Product Reviews Rated 4.02 out of 5 stars
731 Reviews
Most Helpful Positive Review Best liner pen ever!! I have been using this for years. Precise application the tip is so fine it goes exactly where you want it to. Dab a bit of color stay eye shadow over the top and I guarantee it will stay until you remove it!
Most Helpful Critical Review Would never buy this again I was applying this and a tear came out of my eye and the entire thing smudged everywhere. It ran down my face and got in my eyes. I swear you would have thought I was in a horror movie, crying black tears. I must say though that it was very easy removal, no need for make up remover and before my face turned into a freak show, the color was actually very nice.
Reviewed by 731 customers This is always a 5
jessicasoontobebrown from undisclosed
This is always a must have in my bag. It's crisp, the lines are straight, the it lasts forever. I have no complaints about this product at all and would definitely recommend trying. It's inexpensive and you can find it anywhere.
This liquid eye does 3
rebeccaroo from undisclosed
This liquid eye does the job, but it's not a favorite. When I used this product, I noticed it smudged more so than others I have and the applicator isn't the easiest for a precise winged eye. The price is very affordable which makes it a nice choice in terms of makeup available at a drug store. Not the worst, but not the best either. #makeup #liquideye #makeuplover #revlon #colorstay
Easy to apply and 5
alinecmoral from undisclosed
Easy to apply and deep color. My favorite from what I have tested so far. Long lasting.
I like how it's 3
memberbdd6f2 from undisclosed
I like how it's easy to glide on and how the pen lasts long. I don't think it waterproof because sometimes I noticed that during the day the eyeliner has seem to smudged. I don't think I would buy it again because I don't think this eyeliner lasts throughout the day.
I like the pens 5
karw1 from undisclosed
I like the pens to have a more straight line look and can make it as wide or narrow as you want! Lasts forever and doesn't smudge! Cheaper option that is a good product
I used the ColorStay 2
jrkdillon from undisclosed
I used the ColorStay product line pretty extensively back in the late 80's/early 90's and never had a problem however I have to assume the formulas for both the liquid eyeliner and the pencils has been changed in some way because the performance has gone completely downhill.
I really like the 5
ellenk29 from undisclosed
I really like the Revlon eye pen. I would like to have one. It is a really good producr
It works very good 5
alexisc218 from undisclosed
It works very good for a sharp point love it it is a good price not a was of money I would use it every day and buy it a lot not often but a lot 
It's nice and it 4
aesthetixx from undisclosed
It's nice and it has pigment but it does spread kinda easily!! It lasts kinda long! I would add a eye liner stamp for easy application!
I have the Revlon 5
diyam7 from undisclosed
I have the Revlon Liquid Eye Pen with the cat eye stencil, and I absolutely love it! The liquid aspect provides for a deep, black, liner to enhance your eyes and it is fairly easy to apply. The liner is long lasting and doesn't fade, though it does smear if you rub the liner.
Seems a little thin 4
kristent5d37 from undisclosed
Seems a little thin as far as liquid, so cannot get super thick lines. Like the mechanism / delivery of the liner, and think it has a nice color. Was relatively inexpensive, so do not expect perfection. No big complaints.
I really like this 5
fernandaheimlich from undisclosed
I really like this eyeliner because I find it easy to apply because it's a pen! also its color is very strong and it doesn't stain when I use it! good durability and good cost-effectiveness
I absolutely love these 5
lucyyams from undisclosed
I absolutely love these liquid eye pens for the perfect wing! I've been getting the perfect wing since middle school thanks to these.
Great for under eye 4
raniah8 from undisclosed
Great for under eye , love the affect of the pointy head helps draw the line smoothly
Doesn't glide well and runs out of liquid fast 1
MM from Wichit, ks
Dries out as you use it
My favorite waterproof liner but... 5
AlySan from Nashville, TN
Need to know: if you buy this in the store, there are three different tips. You don't know until you know. I've, unknowingly, purchased the point with the edge and I didn't like it at all. I have no desire for a point with a ball on the tip. That said, this one is easy for line control and to create a beautiful cat-eye with.
Nice pen and easy 5
klovesbeauty11 from undisclosed
Nice pen and easy to use! I like to use it when I want a more dramatic eyeliner look. The pen is easy to hold and steady. I like how pointy the tip is too so it is more precise and not such a thick line when applied. I would recommend this product if you like a nice liquid eyeliner pen.
I have been using 4
littleraindrops from undisclosed
I have been using this for a long time! It's my all time favourite, I keep going back to it! Sometimes it does dry out but that's probably my fault with storing it. Yes recommend it!
I have been using 4
snehas34 from undisclosed
I have been using this for a long time! It's my all time favourite, I keep going back to it! Sometimes it does dry out but that's probably my fault with storing it. Yes recommend it!
disappointed 2
kimberly from USA
Product wear is really nice, however I literally just opened the box and it's dried out before I could finish my second eye. :( my bp made me throw this pen across the room in rage
These are the only 5
mcecchi from undisclosed
These are the only eyeliners I will use. They go on so smoothly, they don't smear and the tip of the eyeliner never seems to wear down. Is always like new.
Very disappointed 1
LoriWise from London ontario
Package said waterproof but it's far from it. Wore it for 5 hours and it was a mess and all smudged at the outer corner of my eyes. Waste of money
This starts out great 4
ohlivvy from undisclosed
This starts out great but does dry or seem to come out and have less product much more quickly than I anticipated. It tends to get a little dry and flakey towards the end too. Still, the first few weeks are worth it.
Best Affordable Waterproof Black Eyeliner 5
Panda from MD
I do wing eyeliner for my everyday look. So I am always on a hunt for good black waterproof eyeliner. This one is one of the best I ever found. It is so dark and go on easily even over glitter and metallic eyeshadow. I am using the third one now.
I'm gonna be honest, 5
arianedlp from undisclosed
I'm gonna be honest, I am not good at using that but I like the shape of this one and also how dark the color is. It definitely stays on your skin and the fact that it is a pen makes my life so much easier.