Rated 4.24 out of 5 stars
Most Helpful Positive Review I am in LOVE
I had to order the black brown washable mascara because it was the only one left in stock, i usually use black waterproof in the Loreal Voluminous family. I couldn't wait to try it even though it wasn't exactly what i usually use. Imagine my surprise when i opened the box and got the black waterproof!! Its like it was meant to be!! Anyway...the component is so pretty, its such a perfect frosted pink with a gold band that says L'Oreal. I know that everyone is comparing it to the BTS but this is BETTER!! My lashes are so long and thick i have NEVER seen them like this before. There are no clumps AT ALL, they aren't sticking together and i used a LOT. This mascara actually makes my lashes look like fringe, its crazy. I hope Loreal makes this forever because this is the only mascara for me!!!! love Love LOVE!!! oh and as an aside, I've tried Dior, Chanel and a smattering of high end mascaras for three times the price and this one blows them all away it is just amazing. Is it made with unicorn tears, angel sweat, something magickal for sure...nothing else explains it. Btw, I ordered this on Amazon because it was the only site that had any in stock. Every Target store had sold out (in my area) and all the other stores - drug stores and specialty shops) hadn't gotten it in yet. I can't wait until its restocked i want to try the washable version just for fun.
Most Helpful Critical Review Great after a couple uses, then gets clumpy!!
I bought this two weeks ago along with the lash primer and I am so disappointed. This will now be my second tube of the same mascara that has done this. I wanted to love this so much but I can't if it just keeps clumping and drying out on me. I will not recommend this to anyone.
Reviewed by 1724 customers Favorite mascara
Brittany from Colorado Springs
This is one of my favorites next to the actual Better Than Sex brand
I would buy this product again
Oma from Florida
I put on extra coating when dressing up - does not look to thick
Danu from Texas
one of the best mascaras
LOVE this mascara
hj420 from Henderson, NV
great product at a great price. doesn't get flaky
Very waterproof, but hard to remove
Alyssa from NJ
I've been using this mascara for a while. I've gone through two tubes, but I don't think I'll be buying it again. This mascara is very waterproof. It's so waterproof that it's difficult to remove. The formula is also a little wet for my taste. It makes your lashes a bit hard and sticky, but it's nothing a spoolie brush can't fix. The color is a rich dark black. Overall, nice mascara for the price.
My favorite mascara!
Emily from North Attleboro, MA
This is my favorite mascara. No flaking, and it stays put. It can be a bit difficult to get off, but i use an eye makeup remover and it works great! Love this mascara for mask wearing because i know it will stay put.
Best mascara I've ever used!!
Kelly from New Hampshire
This is the perfect mascara. I have short, straight eyelashes but with this mascara they look incredibly long and keep their curl all day long. It is also buildable without getting clumped up. It looks like you are wearing falsies! I have used tons of other mascaras - including all the "holy grails" out there and this is far and away the best. I am only using this mascara from now on. Side note: use oil makeup remover. Water based will not cut it with this stuff.
Does NOT transfer!
Brea from Teays Valley, WV
This is the waterproof version. It does not smudge or transfer I love it
Raqui from Maryland
I love this stuff. It holds my stubborn lashes in a curl all day and is super waterproof - I can have a breakdown at work and afterward the only evidence is how puffy my eyes are. No streaks, smudges, or flakes, and my lashes are still curly! It adds a nice level of non-clumpy volume and length. Only con to this is that after a couple months of use, it does start to smudge on me. It's worth having to rebuy it more often though!
Won't repurchase-too basic for me
Donna from South El Monte, CA
This is an okay mascara, but it doesn't do anything dramatic at all-just very basic. It also is a little clumpy to me. I will say it's waterproof. It is extremely hard to remove. I will definitely be switching back to my Maybelline falsies push up mascara (the one in the red and pink). Now THAT mascara is worth every dime.
This is the best dupe for better than sex mascara.
Just another person who loved makeup 🥰 from Texas
If it doesn't give you the full lash and length you're looking for I recommend curling your lashes first and do 2-3 coats. 🤍
Qtpie from Usa
I love this mascara- it used to be my favorite
I would buy this product again and again
Jo from Mi
Great lengthening mascara, no clumps!! I bought 4 on a buy one get one 1/2 promotion. What a super deal.
High quality mascara
Sue from Omaha, Nebraska
I used this product as it gives visible results. Quality is high as any high-end product. Highly recommended!
Love this item...will purchase again
No lashes from Houston
Very smooth and does not go on clumpy
pataha from Washington State
I bought 2 for 1 price. Clumps, messy. I thought I got a bad mascara but the second one was just as bad. I will remember that pink tube and not purchase again. Both put in the trash. They need to rethink this product.
Samantha from Florence KY
Its okay, I wasn't impressed with it like I thought I would be. I mainly stick to L'Oréal mascara's and this one just didn't do it for me. Next
Great 'better than sex' mascara alternative
Bree from Kzoo
This is my favorite mascara! For me there is no smudging, tons of volume, my lashes stay up all day, and the price is amazing. For best effect use an eyelash curler, your lashes will be perfect. After I curl, them I Lightly start from the tip and brush up, and then go to the middle than tip, then root to tip. Then dry a Lil and continue building if needed.
!!Remove with makeup remover!!
In my opinion the regular version of this has nothing on the waterproof version.
Trust me on this one, I get complements all the time on my lashes!!
Frida from California
I have fairly long and heavy lashes. I've tried other waterproof mascaras and regular mascaras, but none have actually held my lashes up like this. It's tough to take off, but it shows that's it's fairly waterproof. I will say that it can dry out fairly quickly, hence the reason for the 4 out of 5 stars. Overall, this is my favorite mascara because it's the only one that works for lashes like mine!
I LOVE the formula, best mascara EVER
Andrea from Alameda, CA
I LOVE this mascara, it makes me feel so beautiful and I can't stop batting my eyelashes lol
Kourt from Arlington, TX
Best mascara I've ever tried!! Leaves my lashes looking voluminous and long!! Definitely can compare to high end mascara :)
Lashes stay curly w/ volume&length from Long Beach, CA
First off, my lashes are STRAIGHT as can be. Every single mascara I've tried has flopped them back to being straight after curling BUT NOT THIS ONE. Not only do they stay curly all day but the VOLUME & LENGTH 🙌🏽. And they really do feel feathery soft to the touch lol Girls this mascara is the MVP and I would never finish my look without it. 10/10 would definitely recommend 👌🏽 If you guys are worried about removing waterproof mascara, all I use is micellar water on a round cotton swab. I pour it on and hold it against my lashes for 30 seconds and gently wipe away. Super easy
Waterproof Version Smears
bree from CA
If you have super oily skin or wear any oil-based face makeup (eg: foundation, BB cream, concealer, etc) it WILL smear. I always get mascara smeared underneath my eyes. Otherwise, the formula is quite watery; I prefer the formula when it gets a little dried up after multiple uses, when it becones more creamy. By then, the mascara sticks onto the lash much better and makes my eyeslashes look more fluffy.
Cosmetic Queen from SC
One of my favs! love the waterproof formula, last all day. My lashes looks longer and fuller after using.
WHAT TOOK ME SO LONG
dz from MO
I have been dying to try this mascara since it debuted but kept receiving mascara samples and gifts and finally got around to trying it- WHAT WAS I WAITING FOR?? I love this! Gives me long feathery lashes and the color is black and beautiful. Ill buy it again and again