Product Reviews Rated 4.3 out of 5 stars
2446 Reviews
Most Helpful Positive Review Loving it! I have short straight lashes that can't curl and I'm always skeptical of any new mascara I decided to give lash paradise a try and I'm really happy," I applied 3 coats" No clumps, my lashes look fuller and longer the best part is the brush I feel like it really covers every single lash
Most Helpful Critical Review Great after a couple uses, then gets clumpy!! I bought this two weeks ago along with the lash primer and I am so disappointed. This will now be my second tube of the same mascara that has done this. I wanted to love this so much but I can't if it just keeps clumping and drying out on me. I will not recommend this to anyone.
Reviewed by 2446 customers Love this product 5
ozarkair from st louis mo
This is the best mascara. I have tried so many brands and they all clumped up or would be shedding after having on. This mascara goes on smooth and does not come off during the day. I will definitely be sticking with this brand for a long time.
Wouldn't buy again 1
Apeck from Mesa, Az
Was clumpy after a few uses. I have always had long thick lashes. Have been using this about 2 months, and have had a severe thinning and shortening of my lashes since using. At first had a hard time removing it, then bought remover specifically for it. Still lost lashes. Will be going into the trash.
Amazing! 5
Ba from Ohio
Holds a curl and makes my lashes look amazing! Gonna try the non waterproof one next!
Awesome mascar 5
Edis from Nj
i Usually get lash lifts and tints but i haven't been able to recently and i haven't even bothered with mascara because i never get the results i want but my friend suggested this one and it's AMAZING!! makes me like i have the lash lift and dramatically changes my face.
Great product! 5
Gk from US
Looks really pretty, it is hard to remove but I found that baby oil does the trick! It's my new favorite mascara! Definitely a dupe for the better than sex mascara!
Overrated 1
Jen from Bakersfield CA
It doesn't look like I'm wearing mascara, if you like extreme natural looks this is better for you but I personally dislike it
Great, just not perfect 5
Steph from San Diego
I would rate this 4.5. I have repurchased this mascara several times. It is the best one that I have so far, but I do have some criticism.
-Volume is great, no negatives on that!
-Not many mascaras hold my curl, and this one does a really good job at that. Usually drier formulas are what work best for that, just mind the trade off that it will dry out and clump a little quicker than "wet" mascaras. That's fine with me though.
-The only downside for me is that it does smudge a bit on my under-eye area throughout the day, yet it's really hard to remove. I make sure to powder my under-eye pretty well and it has helped withe the smudging, but not completely. However, a lot of mascaras do that on me, and this one is not the worst one.
Great mascara for the price! 5
Chloe32 from Chicago, IL
I really like this waterproof mascara. I have long bottom lashes, and as such regular mascara leads to constant smudges under my eyes all day long. I switched to using this waterproof mascara on my bottom lashes, and they look great! No more smudging. Definitely recommend for bottom lashes or for day to day.
Extremely Clumpy 1
Jaimie from Charles Town, WV
I normally use LORAC Pro but it hasn't been in stock. Super smooth mascara. I tried this and hated it. It's super clumpy and gobs onto lashes sticking them together with blobs of product - even after I wiped the majority of product off the brush. If you want a professional look with lashes coated separately, I would not recommend. Invest in a product used by pros.
AMAZING 5
aj from texas
this is the best mascara i've found and used. a lot does come out but if you just wipe it on the top you're good.
Overall, Ok 3
your average person from California
I'm not a makeup expert at all, this is just my opinion from my experience. It does give you volume, its quite visible. That being said, I agree with most people when it comes to the formula. My eyes definitely felt dry after a couple of hours of wearing it. when it came time to wash my makeup off, this is one stubborn mascara. I used all types of remover, from typical makeup remover, to coconut oil, and it left my eyelashes feeling extremely icky. they felt dry, and honestly, I thought they were going to fall off.
love this mascara 5
emily from charlotte nc
it is truly a dupe for the too faced better than sex mascara. it's not clumpy like the too faced mascara tends to be. definitely recommend!
Wouldn't recommend 1
Maddie from New York
It holds a curl but when you go to take it off it's really hard to do so and it made my lashes fall out more then other waterproof mascaras. If you don't like clumpy mascara it's not the mascara to go with clumps a lot and it dried out after only 3 weeks!
Do not buy this 1
E from HI
Putting on this mascara is such a hassle .
I scrape off a lot of the mascara on the brush and still have a lot of blobs on my eyelashes.
Very difficult to remove too!
Definitely a must not buy.
I bought this because it was cheap and had good ratings but I rather not do that again.
Disappointed 2
Disappointing from Washington
I really wanted to like this mascara. It held a curl and defined the lashes ok but after a couple hours of wear here come the raccoon eyes! Guess I'll go back to tube mascara or false lashes.
Love the volume- hate the formula 3
Okay mascara from 44070
I loved the way this mascara made my eyelashes look it holds the curl very nicely and almost looked like I was wearing falsies!! However, it is soooo drying on the eyes it felt like I was wearing cheap false eyelashes. This is just my preference and my personal experience so also take that into consideration. but I think I'm gonna try the regular version of this mascara. It's worth a try though because everyone is different so what might not work for me, may work for you!! :)
Great for Asian lashes 5
CF from PA
My lashes are short, straight and never hold a curl. The formula is not clumpy as others say it is but I just opened the package 2 days ago. The brush gave good coverage with 2 coats, dried quickly and my lashes did not go limp. Haven't had an issue with flaking or smudging throughout the day and was easy to remove with Neutrogena's oil free makeup remover. One of the better waterproof mascaras I've used for sure.
Messy 1
Glamojazz from New York City
Clumpy, messy, thick, hard to take off even with makeup remover. I'm not sure how this is has high ratings.
Strong Smell. Clumpy 2
Aimz from Jersey
I had high hopes for this. First thing I noticed was the very strong smell. I tried it anyway and it was super clumpy. Eye lashes clumped together and was impossible to fix.
Great mascara, terrible brush 4
MN Mom from Minneapolis MN
Love the mascara, even better when I used a different brush from an old Clinique mascara. The brush doesn't apply evenly, just weird design
Giving away 2
Hanna from Pennsylvania
There's way to much product on the brush so it makes a mess. I understand that it's waterproof but it's insanely hard to get off and makes my lashes look clumpy
I would not buy again 2
swmr4lyf from Atlanta, GA
I am not happy about how it is so difficult to remove with eye make up remover. Its crazy hard! I also was not impressed with my lashes with it on.
best mascara on the planet… really 5
DL from New York City
I have straight asian lashes that are a decent length (only because of grande lash) and I could never really find a mascara that holds the curl well even after using my shiseido eyelash curler. This is literally the best mascara for people with lashes like mine, and I've seen many people with long/curled natural lashes enjoy this mascara as well. I personally don't think it's hard to take off, I use almay makeup wipes.
Been using this mascara for over 2 years! 5
cindilou99 from NY
After years of buying expensive mascara's, falling prey to all they hype, I finally found what I was looking for!
I have straight eyelashes and this is the best for keeping them curled. I have to use a eyelash curler, but I do not mind, since I have always used one, but with this mascara, no wilting eye lashes for m now!
Nice formula but not a great brush 4
Brendagaylex from Fort Worth, tx
It's a nice formula but sticks my eye lashes together a bit. I used a separator brush but it still didn't quite come apart. I think it would be better with a different brush.
