Product Reviews Rated 4.14 out of 5 stars
426 Reviews
Most Helpful Positive Review Lovely I never thought that I would find a dupe of a dupe! My favorite drugstore eyebrow pencil from the drugstore is the L'Oreal Brow Stylist, however this one offers the same quality but cheaper. I am definitely one who prefers a full face of makeup and this fulfills my desires. It blends out well with the spoolie and offers the right amount of pigmentation. Whether you are going for a full force, bold brow or a soft, natural brow, this product will favor to your needs. This also lasts all day and does not fade. If you set it with a brow gel(I use the essence brow gel) you are good for over 12 hours of not more. Don't sleep, LA Girl offers great quality products :)
Most Helpful Critical Review I would love this so much if it wouldn't break so easily! I am definitely torn on this product. I bought this product as an attempt to try out some other brow options. I had a very difficult time getting it to apply to skin (I typically do my eyebrows first, before my face makeup), but after switching my routine around I was able to improve the application some when applying over foundation or powder. When it does apply, it's a great color (I got the medium brown, and it's not too red), it blends easily with the spoolie on the other end, and it looks very natural. However, because of difficulty in application, sometimes a firmer pressure was needed to lay color down and then pencil would snap. It's about a week after my order and all of the product has broken. Overall, that experience negates how it looked once it was on. I'll probably be looking for a creamier product in the future.
Reviewed by 426 customers Best Affordable Brow Pencil 5
Jessica from California
This is my go-to brow pencil and I can always count of it to fill my brows without making them look too dark
Fave brow pencil 5
Heather from NJ
Parts of my brow are sparse and missing and this is the only pencil I can rely on to make the hairs look realistic.
No 1
Na from Na
Have to press really hard for the pigment to show
Horrible 1
Priya from Chicago
The whole thing came out within the first day. I do not recommend this product!!
Natural look 5
SC1847 from Pembroke Pines, FL
Very affordable. Looks natural. Last all day.
REPURCHASED 4 TIMES! 5
morgan p from Arizona
This brow pencil is my favorite drug store brow pencil. I've repurchased this product 4 times and I love it! I would definitely recommend it.
GOAT Brow Pencil for Oily Skin 5
Julia from Tulsa
This brow pencil is the Greatest Of All Time!!! If you have oily skin, do not sleep on this one. Due to the drier nature of the pencil, it glides right onto my brows & doesn't slide off or disappear through out the day. It leaves a very natural but put together look. No sharpie brows here!
my favorite brow pencil ever 5
Abigail from Vista CA
I into the more natural look and these make my brows look amazing
Would not buy again 2
Sara from NY
too easy to break, not very pigmented. wouldn't recommend.
Breakable 1
Nor from Ct
Broke within the first day of using it!
Works but hard to use 3
Mickey from SD
This product works but is harder to use. The brow product is very stiff and you have to press pretty hard to get color pay off. The blonde color is nice and not too orange though.
Yes I will buy this product again. 5
Arty from Glendale, AZ
On my brows. This color looks natural.
this ain't it 1
moon unit from chicago
decided to pick this up cuz my elf one ran out and wanted to try something new.
i have to press hard to get almost no pay out of pigment. the stick of "lead" in the pencil was falling out of the pencil before i even tried it. barfo. skip this one
Go to 5
G from Cali
Better than the nyx one. I love it.
Buy again 5
Uknown from Aaaaaa
Its affordable and doesnt break easily make sure dont use it long use it short so it wont break
Misleading color name 1
lkat from Massachusetts
I bought this in taupe which is the shade I normally wear in all other brands. This is so NOT taupe, it's more like a very warm blonde. If I had bought this in the store I would've realized that when I saw the color on the cap. However, I bought it online based on the shade name. I can't speak to the performance as I had to remove it immediately after trying it on one brow.
Nope...never again. 1
Pamcanjam from KY
I bought the gel liner, upon a recommendation, which I love and bought this as an impulse buy, as I was out of eyebrow fine line product. It barely makes a line on your skin, and only if you really bear down, which results in end breaking off.
Horrible. 1
Dry. from Michigan
I must have received old pencils. I ordered 4. Each one is so dried out. All garbage.
Best affordable brow pencil! 5
bbibbibrooke from Florida
Soooo perfect for achieving the perfect brow! It's so easy to use and helps you get a really precise brow!
Not enough product 3
Edie from houston
I like the product but I noticed I was going through these sorta quick. Initially thought it was because every now and then the tip would break as I was using it. So when I was opening a new one I decided to roll it all the way out, I was disappointed when the whole piece came out and measured just about an inch. Probably not even an inch. Kinda sucky, might have to find another pencil of this type.
Replaced my ABH Wiz 5
Cat from Las Vegas
I tried this since I didn't want to spend an extra $20 for Anastasia's brow wiz (granite color). I bought LA Girl's blackest brown color and I like it so much better. As far as application, it goes on fairly similar to ABH. I prefer something not as pigmented and can still build-up the darkness of my eyebrows and this works PERFECT. Save your money from expensive brands and try this out. I have oily skin and this doesn't smear on me.
not my style 1
domesticgoddess from tx
I can't seem to master the flow of the pencil, I twist it 1 direction or the other and it never gives me enough or too much and I wind up breaking it off. I prefer old fashioned pencils, Cantrice to be exact and Ulta no longer carries it. If I could master the pencil, it might be ok but every name brand I have ever bought like this, I have had issues w/the flow
better than Anastasia 5
natalia from Ceres
I used Anastasia for years because nothing compared but my friend recommended this product and Im so thankful!great product and great price!!
easy to use. 5
Shree from NJ
It is so easy to use and has spoolie on the end. It gives you the perfect soft look that I personally love. Love Love love.
I'm buy again 4
Yan from CA
Love it!!🙃
