Product Reviews Rated 3.48 out of 5 stars
475 Reviews
Most Helpful Positive Review Fairly Light Neutral Tarte's best concealer imo. Super emolliant- great for aging eyes/dry under eyes. Great shade range. Blends great ~ I use a brush & immediately set w/trans loose powder. I have a TON of concealers & I always come back to this one especially when I really want my makeup to look flawless.
Most Helpful Critical Review worst This is not creaseless! It's super tacky. It settled into my under eye creases even with setting it, and started creasing right away, only to crease worse as hours passed. It also caused my mascara to smudge under my eyes because it was so sticky it just grabbed it. Because of all the creasing it made my under eyes look even more aged. It also appeared extremely cake even though I used bare minimum and blended well. I'm not sure how, but somehow this concealer seems to grab every possible concealer flaw available and put them all right under my eyes. Definitely a no for me. I have very dry under eyes so this should have been a good concealer for me, it just wasn't.
Reviewed by 475 customers Love all Tarte products 5
ninepoint from PA
I use the foundation and eye concealer. Love that these products are good ingredients and don't make me break out. The coverage and long wear are very good.
It is okay 5
Kristina from Los Angeles
The thing is you need only a DOT of this product. Any product you shlaaaakkk on to your face will crease if you have creases. This is the longest lasting concealer I have. I love it. It needs to be set with a damp beauty blender.. NO BAKING. You are not cake batter.
go to concealer 5
Evi from Oregon
I love this concealer because a little bit really does go a long way, just a tiny bit is enough to cover all the dark spots on my face. It is also not drying at all.
Won't buy again! 1
Ash from Brandon, MS
I bought this because my local stores didn't have my color in shape tape. This is absolutely horrible you can't blend it and it left under my eyes extremely oily!
DONT BUY 1
Sam from Baltimore, MD
This product is awful!!! I bought it in the hopes that it would be more light weight than their shape tape but it was absolutely awful. It doesn't blend. It leaves massive creases.
I recommend this product 4
Mariaaa from New York, NY
Some people might not think this is the best product, but it does the job for me. I have dark circles and this product helps cover them a little and stays on the whole day. The feel to this product is waxy and thick but I use my cerave moisturizer to help blend it easier. PS- it creases a little, but it's not that noticeable.
Pleasantly wowed! 5
Kami from Maryland
I usually get tarte's regular shape tape concealer but I picked this up because it is winter and was crazy impressed with how thick and moisturizing this is without creasing into my fine lines. I will never go back to the original now!
Long lasting 5
Kok from Ny
Def helps with the bags under my eyes and stays long
Pleasantly Surprised 5
Dee from NJ
Never use concealer but decided to give this a try. It's amazing!
Garbage 1
Jen from Grand Rapids
Doesn't conceal anything and creases like crazy. Just thinking about this product makes me angry.
Colors are all wrong on color chart 2
Charlie from Wilmington NC
I have bought this in the past and even took my old concealer to the store
Because of covid there are no testers and the color chart is completely inaccurate
I will be returning in an attempt to get a darker cokir
No creases last all day 5
KK from Wilmington NC
I use after applying moisturizer and before foundation
Good coverage
Last all day
I loveeee this concealer 5
Blair from Jacksonville nc
The best concealer! Not only for under eye but for covering blemishes as well. It has a very sticky consistency that I didn't like at first but now I love!!! I've been a loyal customer of this product for three years now
Creamy coverage 4
Pinkbeetata from Bloomington
I really like this concealer. It has good coverage. It doesn't take much to get the job done, it's on the thicker side. If you like to paint your whole under eye or bake, you probably won't like this. You only need a small amount of powder to set this, too much and it might cake.
Do not recommend 1
Roxy from So Cal
I decided to try this concealer and absolutely hate it. I hardly ever even review products but this one is that bad. It is oily and sticky, difficult to blend and ironically creases more than the shape tape concealer.
Not what I was looking for in a concealer 2
Kim from Greenville, NC
This is the same formula and consistency as Shape Tape. It says creaseless, but it is not. It is thick and heavy. While it provides full coverage (like an all day wear foundation) it settles into pores and fine lines. It is not what I was looking for in a concealer. I wanted something natural without a heavy made-up look, and this product does not provide that.
Sticky & causes creases!!! 1
Ashley T from Orlando, Florida
I tried this because I always used Tarte Shape Tape Concealer. This stuff is completely different. It's like thick and sticky. Doesn't blend well at all and leaves you with more creases. Any powder I use over it leaves my skin very patchy looking. I bought this full size and would hate to waste it so I've been mixing it with foundation and it's better that way. Using this like regular concealer under the eyes is a dangerous game and wouldn't try it again.
This is worth the money 5
Tabatha from Starkville, Ms
The application is great and if done correctly, it stays in place and doesn't crease hardly at all. I'd recommend using a creaseless setting powder such as Laura Mercier or IT cosmetics blurring powder.
Update Using the Concealer further 5
Chels3 from Philadelphia
Excellent, two dots one over eye and one below w/ a light under-eye moisturizer, and Needs a concealer brush for best application. Great for winter for ppl who do not use powder vs a dryer waterproof formula for summer. Great for contact lens wearers. Ingredients are good for you and no aweful perfume smell like tart shape tape for ppl who have allergies as well. Will be purchasing again at
love this stuff! 5
crash k. from Texas
This is my go to concealer. I'm really surprised that there are negative reviews at all. I apply using a stippling motion with a foundation brush, then smooth it out lightly using circular motions and I have no issues whatsoever. I started using it over blemishes, forgetting that it was an undereye concealer. It gives such a pretty, dewy, natural look that I hate to cover it with foundation or anything else. So I've started wearing just the concealer alone (no foundation) and a little blush, mascara, and gloss when I want a more simple look. I use it on my under eye as well and have never had any creasing. It is tacky but I think that's what makes it creaseless, and it stays put. It also sets well on me with or without a setting spray.
I might buy this product again 4
JudyW from Sun City West, AZ
I use this product under my eyes and it does have great coverage but it still goes in the creases. I'm going to buy a blurred eye powder to see if it helps.
Love the Ingredients 4
Chels2 from Philadelphia
Bought this for my undereyes for the anti-aging ingredients to give my undereyes a break from my other waterproof concealer. Feels like nothing on and beautiful brightening effect for ppl who actually have dark circles. A little goes a long way but very tacky application with finger. I don't think il need much undereye moisture for this one which was exactly what I was looking for. The concealer hydrates it for you all in one. Does crease a smidge with my heavier moisturizer on so far but not significantly. Will keep giving it a go.
Just ok, shape tape is easier to blend. 3
Beth from Kansas City, Mo
You can't dab the concealer into skin to blend dry easily because it's pretty tacky feeling so you have to rub to blend in which is not the best thing to do on delicate skin around eyes, especially as you age.
LOVE THIS!!! 5
Carissa from Ocean, NJ
I LOVE this product!! I had been struggling to find a perfect concealer because Tarte Shape Tape wasn't working that well for me. I wanted a creamy concealer that wouldn't dry my under eyes. This is perfect! I really only this around my eyes and on the bridge of my nose, and I blend with either a concealer brush or beauty blender. I always use the Tarte base tape primer underneath as well, to create a nice base for my CC cream and concealer. I do very natural makeup so I don't wear a heavy foundation. I also use this on it's own (without CC cream underneath) for my more "natural days". The only "con" I have is that the product was more thick than I expected it to be, but I don't mind it all, it does a good job!
Ehhh... 2
Keisha from Chicago
I really liked this concealer at first but now 3 weeks of having it it became dryer and caliber. It is so sticky and I can only use certain powders over it. I will not be buying again .
