Rated 3.95 out of 5 stars
Most Helpful Positive Review Excellent Quality Eyeliner
So far I own 6 of these Stila eyeliners & I love them! They are high quality, long lasting, easy to apply and stay on all day for me. I also love that they have many shades to choose from. My 3 favorites that I use right now are Damsel(very dark brown)Lionfish(bronze brown) and Stingray(black.)
I have seen reviews saying that they don't crank up and are broken, but I have not found this to be true. They are slow to start cranking up when you first use them, but keep slowing turning the base counterclockwise and they will come up. Just one important thing to note though is that they are not retractable as of yet, so be careful because once you crank them up they are not able to go back down.
I love mine and will continue to purchase!
Most Helpful Critical Review BIG DISAPPOINTMENT
It look amazing on the make up artist that recommended it to me, So me and my mom bought it instantly, then a week later she went to the doctor, and guess what?, the eye liner stopped her production of tears! then she tells me about it and I was feeling the same irritation in the morning after taking it of in the nights, like a cold sensation in the eye all day long. And the waterproof promise (not runny) was sad too 3 hours after I put it on, I had it all over my lids! I thought it was great but it just didn't worked out.
Reviewed by 2405 customers Great product
Barb from Idaho Falls, I'd
Works beautifully but I have only had mine for approximately 10 days. I use it once a day sparingly and it is almost gone. I cannot extend the lead out any further. I feel it should last longer than a couple of weeks. Other than that it works really well.
Mary from NJ
Got this as part of the sale. It was one of the few things I was excited about.
I use this on my waterline and it's all over my bottom lid within 5 minutes. Honestly, probably within 2 blinks. I've tried cleaning it up after it "dried" but it still continued to transfer throughout the day. It did glide on smoothly but took a few swipes. Hopefully I can return this. Don't buy it for your waterline.
I am returning this eyeliner....
Heidi from Arizona
Within an hour of applying this rye liner, it melted under my eye. I also bought one as a gift for my daughter & the happened to her. I will be returning both. Very disappointed, as I know Stila has great products...just not this one. I'll stick with Urban Decay liners.
I dig it
FlipNpattY from Arizona
This eyeliner is truly no budge. This is up there with the Marc Jacobs highliner, which I needed a replacement for since it's discontinued 😞. I will definitely buy more colors.
Great color wish stayed longer
Jules from PA
This color is gorgeous!!! So perfect for fall! Just wish it would last a little longer on the waterline. Seems to fade pretty fast!
Ash from Salem, Oregon
I bought this when it was 50 percent off and good job I did because I feel like other liners work just as good for cheaper. I did like how it glides on easily. I was surprised that it stayed on for hours without smudging. The reason why I gave 3 stars is because it doesn't work when I twist it up and down. I don't know if I broke it or what? And it's dull on the tip for making cat-eye. I'm going to try to sharpen it. Probably stick with UD liners.
Would not buy again
Ali from Rancho Cucamonga
This is not smudge proof!! I got four different colors since they were on sell. Tried them all and hours after they have had time to "set" still smudge and get transfer. Colors aren't as vivid as I would have liked either. So disappointed ☹️
I Wish I Could Love It
Stouffia from Rockaway, NJ
I love the color of this liner but it is not waterproof and smudge stick is exactly what it is. Not long after I applied it it was already smudged beneath my eye and I hadn't left the house yet. Too bad I really wanted this color in this liner to work.
Courtney from United States
The green is so pretty! Really easy to apply. The only reason why it's a 4 star is because it doesn't stay on for a full day.
Issa from South Florida
I don't know what anyone sees in these. I bought multiple colors and returned them all.
Love this liner
Dee from Pittsburgh
Use it to line your eyes. It lasts and doesn't smudge
I would not buy this product again.
Angel eyes from MI
I gave this product 1 star because it did stay on but it really was difficult to apply. It was on sale so maybe i got a bad batch!
I am miserable.
Sam from Tennessee
This was recommended to me by the Ulta salesman. I normally use IT No Tug or Smashbox Gel Eyeliner. I needed a color those brands didn't offer so he directed me to this with big promises. NO. NO. NO. I am sitting in my office at work and have been trying to do work on my computer and process forms and whatnot and I can barely see straight!!! My eyes are burning, watering, and blurry. I went to the restroom around an hour after I got to work this morning and the eyeliner had smudged all underneath my eyes, it's running down the sides from the corners of my eyes as well. I didn't even get to put this in my waterline because it wouldn't go on and I don't have a watery eye issue normally. I have no allergies and no issue with other brands, even dirt cheap ones. My eye makeup is going to progressively get worse while I'm at work for the entire rest of the day and my eyes are watery and I can't see straight. I am so beyond disappointed in this eyeliner and will be returning it the second I'm off work. I've had better luck with Wet n Wild in my teen years. Good grief.
Does not stay on
Nicole from 08062
This eyeliner smudges and transfers to my eyelids. Won't buy again.
I have tried so many brands and this is, by far, the best!
Pidge from Aurora, CO
Easy to apply and stays on all day!
I would definitely buy this eyeliner again
Mary from New jersey
I use it for work all day and it doesnt smear im very happy with it
I love it. Need it in all colors!!
Plain Kim from Memphis TN
Loving this eyeliner. Its pricey but worth it!!
Nice, but with a big but!
ALPS from Clifton,NJ
I really love the color and the application, but it wears off on me rather quickly. I do have watery eyes, however
Smudges On Me
Vero from California
Unfortunately the eyeliner did not stay on my eyelids for long. I have oily skin so it transferred to my eyelid. Not recommended for oily skin folks.
Perfect eye pencil
Shircas from Puyallup WA
Only pencil I buy
It really does stay put
Suzie from Schenectady NY
Easy to use. No sharpener needed.
I love this eye pencil. The perfect color for me.
Tootsie from Montgomery, Texas
I use this pencil to underline my eyes. Perfect for me.
Smudge Proof Definitely !
Star757 from Virginia
I love it It stayed beautiful all day long I love the rich colors
Stila has it right with this product.
Love these liners
Dr. Mary from WI
Smooth liner for top and bottom lid, or just bottom if I'm wearing lashes.
The best liner ever…. Goes on soo smooth and stays on!
Penny from Chelsea, MI
Doesn't smear. Stays all day