Product Reviews Rated 4.33 out of 5 stars
423 Reviews
Most Helpful Positive Review Amazing. I have been wearing this eyeliner for the past 6 years. I have traveled to Suriname, Guyana, India and Nepal and everywhere I have gone, women have asked me what do I do to my eyes to make them look as they do. Fluidline has to be the best eyeliner I have ever used. I have recommended this to so many people, MAC should give me commission!
I have worn this eyeliner swimming and in the humid hot summers of India and it has managed to stay on nearly perfect. It does not run, it tends to melt a little around your tear duct but with immense sweating in India's environment, this eyeliner definitely outlasted the others. I have never been afraid to wear this eyeliner- I know it will last no matter what type of environment I am in.
The colors are also the type that you can wear without fear of looking overly intense or underdone. You cannot go wrong with fluidline. It may be pricey for a tiny jar, but I wear this eyeliner EVERYDAY and I wear a healthy amount and it manages to last me up to 5months. MAC is also wonderful and has their recycling program so I never feel bad going through it the way I do.
It is worth the investment. The brush, 266, has lasted the 6 years that I have had it and ultimately everything pays for it self with all the compliments I get!
Most Helpful Critical Review Great product... Until it dried! :( When I first used it... AMAZING. Perfect precision line for brows with my MAC 266 brush. HOWEVER, after some time the product dried and was incredibly flaky. I visited the MAC counter and was told to try mixing with an oil (olive oil, coconut oil, etc.) This method worked OK, but was too much of a hassle for me. It's really unfortunate because the product is PERFECT when the consistency is normal. When/IF you buy, make sure to keep a closed (tight!) lid. :)
Reviewed by 423 customers Easy wears off 2
Jlee from All over
Easy to put on, creamy more then gel texture, This was upsetting to see it wearing off throughout the day,
So far, so good 5
Tory B from Sherwood, AR
I've been using brown eye shadows with an angled brush for years to do my cat wing. I just feel most comfortable using that tool. However the eye shadow just doesn't stay all day, and I wanted something more durable. This lasted 14 hours and a couple of cries.. because 2020. By then, it was starting to fade, but not much! Very pleased.
Takes time to learn 3
Emily from Richmond va
This product is not for beginners. It can be opaque and very beautiful once you learn how to use it, but without the correct brush your line will be THICK. I have hooded lids and it doesn't transfer to my top lid like other liners have, but I still wouldn't recommend this product to my friends.
Stays on 4
KT from UT
I love this eyeliner gel. most eyeliners tend to melt off my eyes. This one stays on most of the day. If I use a eye primer, it stays on all day. Please bring back blitz and glitz. It is my all time favorite! It is dark but not as harsh as plain black.
Simply the best 5
Laura from Corona CA
Long, long, long wearing eye liner.
I have honestly worn it for 24 hours while traveling.
Creamy and easy to use, I have been using this product for over 10 years.
i wasn't sure 4
lulu from SF
i was concerened that a " gel " would be see thru, and not stay on as i wanted. well, it took awhile to get the result i like. it dries fast, doesn't apply with sweeping strokes, and wasn't as smooth as i'm used to. however, i stuck with it and found that if i used quick short strokes, i could get a very thin, very opaque, very long lasting line close to my lashes. it took several days of getting used to, but i am now quite happy with this eye liner. just be ready to play with the pot, use a very thin brush ( i think ), and throw out the manner in which you usually apply your eye liner. adapt, and voila !
Great 5
Sona from CA
Long lasting, easy to blend/smudge for natural look. Easy to control the amount of application on brows. Will definitely get this one again.
Best eyeliner I've every used 5
Lauren from SouthlakeTX
Love this product! I can stop searching for the perfect eyeliner now. I have found it. I also love that it is in a glass container.
Only Eyeliner I Buy 5
Roni793 from Kahului, HI
I was turned on to this eyeliner years ago. I absolutely love it. Looks great ... Easy to apply ... Stays in place. Love Mac brushes also.
So so product 3
Mary from MN
I wanted to like this product more than I did. It is really creamy and goes on smoothly which is great but the pigment wasn't as dark as I was hoping and also wound up all over my lid midway through the day. Ehhh, only okay.
AWFUL! 1
GabbyP from Tampa, FL
Just don't buy this. I'll stick to my NYX Epic liner because this was just awful. Used the MAC 2083 eyeliner brush to apply- it was a mess! The color would be pigmented in one area and then see through on another. Returned immediately. Seriously don't bother.
no 2
Delia from AZ
I use a thin eyeliner brush to create a very mild winged eye. I pigment is dull.
Terrible for oily skin 2
TR from Seattle
This melts and smudges before lunch… Very disappointed!
Pretty cool 5
Amy from Omaha
I like applying eyeliner this way. Good color. Long lasting
New Favorite 5
Jen from Carmel, IN
This product was recommended to me and I'm so glad it was! I've used and been a fan of pot eyeliner for years now, but this is by far the best one I've ever used. Top of the line.
Smooth Gel when new 4
Gray Lady from Amarillo, Tx
One of the best gel liners I have used. The down side is when it is about half gone it starts to clump. I learned that you can put a few drops of saline spray and it will extend the life for a little bit longer.
Love 5
Something old but not broken from Richmind
Been using this eyeliner since I can ever remember and I can't switch brands! Just love it
I use this to fill in my liner 5
Beckysee13 from Moreno Valley, CA.
I recently started tracing out my wing with a liner pen and filling it in with a pot gel instead of drawing it all together. I find I have more control for cleaner crisper lines like this and this fluidline is a beautiful filler. Yeah. I'm buying this again.
First time purchase and will again 5
Rose L from Newington CT
I like this because it glides on and no pulling of eyelid.
eyeliner 3
Deb from home
can you use on your waterline
Amazing! 5
Looloo from Illinois
I have watery eyes and no eye liner from any brand would stay on. Not only does this stay on all day, but it glides on perfectly!
Dipdown is Perfect Dark Brown 5
Josette from Virginia
It really stays put all day and I apply it with a fine eyeliner brush. The only eyeliner other than the Urban Decay pencils that I've bought repeatedly. This shade suits my brown eyes and light yellow toned skin.
You took away my favorite color! 4
Slkchicky from Virginia
This eyeliner is great! It stays on and does not smudge. The only one I like. The only complaint I have is they stopped making my favorite color - Waveline Blue! It was beautiful and really made your eyes stand out. Very disappointed.
AMAZING! 5
Dana from Naperville, IL
Still so in love with this gel liner. I've been using it for 15+ years and it never disappoints. I agree the pot does get dried up after some time though, but if you're using it daily, it's gone before it dries. SO sad that first Rich Ground is gone and now Deliciously Rich. The colors left are just not shimmery :(.
I love this 5
A.dot from Maryland
I have been wearing this for at least 10 years and will not change. It does not smudge, stays on all day. I was a collegiate swimmer and it would stay on after lifting/sweating for 2 hours and swimming for another 2.
