Rated 4.36 out of 5 stars
Most Helpful Positive Review LOVE!
I purchased "Two Ton Teal" and couldn't be happier! I was iffy when I first opened the tube and saw the color and brush... but both are great. The color is a lot more subtle on the lashes, but it still gives that extra oomph. The product did not smudge, flake, irritate my eyes, or have any other side effect apart from fantabulous lashes. The only way I could be happier with this mascara would be for Clinique to package all four colors in deluxe sizes in a set! I would highly recommend!
Most Helpful Critical Review NO Volume - ONLY Length
After reading reviews, I was excited to put my Lash Doubling Mascara aside for a little more oomph, as promised. What a disappointment! This mascara ONLY added length - my lashes look long, but so thin! The mascara is also clumpy/flaky, so I ended up with uneven looking long lashes, and a dusting of black under my eyes by the end of the day. I gave this mascara one star because it was easily removed with my Clinique face wash. As other reviewers stated, I think the issue is with the brush - it excellently separates, but to a fault, removing all opportunity for volume! If you are looking for length, this may work for you, otherwise, save yourself the trouble.
Reviewed by 542 customers Not Impressed
Ashley5 from San Diego, CA
This product doesn't give any volume! I'm disappointed I went with this one. Could have spent less on a different brand and had a much better outcome!
crisfont from Atlanta, GA
I love the bold brush to make lashes look bigger and fuller.
I would NOT buy this product again
AT from Leonardtown, MD
I specifically asked the salesperson for a lash-building mascara that was removable with warm water. This product does not wash off with just warm water.
Nothing Chubby here
Black Eyes from Yorktown, Virginia
Makes lashes thick but caused eye to water and mascara ran down face.
Won't buy again
Sherri from Metairie, LA
I asked for mascara that would look like I have long/thick lashes without having to put on multiple coats - this does NOT work
Mick from Blackstone, Virginia
I put 2 layers of this mascara on and wow!!! My eyelashes look 10x longer and fuller! LOVE LOVE LOVE
Makes lashes look long
Caroline from MI
I love this mascara, it makes my lashes look long and stays on well throughout the day
Triche from Slidell LA
It's mascara it does give some thickness and length to lashes not clumping but only used one week
Holls from Little Rock, Ar
I usually use Estée Lauder mascara and they didn't have it this time so I went with Clinique. I've gotten so many compliments on how long and full my lashes look with this mascara. It's a game changer, I love it!
RodPhx from Phoenix
I got it as an option for a check out sample and picked one for my mom. She loves it.
Best mascara I've ever purchased
Lisar627 from Illinois
Lengthens my skimpy lashes. But the best thing is that this mascara doesn't smudge while I'm blow drying my hair as most mascaras do.
I would not recommend this mascara. It flies very bad.
vids from AL
flakes off all day
Beautiful Long Lashes and Great Formula
Tracey from New York, NY
This is my second tube of the Chubby Lash mascara. The formula is creamy and applies nicely. For a longer lash, I recommend putting on several layers, rather than combing one layer on for a while as that can dry out the formula. The tube is cute and made of metal, which gives it a sleek and luxe look. While it's not waterproof, I see this as an advantage as it does not strip or tug at my lashes as I am removing my makeup—its water soluble nature is convenient for my routine. It dries beautifully and gives my lashes a nice lift.
Needs to be improved
Mcbethie from Enid OK
I like the effects it makes on lashes but its a struggle getting it to work ... the applicator .seems to come out with clumps on wand and also comes off lashes easily during day onto skin. I wont buy this one again i prefer the high impact mascara . wand and application easy and stays on..
Best mascara by far...
Baker lady from Gilbert, AZ
I will continue to purchase this mascara. It's the only one that thickens and lengthens my lashes. Love it!
The BEST colored mascara
Cap from CA
This product is my absolute FAVORITE colored mascara. The black honey (Burgundy)and grape (purple) colors are so beautiful and truly make me green eyes look even greener. This product applies super easily, makes my lashes look long and thick, AND lasts ALL DAY without any fallout. At the end of the day, it is SO easy to remove with just water, which means you don't have to tug on your eyelashes at all! I have probably gone through close to ten tubes of this product. I really hope these colors come back in stock! They are better than any other burgundy mascara on the market, including YSL, which is not nearly as pretty of a purple color
Awesome product, so underrated!
Addie06 from Missouri
I have used re-purchased this mascara for years now. I think it is completely underrated in the makeup world! It does not clump, it is very buildable, it lengthens the lashes and makes them bold, it gives me a fluttery lash look, the wand is great and coats lashes easily... I could go on and on. I have not had any negatives with this product!
Love this mascara!
Kaci from California
I decided to try this & I love it. I love the formula & I love the brush. It really makes my eyes pop & I've been told how beautiful my eyes are. No flaking either. I would definitely recommend this.
Carolynb from Fla
I like the brush on this mascara wand it distributes the product on your lashes evenly
calibee from westlake village, ca
big, bold lashes!
Rach1029 from Ca
Love this mascara. Lengthens, separates, does not clump or flake. Lots of volume, love it.
Kimmy from New Jersey
I feel like this mascara makes my lashes look really long and thick.
Very good mascara.
Erin from Columbus, OH
Love this mascara because it does a wonderful job lengthening and thickening my blonde lashes. The only con is that it can clump some.
Teacher Lady from Selinsgrove, PA
I use this with a primer and this makes my lashes nice and long.
Connie from Coralville
Love how it makes my lashes stand out.