Rated 4.61 out of 5 stars
Most Helpful Positive Review HOLY GRAIL
All I have to say is that if there is one thing I know - it's eyebrows. I've been obsessed with brows for like over ten years. This product is hands down, the absolute BEST eyebrow product I have ever used. The formula is light years ahead of the ABH Brow Definer. It is highly pigmented but also buildable, which is incredible. It made my light blonde, thin/sparse brows look full, defined, and perfect (in combo with Gimme Brow) and took me less than five minutes. I received this as a Platinum Perk (Thank you Benefit & Ulta, you are so good to me!) and I will be in line when Ulta opens on June 24th to purchase another one.
Most Helpful Critical Review Not what I expected!
Love how the wand makes it easy to apply but I felt the product too creamy which made my eyebrows look very oily by the end of the day.
Reviewed by 10731 customers It's awesome!
Gabrielle from Republic,MO
I've tried probably a dozen different brow pencils in the last several months and none have worked and stayed put the way this one has. Very easy to apply too! Would definitely recommend and will buy again!
Best brow product
Conner from Ohio
First off let me say I have used ALOT of brow products from tinted gel, pomade, pencil, powder by drug store, NYX, Anastasia Beverly. I have VERY sparse, thin eyebrows that you can barely see because they are so blonde and have gotten thinner as I've gotten older. I love Benefit and their micro define pencil, tinted brow gel and this goof proof is my absolute favorite. I CANT stand a drawn on weird filled in brow. I have blonde hair and I prefer 2.5 color as it's more natural looking.
It's so easy to apply!! I start by using point end to draw outer lines to create shape on brow and arch then turn sideways where it's flat and fill brow color naturally. It glides on effortlessly and can easy to remove if mistake made. Finish with spooly to brush out and make natural looking and can even apply brow gel for hold with no issue if you want. Stays all day as well and doesn't look drawn on!
Bobcy from Florida
I love this eyebrow pencil. I have sparse eyebrows and every other product I've tried looked like I drew my eyebrows on. This product makes my brows look natural. And it does last throughout the day. Please don't stop making it!!
Not for oily skin
CocoaCutie from Inland Empire, CA
I was so excited to try this brow pen after reading the reviews. However, the staying power is terrible on my oily skin. This pen gave me the same coverage as my NYX brow pen, which was less than half the price of this pen. Perhaps, the lack of staying power is due to my oily skin. I'm not sure. I definitely would NOT purchase this pen again.
Cara from Austin, Texas
Love this product!
Best brow liner
Penny from Milton, Vt
Fill in space places then use to draw in where no brows. Brush to even. Tried many and was not happy. Only place I have found the cooler gray.
Brown sugar from Greenbrier
Used for my fine eye brows
mo from Concord
takes a little practice but works nicely
I hate this eyebrow pencil.
JM from Littleton, CO
Admittedly, I grabbed this pencil instead of the Benefit microblade eyebrow pencil on accident. But decided to give this a try as I didn't feel like going back to the store. I am a beginner eyebrow pencil user, and I figured I would practice with this one. I hate this pencil. I hate the color (I got black, but it looks dark brown next to my eyebrow hair) and the color just completely brushes away. I also have 2 patchy areas on my brows, and the color won't take at all. This pencil is terrible for me.
Donna from Effingham Il
We were on a sisters shopping trip.
All three sisters tried mine and purchased their own at Ulta!
Not what I expected
Tanya from NY
I thought this product would blow me away.... one nice day in NY and my husband asked me what happened to my eyebrow.... There was a "bald spot" after beads of sweat came through it like a razor
Super Fine and Waxy
Shewhoknits from Plymouth, MN
One of the best Benefits associates worked hard with me to figure out what would be best. I had been using eyeshadow to create my brows and I detailed my struggles with that. It is my fault that I neglected to mention I have neuropathy. She suggested the gel plus this pencil would be easier than the eyeshadow to apply. I made a mess all three times I tried to apply it. I looked like I had a patchwork quilt for brows. There were globs and gaps, and trying to work it made it worse, especially with the pencil because it was so fine, it took forever to cover the gaps, was very waxy, and it messed the gel up. I will say the color was nice. I hate to be so negative but this is my experience. That being said, I can see how others may be much better at using it, and have it look great. I am moving onto Anastasia powder next....
Perfect Brow Pencil
Chris from Waterford, MI
I have used a lot of brow pencils.
But, I've Finally found the Perfect One. Thanks Ulta
I will buy this product again for sure
Ari from Fremont, CA
I was looking for a pencil with ultra thin tip mainly to shape and fill few spots in my eyebrows. so i came to Ulta store. One of the associate at store recommended benefit precisely my brow pencil. I needed something to shape the eyebrows without seeing the pencil mark or thick mark and this pencil is exactly what i was looking for. It has really good pigmentation that i don't need to apply a lot and it does a beautiful job on the skin as well as between the eyebrows. The tip is little creamy and last all day. I have very dry skin so this is perfect for me. I have become obsessed with eyebrows and tried different things but I wasn't really happy until i found this pencil. I bought pencil number 4.5 and i feel that it is little too dark for me. I am going back to buy a shade lighter.
It's a must
Beckyboo from Washington
I am obsessed! I work for hours at a time around grease, fryers, hot ovens, and a lot of steel but my eyebrows are still in perfect condition. I will be buying again.
Julie W. from Plainfield, IN
Was contemplating microblading. Tried this, and it's absolutely the best brow pencil I have ever used. Perfect match shade, and will be definitely buying again.
I would buy it again and again!!
Daisy from San Mateo
I love this eyebrow pencil! I bought this five times already. I tried a lot of eyebrow pencils and this is the best!
Best brow pencil i have used !
Liz from Fredericksburg Va
I have tried several brow pencil because I have thin brows and I believe a well shaped brow is the key to a perfect look. This pencil worked well for me as I am not a professional makeup artist.
Benefits tests on animals - this is NOT cruelty free
e333 from Portland, OR
I loved this pencil and don't get me wrong, it works well and is easy to use. BUT I recently discovered that Benefit is NOT a cruelty-free company (a quick internet search will verify this). They do allow their products to be tested on animals in China. Nice eyebrows are great but I don't want to support a company that doesn't align with my values. So I looked for a cruelty-free brand to switch to on my last trip to Ulta and found that Anastasia Beverly Hills Brow Definer Pencil has a really similar design and is a good dup for this. I can have nice eyebrows and a clear conscience. Bye-bye Benefit!
This one is a keeper!
CydneyC from Dallas
I love the angled edge, making it easy to apply while not overdoing it.
I would buy again
Wyogal from Riverside County
Very fine line...excellent for geatheting
I have bought this product again and again
CoJoWa from Idaho Falls , Idaho
I draw/fill in my eyebrows every day
Music lover 18 from Orland Park
First brow pencil that actually fills in my sparse eyebrows. Highly recommend!!
Gigi from Florida
I love it. The only product that works for me.
Rosy from Newport News VA
Drawing on eyebrows is an art .. and this product is excellent and easy to use.