Rated 4.39 out of 5 stars
Most Helpful Positive Review Great brow pencil
I have been using the Tarte a few years and I really love the brow pencil. I am very pale and my brows are next to nonexistent.
I love the brow pencils I can make dramatic brows for nights out and lighten my hand for everyday.
Totally easy application, nice fine point on the pencil.
Most Helpful Critical Review Lasted ONE week
It's a no for me. When applied, I really don't mind this brow pencil. It is nice and precise for natural hair-like strokes. The staying power is satisfactory - overall better than average I would say! Unfortunately there is just such a small amount of product that I will never repurchase this again. Since I have sparse brows I have a lot of "brow creating" to do, but at the same time, I don't fill in for "full" shaped eyebrows. I basically just outline my natural thin shape then fill in with natural strokes. My brows are still a slim shape once filled. I probably used this product for 5 applications and am down to no product left to twist up. I don't wear makeup every day, maybe every other day if that, since I'm a stay at home mom. One thing is that I have noticed that it's not just Tarte that has very little product in their retractable brow pencils. A lot of brands with the retractable packaging concept are the same way. For this reason I will never repurchase. If you use brow pencils for just an outline or filling in small gaps, this might work for you. I have a lot of space to create eyebrow in so I will stick to a pencil that I may have to sharpen myself, but lasts me 3 months.
Reviewed by 449 customers Do not like
Nadine from Valleysprings
I don't think I need a comment
Wish I had discovered this sooner!!!
Vannah from MO
I love it! I have used an UD brow pencil for a few years now and I did like it, but Ulta quit carrying it and I only shop Ulta, Nordy and my mes spa for beauty products, so I had to begin the search for a different brand/product, which leads me to this product! Yay! So good!!! I use several other Tarte products, so I was pleased to see they carry a brow pencil in the shade I prefer. I am a medium blonde with lighter blonde framing my face, so a taupe shade is always a safe color for my brows, but this taupe shade is literally perfection! Obsessed! Applies well and lasts with better ingredients than most. I will continue to purchase this product! Tarte wins again!!!
Pretty good but needs more product
Customer from California
I break out from other brow products only bc they have oil in it, but this one doesnt so i dont break out as much! And I love the consistency and how it stays on my eyebrows the entire day. The only con, and its the one that i care about the most, is that it only lasted me for about a month or two!! Which is rlly bad in my opinion considering the price. They need to put more product in one packaging.
I have bought this product again and again.
Lou from Asheville, N.C.
Already made my comments
Amanda from Florida
I've tried other brow pencils and this is by far my favorite one. I stopped trying other ones because I go back to this every time.
Starry from Katy Texas
Easy to use
Fav Eyebrow Pencil
HGood from Columbus, OH
Best eyebrow pencil I've ever used. Nice and thin pencil for easy and quick eyebrow fillings. The color is perfect, too.
Cindylourod from San Bernardino CA
It goes on nice and smooth. I love the way it makes my brows look😊
Love it. Stays on all day.
Lola from Cathedral City
I've tried a lot of brands, this one seems to be the best for me. I'm a Mom and a waitress, so makeup goes on about 5:30 a.m. and by the end of the day around 10:00 p.m. while the rest of the makeup has basically worn off for the most part. My eyebrows still look great.
astone from lakewood ca
the color is nice but it does come off easily and appling it difficult with oily skin types
Myrtle from Nc
I love this eyebrow pencil. It never budges.
100000000 i love love love this product
Naieema from Knoxville
I love this pencil. My eyebrow don't grow anymore due to years of waxing but this pencil has been a life saver. It's very natural and people can never tell that my eyebrows aren't real.
Tarts brow pencil
Carriecar from Oakdale, Ca
Only used it a few time seems to stay on all day
Would purchase again
The Perfect Brow Pencil
Sabrina.Lovely from Michigan
This is the only product I will use on my eyebrows. It's the only one I've found light enough to look natural, but that has buildable pigment so I can go a little darker at night. 10/10 application, very easy for beginners but still a knockout for seasoned makeup wearers. Feels light on the face, non-greasy, and very easy to fix mess ups while applying.
Finally found the right undertone
Becky is going cruelty free from St. Joseph, MI
I finally found a dark brown eyebrow pencil that doesn't have a red undertone to it. I'm trying to go cruelty free with all of my beauty products and none of the less expensive options had a cool undertone eyebrow pencil with a micro point. This pencil finally gave me what I was looking for! The only reason I didn't give it five stars was because of the price. Considering how often I go through eyebrow pencils this is going to be very costly for me.
Love this brow pencil
SEB01 from Knoxville, tn
I've fallen in love with this brow pencil. Nothing else compares. Such a good value and product.
Favorite Brow Liner
Cheska from Pgh, PA
One of my favorite eyebrow pencils, no complaints!
This did not work for me.
melynt from san antonio, tx
I wanted something that would stay all day until I washed it off, this did not work. I work out a lot and have somewhat oily skin but this just never stayed.
Love it butttt
Jessica from Fort Myers fl
Love this brow pencil stays on pretty well just wish the tip was a bit sharper although it is way better than some other brands hands down
Amazing from Texas
I found my holy grail!!!!
Thank you! Keep the product coming! Love!
Catnip from Marianna,fl.
Eye brows! Safe for those with allergies! No sulfate parables fragrances.
Chris from Az
Go's on smooth and looks great
Eye brows done easy
Enhancing1 from NC
Love this eye brow pencil. Goes on easy and lasts a long time without smudging. This with a clear eyebrow eyelash gel mascara and you are good to go. Natural looking brows that stay in place. I have naturally thin sparse brows and this works nice to create natural looking brows in places I really need it with out looking fake.
Favorite Eyebrow Pencil
Alissa from Grand Rapids, MI
I absolutely love this eyebrow pencil. The very fine tip makes for super easy, natural looking application. I can be flexible with how I apply it, whether I want a more natural look or more defined brow. Highly recommend! Only downside is it tends to run out fairly quickly. One pencil will probably last me 1-2 months depending on how often I use it.
Yes 100% yes
Ac26 from PA
I never used a brow pencil before for fear it would just look fake, BUT when I went to Ulta and had a makeover he showed me how to apply which was simple. The difference was amazing!