Rated 4.43 out of 5 stars
Most Helpful Positive Review Best Eyeliner For Upper Lash Line
My search is finally over. This eyeliner is a deep but not too dark cool shade of brown. Most brown eyeliners look too dark for my fair skin and mature age. It's easy to apply and looks just as good at the end of the day as when I first apply it early in the morning. I apply over eyeshadow and I use Too Faced Shadow Insurance as a primer. I've tried many eyeliners over the years and this is the best one that I have found. The only con is that it applies very lightly on the waterline so I don't recommend it for that. I use Givenchy Khol Couture waterproof eyeliner pencil in Chestnut and that stays on fairly well. A good makeup remover specifically made for waterproof products is required. I've been using Clinique Take The Day Off For Lids, Lashes and Lips for many years and it works well without causing irritation. I use that first and then wash my face as usual. I highly recommend this pencil!
Most Helpful Critical Review Not worth the hype
I wanted to love this product, since I'm a Benefit fan...but it's honestly one of the worst eyeliners I've used. It claims to be non-transferrable and waterproof....I can honestly say that with normal wear, it only lasted about an hour. My tightlines had slipped, and liner was under my eyes. Additionally, this is absolutely transferrable. Give it a gentle swipe with your pinky, even with primer, and you'll have a black finger. Wouldn't purchase again.
Reviewed by 83 customers Love it!
Shelley from KY
Goes on smoothly and lasts all day!
best eyeliner hands down
Megan from Schaumburg, IL
I always use black eyeliner on the water line underneath my eyes and always had a problem with smudging. This eyeliner lasts all day, and doesn't run or smudge unless you smudge upon application. Will continue buying!
Not pigmented enough
Zoey from Paso Robles, CA
If you're looking for a waterline pencil don't choose this one. It comes off so fast and even on eyes is not pigmented. I'll give it that it doesn't smudge easily if put on your eyelid, but if you try to use it on your waterline it comes off within an hour. You have to put multiple layers on
to make it dark on your eye and the little blending thing at the other end is so useless. This is way too expensive for what it is.
Computer shopper from Indianapolis, IN
I like this eyeliner pencil, because it goes on very smoothly. I'm able to draw a better line On my eyelids when using it. There's no pulling Or tugging . I like the added smudger that's Also included on the other side of the eyeliner pencil.
Very Happy with Purchase...
ACLFLA from Hernando, FL
Recommend by sales person on my last visit to Ulta. Applied the following morning and stayed fresh looking all day. Glides on easy; brown is a very nice rich color. Liked it so much I purchased the purple on-line the next day.
Janie from Charleston, SC
Easy glide on and great pigment
Cdf30 from Michigan
I really like this eye liner. It glides on easily, has great pigment, the color is perfect for me.
Love this eyeliner!
Misti W from Prosser. WA
Glides on smoothly and really stays put all day!!!!
CA transplant from NC
I absolutely love this eyeliner, goes on so easy and stays
Tonya from North Carolina
This eyeliner is awesome. It goes on smooth and stays on. I have always had trouble getting my upper eyelid straight and this makes it so easy.
The Perfect Eyeliner Pencil!!!!
Dawn from Murrells Inlet, SC
I used to use IT no tug, then IT changed the formula and packaging which was a total disaster. Since I have green color eyes, I needed a purple/plum eyeliner color. I was thrilled to find it in Benefits collection. I love their mascara, so I purchased the eyeliner! Well let me tell you, THIS IS THE BEST EYELINER EVER!!! Worth every penny. Wish I new about this eyeliner years ago!!! I bought two more!
I stopped using after a few trials
Gardennymph from Valdosta, GA
I love the Bad Girl Bang mascara so I saw the eyeliner next to it at Ulta and decided to try it. It is a twist type stick vs the kind you sharpen which is nice but it doesn't glide on easily. It's rough on my eyelid and I found after a couple of days of use my eyelid was a little raw. It's going back to Ulta if I can find my receipt!
I love this purple (and blue) very smooth liner.
Kel from Morton Grove, is
I like bag gal liner in general because it goes on very easy. I like the purple color. It's deep. I think you can decide whether to use on upper lash or lower lash for different effects. The blue liner and mascara always get compliments. I also have used the black for years and I love it and its long lasting. I'm hoping more colors come out for liners and mascaras. My favorite brand.
I like this eyeliner!
Delinda from Texas
It goes on well and stays pretty long.
peggy from Pennsylvania
Easy to apply and feel great
Finally, a good brown liner!
Madi from VA
My go-to daily eyeliner. It's so hard to find a brown eyeliner, so I was excited to find a true deep brown. Application is smooth and pigmented, and honestly stays on ALL. DAY. LONG.
Did what I wanted.
gi gi from butler pa
Cindyd from East Wenatchee, WA
I prefer using a self-sharpening pencil eyeliner. I've tried MANY brands and BADgirl BANG! is by far the BEST! It glides on so easy, stays on, is waterproof, and lasts ALL DAY. I wear contacts and I've never had a problem with it flaking off and getting into my eyes. I love, love, love this eyeliner. Dark Brown is the best color. Please don't stop making this!
I love this product, even saved box!
Deb from Germantown Tn
Everything was good about it. I will buy it again!
Not what I was expecting
Shel from Mechanicsburg, PA
I asked a salesperson at the store for her recommendation on an eyeliner that goes on very smoothly. She recommended this. It is absolutely not smooth at all. And the color is so light I have to put several layers on for it to have any significant color.
Best eyeliner ever!!
Smileykat from Sacramento, CA
I have tried a lot of eye liners! This one is the best I've tried . I'm done looking, it's my favorite!
This is my Go To Eye Liner
Penelope from Richmond, VA
I struggled to find a good long lasting eye liner that didn't end up making me look like a raccoon by lunch, this eye liner exceeded expectations. It seems to last longer than other brands I've tried.
Dess from Washington
Probably the only liner to stay inside my eyes allll day and all night, no I don't sleep with it but you know what I mean, because sometimes when you apply eyeliner to the inside of your eye it smears off, this one works well and stays on nice and black! Love
Did not disappoint!
Hijenk4 from New Mexico
I was attending a wedding in Arizona in July and needed an eyeliner that would withstand the intense heat and the tears of joy. Benefit was an obvious choice because I already use their mascara, but this eyeliner exceeded my expectations! It glides on smoothly, looks great, stays on all day and does not sting or irritate my eyes!
Yes, I would buy this again!
Awesome from Palmdale, Ca
I was surprised how easy it glided on, and stayed on all day! I was an IT Cosmetics lover of their black NO TUG Eyeliner, however they changed their product to a pencil that you need to sharpen. I waste more of the product trying to sharpen their pencil! 👎🏽. I am very happy I tried this Benefit Eyeliner pencil! It has a retractable auto sharpen pencil to adjust as little or more! I like that it doesn't smear or smudge, stayed on all day! I will buy this again!