Product Reviews Rated 4.02 out of 5 stars
9618 Reviews
Most Helpful Positive Review A true long lasting lip color I've been using the new superstay24 lip colors in Keep up the flame and constant toast for a little over a month now and LOVE them! This liquid lip color is a true long lasting lipstick that won't come off on your straws or cups when you need a little sip, it won't come off on your babies forehead when you give it a little kiss and it won't be needing 100 applications a day . It's easy to apply and applies evenly, please don't rub your lips together right after application because it does need to dry but really only for a few seconds. I love that it doesn't dry out my lips like others tend to do. I only hope some matte options come available soon
Most Helpful Critical Review USED THIS A LONG TIME, DONT LIKE CHANGES I love the product but plan on looking for something else. I have used this product a long time. When I first started using it they did sell a gloss separately and even one that was in a gold tube and had some shimmer for that was nice for going out rather than just for work. Also I did not have trouble with the gloss falling off the tube like I do now. I hate it when companies have something good and then change it for the worse. I plan on contacting Maybelline about this. I understand that they might make more money by not selling the gloss separately forcing you to buy a whole new tube but they could set the pricing on the glosses to make up for it. Disappointed!
Reviewed by 9618 customers My GO-TO! 5
JazzyJ from Socorro NM
The only longwear lipstick I'll use if I need it on all day! Can barely tell if any rubs off, it looks the same. Goes on so smoothly and pretty, as long as you're prepping your lips and letting it dry properly before adding the gloss! Way better than the NYX Shineloud, those wouldn't stay on an hour.
Dry 1
Unsatisfied from Florida
It's a 2 step process. Goes on nicely and then just absorbs and dries out your lips. Left an awful feeling. I tried it 3 different times and disliked it more each time.
I would buy this product again. 4
Blueeyes from NC
Love the color. Does not last 12 hours but stays on pretty well.
Been using for years 5
Letha from Williamsport, PA
Love this lip color. Have been using it
Since it first came out. Stays on all day. No touch ups needed
Don't like 2
fire_owlie from Plano
I don't like the way this product feels. It does stay in place though. I'll give it credit for that.
CRUMBLY MESS 1
Maggie from NA
Ok at first this product was really comfortable on the lips but after about an hour it started crumbling off. If you rub your lips together even a little bit this product will crumble and flake. Not a good look.
Was hoping for Better 2
Sam from Go
I was so excited to try this product after seeing it all over tiktok and YouTube sadly when applied it was disgusting and flaky and separated will be returning
I have been buying this product for years 5
Minette from Wesley Chapel
I really like how long the product lasts
After searching over 35 years, I found THE ONE!!! 5
SelinaMR from Flint, MI
I love to put SuperStay 24hr Color on in the morning and not have to worry or wonder if my lips look great.
You know why? Because they look great until I climb into bed, at the end of the day. Your lips stay matte unless you add the moisturizing stick on the opposite end. I prefer a matte lip, so my color lasts all day and into the evening. And trust me I have tried almost every stain, tube and stick and nothing compares to this!
Not what I expected 3
Angellove from Tennessee
Bought this so I can still be cute under my mask. And it did not last all day and it doesnt show well on my skin tone. Not for me...maybe for others
No better lipstick ever! 5
jakmaw from Waterford MI
Lasts a long time - real staying power. I wouldn't use anything else, and will be beside myself if they discontinue it!
This is my second purchase 4
Marci from Georgia
Same as pros and cons
doesn't stay at all 3
Larisa from Long Beach
Even without the "superstay" part, this wipes off from just talking.
Disappointed 2
Briii from United States
Uhh, I don't know if the formula changed since launch or it was overhyped but I bought this and all it did was peel off after like 1 hour. It hardly showed on my lips too. I just won't be buying this again because it also burned my lips???
Yes 5
Bebe from Palm Desert
Really stays on.
Garbage i just bought this wont even apply 1
Oo from Virginia
Ridiculous how hyped this was.
I wouldn't by this product again 1
Daisy from Montebello
It did not last at all
Never again 1
Rosie from Roseville location
I loved the color I purchased a bright red and was obsessed. I waited the 2 minutes to let the first coat sit as instructed but when I went in with the other side it literally just melted off while applying.... it lasted a whole 3 minutes and I ended up removing it because it looked horrible. (And yes I did this on clean non chapped lips)
Returning 1
Mia from Media
I bought the color chestnut and lemme tell you the color looked NOTHING like it did online it was an ugly pinkish purple 😐
Can't go wrong with 24 hr maybelline. 5
Amber from Portland Oregon
I have been using this product since the first days of free product sampling and now is the most important time because I know it will stay put under my mask. No need to reapply. Would LOVE to try more colors
Would not buy again 1
Becky from California
It didn't last long at all before it started to get patchy and uneven. Less then 2 hours. Maybe it was user error but I wouldn't recommend.
Yes but it wasn't my perfect colir 1
Tata from Mismi
Like a lipstick that stays with the mask
Not great 1
Barellano from Visalia Ca
Color wasn't pretty at all and didn't last., crumbled on my lips and left them feeling dry.
Beautiful color! 5
Maddy from Salt Lake City
Love it!
Great stay on lip stick 4
Candi from California
This protects stays put very well. It's less drying then the other brands. And the color is perfect. Not too dark not too light. Very pretty. I only ha e it 4 stars because it still is drying (I haven't found one yet that isn't) and it doesn't stay on as long as it says. But honestly hands down the best one I've tried this far. I'm going to buy more from them. I have a few from the other major brand but I will be switching to this brand! Great product
