Product Reviews Rated 4.61 out of 5 stars
1644 Reviews
Most Helpful Positive Review Completely infatuated with this! < 3 < 3 I'm in LOVE with this shadow!!! I do my Smokey eye and then add to lower lid above lashes... or as a liner ... I get so many compliments! Really brings out hazel in eyes...I literally smile every time I start putting this on- it's the little things in life! LOL ... shimmer- Smokey- blend... you can do it all ... and the applicator tip is a great added bonus!
I would probably never had bought this if I hadn't gotten it as a sample... now I'm like 'MUST BUY ALL THE COLORS!' I have to stop myself because I don't wear too many colors ... it is costly- but one of the rare things I splurge on for ME... and it will last forever!!
I probably wouldn't but 'Kitten Karma' and 'Smoldering Satin' if I had to limit colors... they are VERY similar in color and not enough drastic difference to warrant both .. but both are beautiful
Most Helpful Critical Review Chunky and Patchy I had heard so many times that these were such amazing products, so i decided i would give them a try. I bought Ballet Baby for quite a costly price in my opinion. And upon getting it home and trying it, it didn't take long for me to see the flaws of this product. (Now this could be a bad batch, or the colors formula is a bit iffy, i dont know? Just sharing my experience. The initial things i noticed were
-The glitter clumped up in certain areas and it was quite patchy, it was definitely hard to even get the color somewhat even, never-mind opaque!
-The glitter only truly showed pigment and shine at certain angles. I didn't like that only at certain angles could you really see the product, i expected creamy glittery goodness, and was given patchy uneven shimmer.
-Probably my biggest issue; IT WAS SOOOOO CHUNKY!!! In certain places the glitter would chunk up and get uneven, and when i went over it for a second coat it just rubbed the first coat off and i was left with weird bald spots on my lid.
-Super uncomfortable, i dont get how these gurus can say this is comfortable when it feels like someone made an eyeshadow out of sand paper!
That's the bad and ugly but what about good
-I liked the color, it was a cute shade even if not opaque
-Its glitter, and i mean, who doesn't like glitter? (EVEN IF the glitter is chunky and gross looking)
THE VERDICT: Is this product worth the money? ABSOLUTELY NOT! (as of now) I still look forward to trying these supposed metallic formulas ive heard about and maybe give another shade in the glitter collection a shot and maybe i just got a bad batch or something. But as far as my experience goes, it was a terrible and useless product that costed me too much money.
FOR THE RECORD! yes i used primers and bases and concealers and eyeshadow primers and foundations and even tried powder bases just for the heck (because apparently the other word is flagged) of it?? Ive tried everything in my power to make the product work and it just didn't
Reviewed by 1644 customers Made my eyes burn like crazy 2
Beth from Nashville,tennessee
I love the color of this and I like liquid eyeshadow but this literally made my eyelids burn The Whole time I was wearing this
Yes 5
Gaby from McAllen, Tx
Magnifico
Barely Noticeable 1
KK from Charleston, SC
I expected far more pigment, but was extremely sheer. Used eye primer and everything, but could barely see anything on my lids. Much too expensive, especially for the quality/quantity.
I would not buy this product again 1
unhappy customer from Florida
The product may be good, but the applicator sponge came off and is stuck inside the shadow.
So pretty! 5
Cheryl from SC
I absolutely love these liquid eyeshadows.. this color is one of my favorites it had almost a rainbow shift when in the light! beautiful!
I will buy again 5
lizzie from Albuquerque NM
Love it
Kitten Karma! 5
Taylor G. from Williamsburg, VA
This is the first liquid eyeshadow I've ever used and I love it so much! Long lasting, gorgeous color, and oh so sparkly! I've lost count on how many compliments I've gotten from wearing this. I would definitely buy this again!
Diamond Dust 5
Mads from FL
So sparkly and pretty! I love this product and have repurchased this shade many times now
Not buying this again. 3
Crazy A from Cincy
If i wouldn't have thrown the box away when I bought it I would be returning this. Disappointed.
Smoldering Satin = mess 1
MapleTree from Tx
This eyeshadow, and mauve particular this color, was a hot mess. If you're in the adult entertainment industry then this will be great for your glitter needs. Otherwise it's messy, the glitter (not shimmer) flakes all over the place and just ends up all over your face.
Not sure 4
Nan from Tyler Texas
Its ok not as sparkly as I wanted
So pretty 😍 5
Ash from Houston, TX
I love this product. I'm been looking for a shadow that was really sparkly and I decided to try this after many years of putting it off. Its so beautiful and used alone gives it a lovely sparkle and wet look. I will be ordering more of the colors!
Not a fan 2
Carriep from NY
I am not a fan. I bought this in several colors. They do not show up well. All the colors are basically the same. It just looks like I have glitter all over the place.
Amazing! 5
Imani from Marietta, GA
This is an amazing eyeshadow color! I love these stilla colors and I get so many compliments when I wear this. I bought this one for a wedding and it's so easy to apply on your lids for a nice corner highlight. I can't recommend this product enough!
Not just for young women 5
Mo from New Jersey
I thought I might be too old for such a shimmering eyeshadow. After applying it I was so glad I purchased it. It was elegant, bright and tasteful. It was a nice way to welcome the New Year.
I would buy this product in another color as well. 5
Stephani from Fort Collins, CO
I wear the product every day when I have time to put it on or when I remember to put the product on.
Not enough pigment-better as glitter topper shade 2
ES from St Paul, MN
When I tried this I expected it to be like their metallic shadows which have a lot of pigment to them, but it was mainly just glitter without much color, sadly. I was not looking for a topper shade so I returned it
Obsessed 5
Bay from Ohio
I've bought the smitten one like 5 times now, color is bright & beautiful & last all day!
Absolutely worth the money! 5
Dani B from Omaha, NE
I use this daily. For a simple sparkle w/ light day makeup or use it over my colored shadows at night really heavy to get that more dramatic pop.
Glorious glitter!! 5
Dawn from Union,mo
Goes on smooth, stays on all day. Tons of compliments. Love it
love 5
Jessicac541 from bend, oregon
there is no other liquid glitter eye shadow that sparkles quite like these. I haven't found a color I don't love yet.
Love them 5
Jess from Tallahassee
These are great for highlighting the corner of your eye or using as an eyeshadow. I bought a full size and then 2 travel sized ones. I love them.
Couldn't resist 3
Sarah from Sacramento, CA
I've been waiting to buy some of these after seeing such great reviews. They're beautiful but kinda wished I hadn't. Or at least that the shimmer ones has been the ones available during 21 Days of Beauty. These are pretty much straight up glitter. It's in the name, I should've known. They make the eyes pop. But I'm not really going to wear glitter to the office and I don't love putting actual glitter on my eyes. I'll use it and again, it's beautiful, but I should've read the fine print. Don't be me! Make sure glitter is what you want!
Def would buy again 5
Jamie from Bellmawr, NJ
So this color u can wear on its own during the day for work and put it over eyeshadow at night to go out that's what I did it literally is perfect! All stila shadows are great
Beautiful Colors - Terrible Fallout 3
TennisBeauty from Nashville
I purchased Smoldering Satin and Wanderlust during the 21 Days of Beauty. Both colors are beautiful; however the fallout goes everywhere especially after removal. I won't repurchase and I"m glad these were half off. The Shimmer & Glow Liquid Eyeshadows are a better option with no fallout.
