Rated 4.18 out of 5 stars
Most Helpful Positive Review Love the new carbon black!
This eyeliner is hands-down the best I have used. Other mechanical eyeliners always disappoint with the points breaking and me losing product down the drain. This lasts throughout the day and glides on nicely! My favorite is the newer shade, carbon black.
Most Helpful Critical Review Not so bad
I thought I'd really like this, especially with the whole 16 hours thing. I use this liner for tight/waterlining.For tightlining, it's really good with a creamy consistency and it stays all day even with my oily/sweaty skin. Waterlining, not so much.After an hour or so, my waterline is blackish rather than a bold line which I didn't like.Not a whole ton of smudging, but there is some in the corners and under my eyes. Overall it's a decent grab but not as infallible as they claim.
Reviewed by 512 customers Love it
Ash from NY
I've been using this eyeliner for over a decade now! I absolutely love it. It's smudge proof, water proof and stays on all day! It's so easy to apply, takes me not even 2 minutes to apply this eyeliner. So many people have asked me about it and I highly recommend this eyeliner to everyone!
I would definately buy again
Jennifer from Klamath Falls, Or
I use this everyday
Worst eyeliner I've ever bought
Jen from Golden, CO
Horrible product. The tip gets thick and rounded super fast and I didn't know how to sharpen it until watching a youtube video. Went to Loreal site and learned I needed to buy a sharpener. That in of itself is super annoying but I did it. I wasted half the pencil trying to sharpen it and could never get a tip on it without it falling off again. What a huge waste of money and time. I will now never buy Loreal again. Can't believe this product is still on the market.
HR from Michigan
This eyeliner is great for its price. The black is very dark and black, as expected, and it comes with a blender and a sharpener. Very satisfied!
Foreal INFALLIBLE eye pencil
Aj from Maryland
This liner is too expensive and doesn't seem to Be able to sharpen or be mechanical.
you can sharpen it!!
Aleksandta from Darien
Am i the only one that noticed the sharpener on the oposite end? its when you pull the smudger. Eureka !!!
This is my second purchase
jktejas from North Bergen, NJ
More to fill in the lash line and softer colors to share
Great! A disclaimer though:
Sham-bam-Shannon from California
I love this product! It goes on very smooth and love that it has a built in sharpener. I want to let you know that the smudger does smudge, but not to the extent where you can blend it out like a gradient eyeshadow (which is fine, but in case you want to know). Also, my eyelids get pretty oily, and so the eyeliner moves to the crease of my eyelid. But I used eyeshadow primer (urban decay) and it works great!
BEST liner for waterline!
Em from Pa
I tightline my upper waterline everyday and can NEVER find an eyeliner that stays put all day. This replaced my Marc Jacobs liner! so so awesome!
I would buy it again
Maggie from Texas
Love nice and black goes on great
My favorite eyeliner, even free trying high end options
Jess from Connecticut
I have tried a lot of the more expensive/"better quality" eyeliners on the market, both liquid and pencil, and this is always my favorite one. I can always draw perfect straight lines with it, with a great sharp wing. It's not too mushy either like some of the other pencil types. I would recommend this to anyone interested in an upper lid eyeliner. Maybe not the best for the water lines as it clumps into the inner corner after a few hours.
I would for sure but this again
AK Ross from Yuma,AZ
This is a amazing drugstore product and will not disappoint its very easy to work with again and it's better then some higher end eyeliners.
Em from Illinois
I'm terrible with liquid eyeliner so my go to is always a gel/crayon. This eyeliner is AMAZING! I was using a different brand that was tough to put on and last long and this one goes on so easily and stays on! It glides right on. I'll never go back to the other brand, I fell in love instantly!
I would recommend
Y from Fl
Great and easy
Simple and Dependable
Beyb7 from NE
Definitely a simple, everyday eye-liner. I like that it easily glides over my eye shadow and (with the black) is very pigmented so you dont have to struggle gliding it on. I personally think the correcter at the end is useless (unless you want to use it to smudge). My only qualm is that I run through these in about 2-3 weeks fast with everyday use. Wish they could increase the amount of product inside. Overall, dependable product.
I loved it last all day
Lolys from Downey ca
Is good product creamy and easy application and last all day
very easy to use
Jazz from Fort Walton Beach
very easy to use
Goes on easily
Cher from AZ
Would not repurchase
Nikki from Denver
Wanted to love this but...it smudges, does not stay put and did not work for me. Within 30 minutes it smudged for me every single time I used it. I ended up throwing it away. I am an eyeliner junkie so...no thanks on smudges!
Hikemylife from AZ
Good basic, not expensive, goes on smooth so you're not stretching your eye.
Carrie from Idaho
Broke on my first use & waste of money
Menopause madam from Severn MD
Love the easy application and won't smear if you rub your eyes
This is my go to Liner... even when I stray, I return!
LLH from Peoria, IL
I have tried others, continue to try others, I should give up and just stick with this one!
Jayar from Hi
The liner was on sale. Maybe thats tbe reason for the smell.
I would recommend this product
Peggy from Burrton,Ks
I had never bought this product, but I would highly recommend it to anyone! It goes on smoothly and wears well.