Rated 3.97 out of 5 stars
Most Helpful Positive Review Excellent Quality Eyeliner
So far I own 6 of these Stila eyeliners & I love them! They are high quality, long lasting, easy to apply and stay on all day for me. I also love that they have many shades to choose from. My 3 favorites that I use right now are Damsel(very dark brown)Lionfish(bronze brown) and Stingray(black.)
I have seen reviews saying that they don't crank up and are broken, but I have not found this to be true. They are slow to start cranking up when you first use them, but keep slowing turning the base counterclockwise and they will come up. Just one important thing to note though is that they are not retractable as of yet, so be careful because once you crank them up they are not able to go back down.
I love mine and will continue to purchase!
Most Helpful Critical Review BIG DISAPPOINTMENT
It look amazing on the make up artist that recommended it to me, So me and my mom bought it instantly, then a week later she went to the doctor, and guess what?, the eye liner stopped her production of tears! then she tells me about it and I was feeling the same irritation in the morning after taking it of in the nights, like a cold sensation in the eye all day long. And the waterproof promise (not runny) was sad too 3 hours after I put it on, I had it all over my lids! I thought it was great but it just didn't worked out.
Reviewed by 2342 customers Not sure about the negative reviews...
Chanel from Texas
I have been using this for years now. Lionfish is my favorite shade, since I have extremely fair skin, and some browns can be too light, but love this color and slight sheen it gives. It stays on all day and doesn't smear (even when I cry or have watery eyes). This usually last me 3 months and that is with daily use - not sure on some of the other reviews... been using for 5 years and will not use anything else!
This pencil gives too little product for the money.
Kristin from Detroit
There was barely any product in this pencil. Very disappointing.
love love it
kiki from roseville mn
i will only use this!!!
I have purchased this many times but this one is defective
Susie from Harlingen
I have used this lionfish and had been a good product but not this one. Terrible.
Doesn't stay put. Under my eyes all day. Hoping to return to
Missy from Oak Ridge TN
Cleaned up under my eyes all day. Not pleasant. Hoping to return asap.
I would buy this again.
Kelly from NC
This helps add some pizazz to my eyes.
Best eyeliner EVER
KC from Helena, AL
Have used this product for years. Stays on well, easy to apply, goes on smoothly and with a thin line. Does not wear off and has many colors to chose from....a liquid liner
Great Replacement for Laura Geller
CtinaNC from North Carolina
I've been looking for a replacement for Laura Geller waterproof gel liner. This worked great!
Didn't stay on!
Jes from FL
I purchased Stila eyeliners because they were Carmine free. I'm allergic to Carmine and thought I would give these a try. My eyes were very irritated. The eyeliner did not last.
The twist up mechanism wouldn't work properly :(
Meesh from Aldie, va
I loved the color espresso, a true warm medium brown, and I loved the way it looked smudged and then set. Unfortunately, I could only use it once because it wouldn't twist up or down.
Didn't stop my eyeliner from bleeding
Rdkai from Nebraska
I still ended up with eyeliner bleeding onto my lids, even with a primer.
No. I don't like it.
Sandy from Winter Garden
I don't like it. It is not waterproof and the retractor doesn't work well.
Lionfish Doubles as Brow Pencil
AprilinParis from Bay Area, CA
Overall, I like these eye liners. There is a good color selection and, unlike other reviewers say, not only does it last, but it's hard to remove at night. I usually wake up with tell-tale liner. I discovered a bonus with lionfish, it doubles as a brow pencil! It works better than my ABH brow products. I did take one star off, though, because I have gotten them in the past where the retractor mechanism does not work AND you do get very little product. I need to replace after 3-6 months. Love the lionfish and the purple one for my green eyes.
Wish I Returned It
Chrisie from Atlanta, Georgia
You can't carry this liner along with you for touch ups because the top comes off easily. The liner dried out before I could even use it a third time. The shade I bought was perfect for what I needed but it didn't last long on the waterline. I wish I had returned it because I didn't even get to finish half the product before having to throw it in the garbage. Waste of money. I purchased inglot gel liner and I'm in love with it.
Not pleased. it still doesn't stay on like other brands
Momma Doc from Newport Beach
Color is good, but it doesn't last all day
Not buying again
Royjean from Jacksoncille
Goes on easily but does not stay on your eyelids for more than half the day. I love those liquid but not the pencil
Not waterproof, flakes off
DJ Ultafan from Crystal Lake, IL
Doesn't stay on as advertised. Will be returning this item.
Pricey for a meh.
L'alice from Philadelphia pa
Tried it once to see if it could outlast Estee Lauder's eyeliner pencil....... nope.
Goes on nicely,but fades throughout the day. Had to use with primer to get long wear out of it.
Stila is my favorite eyeliner
Kimmmie Queen from Louisa, VA
The Stila brand so far has been my favorite for eyeliner. It is consistently the same and is easy to apply. This eyeliner seems to never dry out and is very soft when applying. It never smudges or smears.
Margir from Clifton New Jersey
The eye liner didnt lasr not even 3 hour. I returned and purchase a different one
I would buy this again.
Jodi from Fishers, Indiana
It goes on easily. I can put on a thin line.
My favorite eyeliner for several years
Dee from Pa
I love how the product goes on smoothly and stays. I tried a different color one time and it was not easy to apply , so I stick to the color Stingray.
Nancy from Ohio
I have this in several colors. They go on smooth and stay on all day.
I would buy this again
Lizzy from RSM, CA
It looks nice after application.
Lash line, Water line for thicker looking lashes
MaggieB from SF East Bay
I've finally found a great, lasting, water line/lash line pencil. Instant fill-in for thicker looking lashes... stingray is a rich black color.