Rated 3.96 out of 5 stars
Most Helpful Positive Review Excellent Quality Eyeliner
So far I own 6 of these Stila eyeliners & I love them! They are high quality, long lasting, easy to apply and stay on all day for me. I also love that they have many shades to choose from. My 3 favorites that I use right now are Damsel(very dark brown)Lionfish(bronze brown) and Stingray(black.)
I have seen reviews saying that they don't crank up and are broken, but I have not found this to be true. They are slow to start cranking up when you first use them, but keep slowing turning the base counterclockwise and they will come up. Just one important thing to note though is that they are not retractable as of yet, so be careful because once you crank them up they are not able to go back down.
I love mine and will continue to purchase!
Most Helpful Critical Review BIG DISAPPOINTMENT
It look amazing on the make up artist that recommended it to me, So me and my mom bought it instantly, then a week later she went to the doctor, and guess what?, the eye liner stopped her production of tears! then she tells me about it and I was feeling the same irritation in the morning after taking it of in the nights, like a cold sensation in the eye all day long. And the waterproof promise (not runny) was sad too 3 hours after I put it on, I had it all over my lids! I thought it was great but it just didn't worked out.
Reviewed by 2385 customers It really does stay put
Suzie from Schenectady NY
Easy to use. No sharpener needed.
I love this eye pencil. The perfect color for me.
Tootsie from Montgomery, Texas
I use this pencil to underline my eyes. Perfect for me.
Smudge Proof Definitely !
Star757 from Virginia
I love it It stayed beautiful all day long I love the rich colors
Stila has it right with this product.
Love these liners
Dr. Mary from WI
Smooth liner for top and bottom lid, or just bottom if I'm wearing lashes.
The best liner ever…. Goes on soo smooth and stays on!
Penny from Chelsea, MI
Doesn't smear. Stays all day
Melody from SC
I am so messy with liquid eyeliner. This one applies smooth like liquid but with more control. The faint sparkle really adds glamor to this product!
Courtney from Maine
Unfortunately this dried out shortly after I bought it and had to throw it out and wouldn't twist so I could attempt to use more. This is the first product by STILA that I have been disappointed in.
I really like this but for some reason it won't twist more
Gina from Nj
It's so easy to use and goes on smooth but there is not much in the pen
I will not buy this eyeliner again.
Dog mom from Dayton, Ohio
I bought this eyeliner today the color stingray which is the black one the blackest one. I was looking for eyeliner that wouldn't run and this eyeliner is what they recommended to me because I don't like liquid eyeliner and I don't like pencil so I brought it home and tried it and I put it on one time my eyes have not stopped watering and you can only use just what's out when you buy it you cannot twist up anymore so you would only be able to use this product maybe five times if that which I seriously doubt you couldn't even do that
II would never buy this product again.....
Marcy from Kahului, Hi. 9673#
The liner was dried out. Looks to be old. When u put it on it pull and very little color comes out. I threw away the receipt so couldn't return it. Very disappointed with the product....what waste of my money. Don't think I want to go back to ULTA formakeup
I would give it zero stars if I could
Alison from Chandler, AZ
I used this once and the twist part to raise the liner doesn't work. Trash product and huge waste of money.
Stays on all day.
Wrendy from Oklahoma
This is a great liner, but I don't use on my eyes. I buy the color Jasper for a lip liner and it works perfect.
Lasts 5 wears
maya from New York, NY
New to eyeliner and thought this would be great to start with. I do very thin lines and only used this for my waterline. The product is down to a nub after using it only 4-5 times. Never dropped or lost product anything. Don't buy if you want to use it more than a week.
Would buy this again
Jeanie Beanie from Fredericksburg, VA
I use it daily for work and into the evening.
ash from new york
not worth it product is good but the pencil mechanisim doesnt work. its broken after one use. just buy drug store
Giftygirl from Akron, OH
I was excited to try this after reading the great reviews. I'm extremely disappointed at it's claim to "stay all day". It stayed for maybe, 3 hours. The color on my top lid bled all the way up, which resulted in a greasy gray sheen. Not worth the high end price.
Best eyeliner ever
Rosie from Michigan
Stayton all day
Shopper from CA
Stila products are great! I love this eyeliner; use it on the bottom lid and it stays.
Not for waterline use with contacts
Nearsighted Nelly from Massachusetts
This eyeliner is trash. I felt compelled to come write a review on this garbage after literally going through a weeks worth of daily contacts in a three hour period. The culprit- this hot pile of garbage eyeliner that says waterproof and is recommended for use in water line.
After putting this on this morning I started doing the one eyed wink about 20 minutes into my work day. Ok, fine- sometimes you get a dud contact no big deal... flash forward to seven (!!!!) contacts later and I have my glasses on because I can't bring myself to waste any more.
The eyeliner, although it has long worn off, is still pooling around in my eyeballs and trying to find its way out of my eyes. Let me also state for the record that I am very skilled with makeup, and I cannot stress enough that I do a thin line in my waterline, nothing more than a very light coating. With the contacts it found a way to sit directly on top in the center where I couldn't see it with a mirror to try and trouble shoot- no it went for the complete annihilation of all contacts and my vision.
If this review saves even one of my nearsighted sisters, I have done my job. This stuff is absolute garbage
GOODBYE RACCOON EYES
Hannah from Wisconsin
I really like this eyeliner. I bought in color spice. For comparison, I have been using revlon colorstay in expresso. I use eyeliner primarily on my top waterline and was over my revlon stick fading into the inner and outer corner of my eyes within 2 hours, making me look like a raccoon. I asked the ulta technician to help me find an upgrade and she suggested this. I just used it for the first time on my top waterline and it has stayed put for a 12 hour nursing shift! No raccoon eyes!! This is the first "higher end" eyeliner I've purchased so I'm not sure yet if the price seems fair for the amount of product/how long it lasts.
Kelly from Ohio
No better than drug store liner
TayHumble from Clarksville TN
I'm so in love with this eyeliner. I first received it in a BoxyCharm box. I would have never picked out a color like this on my own. I fell in love with it. It makes my green eyes pop without the harshness of a black pencil. It goes on so smooth. It's pricey but I will pay it over and over again. I love it.
No, Not This One.
MarSwit from Gilbert, Arizona
An Ulta sales associate recommended this pencil (normally I use Bare Minerals or Mac). My favorites were out of stock, so I bought it.
I am completely satisfied with this product!
Disney from Bismarck, ND
I love how easy application is -how well it remains in place - and how easily it removes when I decide it's time!
I will definitely buy this product again!
A happy camper from TX
As a long-time user of Smashbox's Always Sharp, I've been searching for a better liner. The Smashbox liner breaks easily and has begun to irritate my eyes. This liner is exactly what I've been looking for. Glides on smooth, can retract so the product doesn't break, and most importantly, doesn't irritate my eyes.