Rated 3.87 out of 5 stars
Most Helpful Positive Review Best waterline pencil liner EVER!!! Please don't stop making
The best liner for my upper and lower waterline EVER!!! My eyes get watery and oily. Other liners never stay on. They smudge off within minutes.
This liner stays on till I remove it the next day with my eyes makeup remover. This doesn't smudge on me.
Please always keep making this product!!! There's nothing like it out there for me. I won't be able to live without it.
Most Helpful Critical Review Another letdown by UD
I debated on buying this after being let down by their 27/7 eyeliner and lip liners. I ended up purchasing this in the color Street and while this did glide on very smoothly, it did take a couple of layers to really get the pigmentation. Unfortunately, after 3 hours, I can see that the pigmentation has faded quite a bit and the product has already worn off of the outer corners of both the top and bottom waterlines. In addition, it has also leaked/smudged in the outer corners of my eyes.
Overall, just another basic, overpriced eyeliner, that I would not recommend.
Reviewed by 1072 customers My favorite
heather from IN
Definitely my favorite eyeliner
emmabear from Oklahoma
I had so much hope for this eyeliner that I didn't mind paying over $20. This eyeliner ran and smeared all under my eyes! I tried it a few more times but same results! Everytime I ended up looking like a raccoon! I've had better luck with $8 eyeliner!
Would never buy again
Heather from Atlanta
If you wear contacts please don't try this. It does not stay on the waterline at all. It gets all over my contacts. There is nothing special about this at all. Not worth the money. Save yourself some money and buy something else.
I would never buy this again!
Kayla from Albuquerque
I've been looking for a really good eyeliner for the waterline and this was not for me. It doesn't go on smooth, it comes off within a couple hours of putting it on and then the tip broke off into the cap! Not worth the money at all.
Not as good as the Floor Helper said it is.
a working mom from TX
Well I went into Ulta because I was looking for an eyeliner that would not run or make it look like I have a black eye. This was recommended and I was told it would stay on the waterline and that it would be perfect. However......within 2 hours of wearing this I have have what looks like black eyes. So it really does not stay on like I was hoping.
cheryl from Macon Ga
Am. to Pm is a lot better
Best eyeliner!!!! Love it!!!!
Wandy from Orlando, FL
I have been looking all my life for a waterline liner that actually stays on all day, and doesn't smear to my lower eye area. I have oily skin and after an hour I always get raccoon eyes if I don't keep cleaning it. Let me tell you this one delivered it really stayed on all day without me having to fix it I'm in love. Will be using this for life!!!!! You just can't sharpen it too much because the tip tends to break off if its too out there. Bottom line I love it soooo much!!!!!
The Most Underrated Waterline Pencil.
Midwest Girl from Plainfield, IN
This is my holy grail waterline eyeliner. All other waterline eyeliners transfer on me but this one stays put all day. It is less creamy compared to the OG 24/7 eyeliner but I think that's why it stays put in the waterline so well. I do wish UD had maintained the color selection for the waterline pencil. The only selection is black. I would say if you are going to line the outer lid this is stiffer and not as easy to use so be mindful of the that but if you suffer from waterline fade or transfer this will be your saving grace!
Works great but will fade/smudge after longer wear.
Jon from Ocala,FL
This works great for the waterline on the eyes, however it didn't hold up as well as some of my other liners. It will start to smudge and fade after about 4-5 hours of wear. No big deal tho, I just retouched as needed throughout the day. If you're eyes tend to water from allergies I don't recommend this for you.
If you are looking for a nice bold liner for a night out then this works great!
No for me
StaciA from Dayton,Oh
Did not work at all on my waterline and this is a waterline eyeliner. Tried again after sharpening I still did not transfer any color on my waterline.
Absolutely love love love this!!
Trish from Arizona
Perfect and exactly what I was looking for! Every time I purchased eyeliner it ended up on the top of my eye lid this product doesn't do that and the color is perfect! Love love love!
I am not sure if I will purchase again.
McKenzue from Arlington, TN
I will return it to the store and see what the outcome is. Hopefully, it works out.
CoolCat from San Antonio, TX
An associate inside my Ulta recommended this product when I told her I was interested in an eye liner for my waterline. I took it home and put it on. Within an hour, it was almost all gone.
Definitely a must have in your makeup bag!
Jess from Bowling green Kentucky
I recommend this product if you don't like smudgy eyeliners, it's waterproof, doesn't smudge, great for sensitive eyes! I have no cons for this product!
Regret trying this product
Izzy from MD
I wish I had something positive about the product, but the only things I can think of are that the packaging is attractive, and the color was nice after being built up. I applied this product and it couldn't withstand an hour on my waterline. My first impression was that it looked promising, but I had to go over the waterline many times to get color, and then had to keep going over to get a nice pigment rather than a watery grey color. After I was satisfied with the color, I went out for an hour, and when I got back home, there was zero product left on the waterline. What product was left had bled to the sides of my eyes, so I looked like I was crying grey tears. It was a disaster. I really expected something better from Urban Decay, as I usually enjoy their products. I do have to add that paying over 20 dollars is a bit overpriced for an eye pencil, especially one that doesn't sharpen or twist out. I'm quite saddened by this turnout.
The Amazon from Lafayette, IN
I was really searching for an eyeliner that would show up well on my waterline and not take a ton of layering. This is it. It goes on easily and is very smooth. The only problem I've had with it is that it does smudge like crazy after a bit giving raccoon eyes. I did find that setting it with powder directly underneath it prevents that so it's no big deal to me now. Using eyeshadow directly on top also works to set it.
Wouldnt buy again
Janice from Mesa, AZ
Didnt go on easily , lacks dark coverage, doesn't last.
Not worth the price
Bootsthecat from Houston, TX
I love eyeliner and everything eyeliner. I've been trying to find one to use on my waterline. I heard about this one but jeez was it above my budget. I gave it a chance and I shouldn't have. It runs after around 3 hours and it looks like I didn't even put some on.
This is ok
Chickie from New York
this liner is suppose to be specifically for the waterline of the eye but it doesnt go on as full and smooth as i was looking for and i can see it spread under eye throughout the day
Possibly would purchase again, if there were improvements
Kelsey from Chico, ca
Needs to be self sharpening. The fine point the pencil comes with is perfect, but once you sharpen it with a sharpener it never works the same again. I end up wasting so much pencil trying to sharpen my pencils so they go on smoothly and do not have any sharp wooden edges.
THM from St. George UT
The best waterline eyeliner I've found so far. I would give it 5 stars except I prefer a black/brown color and Urban Decay stopped making that color.
Love this liner!
Angel with an A from Seabrook, NH
I love this all day wear, no smudge eyeliner!
Works but can fade
Aly from Arvada
The reviewers who are saying it doesnt glide on easy. Mine didnt right away either. I actually had to resharpen it a couple times now it goes on much easier and "glides on". It does kind of "fade" away on the bottom waterline. I haven't had this issue on the top waterline, you are able to see it on the bottom waterline just not as defined and the eyeliner would need to be reapplied but I am impressed with this product because it doesnt slide into my under eye part. I have tried every eyeliner in my 30 years and I have never been able to find a eyeliner that didnt give me raccoon eyes. This one works it may fade and need to be reapplied once or twice throughout a 12 hour day but it's well worth it in the fact that it doesnt give me raccoon eyes. I will buy again.
The water proof pencile lays on my water line so smooth
Say say from Concord
The water proof eye pencil is so nice and soft on my eyes 24 hour wear even thought the pencil says 12 hour ware I would buy it again for sure
Leigh from East Brady
I'm sad to say I expected so much more from this pricey 24/7 liner. It didn't last, gooping up at both the inner and outer corners of my waterline/tight line, not to mention it doesn't glide on smoothly/effortlessly at all. I get better and longer lasting coverage with much cheaper products!😪