis
I prefer the pen, felt tip liners, so this didn't do it for me.
snacks from Ohio
After reading the reviews, I decided to give it a try. I have a dry eye that tears up and by the end of the day it looked like a watercolor around my eye. I gave it to my 16 year old and she gave it back because it smeared. Ulta was great about refunding it. I will stick with roller lash. it goes on great and never runs.
janesays from Queens, NY
I know there are always mixed reviews when it comes to eye makeup in particular, as people have different sensitivities and skin issues specific to their eyes. I've tried pretty much most eyeliners on the market, from high end to drugstore, and this one works best for me in terms of texture and longevity (as far as non-liquid liners go). I have gone swimming with it on and have accidentally fallen asleep without taking it off, and it doesn't smudge or fade. I also have sensitive skin and eyes, and I've never had a reaction to this eyeliner. Tarte is also cruelty-free, which is important to me. I would definitely recommend it to anyone. (Note: I'm not as much of a fan of the liquid version of Sex Kitten since I've found that it flakes; I prefer KVD or Stila.)
Best eyeliner I've ever used
Dog lover from Ft Wayne, IN
I have used this product for quite some time. It's the best eyeliner I believe I've ever used. It stays on. Easy to apply.
Riah from South bend
It is a good eye liner but my eyes water so much and I've been on a search for waterproof eyeliner and I've been using this for about a year and it's just not it.
This is great eyeliner for sensitive eyes
Debbie from Riverview, FL
I've bought this eyeliner several times as it's great for my sensitive eyes. Just wish Ulta would carry more than 1 at a time so I can buy more than 1 without having to go online or come back. Inventory management would help.
THE BEST KOHL LINER OUT THERE!
Kimmyandco from Newport, RI
As far as kohl liners go, this one is TOP-NOTCH! It is super smooth and easy to apply- no snagging or skips, and it holds up and stays put better than any other kohl liner I've come across yet (which says a lot, as i am an eyeliner aficionado and have tried literally hundreds) My new everday eye is Too Faced's Better Than Sex marker liner at lashbase of top lid, TARTE's Sex Kitten retractable pencil at lashline underneath, finished off with T.F.'s BTS mascara- i don't see topping that!
Only eyeliner I use
Shelly from Crossville, Tn
I have been using this product for a few years now. Only brand I will use.
I would not buy this again
Pisces.7 from M-F, OR
Looks nice when you first apply it, but doesn't last long, it smudges below my lower lashes, and not waterproof.
I hope they never stop making this!
Stephanie from Houston, TX
I use this daily and love it! It has great coverage and goes on smooth. This is now 1000% my go to eyeliner.
I would definitely buy this again
Carol from Thomaston GA
This eyeliner is really smooth and lasts all day
My favorite eyeliner
Kate from Dover, Ohio
Perfectly add the small amount needed to make eyes pop
Easy peasy to apply!
MK from California
I'm a no frills makeup wearer. This liner is easy to apply, stays on, and removes easily. I'm in my 40's and only started wearing eyeliner about four years ago. This liquid liner has been the best and easiest to apply.
Good but tends to bleed a little
Deana from Springboro, OH
I'm very picky about my eyeliners b/c most products don't stay on my eyes. They bleed out or smudge too much. This one does pretty well on my upper inner lid. But doesn't stay well on my lower line. i had to wipe under my eyes several times during the day b/c it had smudged down.
Doesnt last long
Shell from Wisconsin
I was looking for a highlighter that went on easy and lasted throughout the day.
My go to
Brooke from Cincinnati
This is my go to. I don't use or like anything else. Easy to apply and looks great. Last forever!! It can be sometimes challenging to take off completely, but that's what makes it a true all day waterproof wear.
Dmarie from Lewiston
Goes on smooth, great application and the other end of the pen allows you to smudge/sharpen your look.
I would buy this product forever
N/a from Ny
Love this, will buy bigger size and only use this product go
Great eyeliner! Goes on smooth
Sandy from Maryland
Love this eyeliner, goes on smooth, lasts well! Very little smudging.