Product Reviews Rated 3.56 out of 5 stars
36 Reviews
Most Helpful Positive Review Use it as an eye primer I use these sticks as eye primers! When I want a bright colored makeup, I use the white ones; otherwise, for smoky eyes, i like to use the black one. I saw similar product on Youtube and saw that many beauty Youtubers use them as primers which i thought, these are very convenient and multi-functional. No lie, i have most of these colors in my makeup kit. This is a product that I can't live without.
Most Helpful Critical Review never again I don't understand how this has any stars. First it immediately runs and smudges EVERYWHERE! Then it melts off your face and leaves you looking like a raccoon. Worst product I've tried in a while. I've tried this as eyeliner and in my water line and immediately after application I had to pretty much redo my eye makeup because of how terrible this product was.
Reviewed by 36 customers The white is awesome 4
Boo from Vegas
I love the white color for my face but the colored ones suck on Youre eyes
Wish I loved this 2
Boo from Vegas
The pink & blue ones are super oily & creases in my eyes immediately. Even with eye primer
Nice eye pencil/color 4
Lainer from Albuquerque, New Mexico
I like how this shade brightens up my eyelids. Nice color and ingredients don't bother my eyes. It tends to crease a bit and I have to blend it a bit later in the day.
disappointed with formula :( 2
vic from Cairo Ga
it wouldn't stay in place on my lids for more than a few seconds
Allergic reaction 1
Eileen from El Paso
I was excited to try this pencil in coffee expresso. It was easy to apply and blend. However, it clumps. The worse part for me was the redness, the itch and puffiness of my eyelids… it literally burned my skin after a couple of hours of use. Two days after I tried this, I'm still in pain. For obvious reasons, I won't buy again.
Love truffle 4
BeccaMS from Brandon, MS
I use the truffle around my whole eye and it makes my eyes look bright and glowy. It's like a rose gold color. The pencil is really soft so I use a brush to apply. It doesn't have the best staying power so use a primer or setting spray, but really at this price I don't think that's a big deal.
Not good 1
Ariel from Texas
My sister bought this because she has been wanting a white eyeliner to put on her waterline. She claims that it burns really bad and it made her eye swollen. Pls don't buy.
A new fav 5
Ash from New York
I'm obsessed with this eye pencil. I have it in white and it makes my eyes look bigger when I put it in my water line.
I wanted a white eyeliner for my waterline, way too creamy 1
Melia from Bedford, NY
So I wanted to try a white liner for my waterline (for a bigger eye look) and this stuff hardly could even get onto my waterline, let alone stay in place. I blinked once and it was on my lashes. Don't get this instead of a pencil
A Great, Multi Use Crayon! 4
Attila The Shopper from Erlanger, Kentucky
I use the colour Marshmallow as both a primer and an eye colour. It's easy to blend, and it's highly pigmented, but it has little staying power without a setting spray or setting powder of some kind. It unfortunately doesn't stay on well in the heat. Still, as inexpensive as it is, it's worth the money and effort.
Mold and very soft 1
JusticeK from Washington
I bought 4 different colors,
I used the silver one and it was very soft and after wearing for about 2 minutes it started clumping and coming off.
I tried the Rocky Pinky and the tip came right off.
The Vanilla sky unused and molded.
I didn't even bother with the Violent one.
These came in the mail 2 days before I tried using them so they weren't even old. Very unhappy with my purchase.
Unfortunately my local stores tried to rip me off when I make returns of exchange's
A New Favourite! 5
Attila The Shopper from Erlanger, Kentucky
I use these as an eye shadow and eye liner, and the white pencil is a great primer! The white pencil really intensifies any eyeshadow and makes it pop! These are of a spectacular quality, especially for the price! Be sure to use a quality setting spray of your choice with this product. I highly recommend this to anyone!
A New Favourite! 5
Attila The Shopper from Erlanger, Kentucky
Try one of these little ubiquitous eye pencils! I usually use those by NYX, but they were sold out of the ones I needed, and they also require a special sharpener, which resulted in the wasting of a good portion of the pencil. These only need a standard sharpener, and they last longer, not to mention they're cheaper. These are highly pigmented, and blend out well. The white pencil is a great primer, too! Use a good quality setting spray of your choice with this product. Try these today!
Love it! 5
Coll from NJ
Glides on smooth and creamy. Has staying power and pigmented. Got dark chocolate. Wish came in more colors. I have oily kids and no problems with this! Looks beautiful on. Not as dark as shown. Perfect shade.
Be aware 1
Anne from NYC
I just received mine in the mail. It was missing any plastic seal and looked previously opened. The entire tip of the stick was covered in white specks of mold. Very gross. Not sure if just my product or if old stock. I have another one coming so I guess I will find out soon! Dissapointing. Can't speak to actual product besides that.
very nice ! 4
danny from colorado
this product goes on smoothly and the pigment is good ! it does smear quite easily so be careful about that. other than that i would recommend !
Love this!! 5
Becca from Ms
This pencil is great! It's buildable so you can use just a little to give your eyes a natural glow or build it up to use as a shimmer eyeshadow. I have fair skin and this color is perfect
More of a red color 3
Melissa from WV
This has more of a dark red/rust color rather than dark chocolate. It's pretty but the color name is misleading.
Most colors work well, except for silver 4
Sarah from Virginia
I bought a half-dozen shades and all but one work well. They all go on smoothly with no issues. However, the silver shade isn't solid. It's mushy and it goes on clumpy from the first time I used it. Because of that, I'm already down to the bottom of the pencil in one month after only using it four times.
Staying power 5
Missy from Pennington NJ
I bought the 2 lighter nude shades (pink and light brown). I love them. Perfect if you want a polished look without glitter (ugh). I am 49 and this product blends nicely on my skin.
Really pretty ! 5
Alex from Charlotte, NC
I got the truffle shade and it's so pretty. Shimmery but not too overboard, you can build up if you want.
It looks amazing when I wear a no makeup makeup look. Prime eyes or it will crease.. otherwise sooo pretty! Will buy again !
its ok 4
sweet from indiana
the eyeliner/eyeshadow pencil goes on smooth, but seems to smear within a half hour. My eyes did sting a little bit and water after putting thisnon, and I do not have that problem when I use Ulta eyeshadow pencils. I decided to give this a shot as it was on sale. Me personally I would not purchase again. I gave it 4 stars because for the price ita good if you dont have sensitive skin or eyes.
Chocolate? 3
Sherry from Pennsylvania
The color when I first received it made me a bit nervous. I ordered Dark Chocolate, and it appears almost red in the pencil. It does look a lot more brown on the skin, thankfully! It's very oily, though, doesn't really stay in place, and is difficult to apply exactly where you want it. I want to use it as a top lid liner, but the point is just too thick. Maybe it is meant to be used as a shadow. I wouldn't buy it again.
I keep two of these pencils on hand... 5
Beliza from Wilmington, NC
I love the ease of these pencils and how they glide across your lid or on the lash line. In particular I use the white shade, Marshmallow in my lash line when I want the sclera to appear whiter or to look more awake.
Great product. Easy glide on. Good pigmentation 4
Susie-q from Citrus Heights
Great product
