Rated 4.05 out of 5 stars
Most Helpful Positive Review Best yet!
After several tries of the vast array of concealers past years, FINALLY found this product while out browsing/shopping. It has to be new. Instead of a typical under eye remedy cover ...perhaps I was looking not in the right direction, so-to- speak, but, instead thought a much I needed correctiveness. So, I purchased this product. Rushed home, placed in on my under eyes and wham! Away went the dark holloweness and my tired eyes literally popped with youthfulness! Included a photo for you to see Left eye WITH product/Right eye WITHOUT. Beyond thrilled with the results ....pure ecstatic happiness! I am 53, blonde hair, light/med peachy pinky skin tone.
Most Helpful Critical Review Useless after 2 weeks!
I love the smooth application, love the color (charcoal) and love how long it last on my eyes.BUT...I tried every method suggested to sharpen the tip after two weeks of use and the design and composition (hard plastic) of this pencil totally sucks! I bought 3 different cosmetic sharpeners and just when I thought I was making progress, the tip of the eyeliner broke off. I read every review here when I couldn't figure out how to get more product out. I followed all the suggestions - this item is going in the trash and I will go back to Ulta Waterproof eyeliner. Do not waste your money on this product until they make it in a twist holder.
Reviewed by 6621 customers Overall really great
jazrod34 from United States
This is a really good concealer for dark circles. If you have really bad dark circles ( side note: i do get sleep it's just genetics), this concealer is pretty great on covering them. Alone, if covers the vast majority of them but not a huge amount of coverage. I use the neutralizer shade under my usual concealer and it works great at canceling out my dark circles.
Love this product!
K from Chicago, IL
I love these concealers!
No I will not buy again.
Geni from Amarillo Tx
I bought this product and it doesn't work, nothing comes out.So no I will not buy this again..
Best under eye concealer
M from United States
Best concealer for under eyes! Covers them up with one swipe of product and brightens at the same time which is amazing, would never replace this product. Can also be used to highlight your face! Definitely not to be used for blemishes though, which isn't its intended purposes anyways.
Use a blender sponge!
Sarah from Ohio
When I first bought this I was pretty underwhelmed, but it was mostly because of the sponge on the stick. It's awful and won't blend if you actually use enough product to cover up dark circles. I have several broken capillaries around my eyes due to coughing from my severe asthma. I'm really self conscious about them and have tried SO many concealers. This is actually the only one that's worked for me without creasing! I've found the trick for me is to apply a liberal amount of product and then press it into my skin with a blender sponge. Four stars only because it's annoying to have to use another tool when the packaging comes with a sponge already on it!
The MUST HAVE
Katgirl from Ulta Beauty in Leesburg
I LOVE this concealer!!! I would say this is my favorite concealer. It's not only affordable but the applicant is very smooth and cream, which blends easy on foundation, tinted, powder foundation, or bb.
would not recommend
Jasmin from Taylor Texas
i got it because i heard good things about it, but when i used it the color came out good in the beginning with good coverage but after 10 minutes it would be like i never put on anything it would just disappear.
I would buy this again
Grace from Rayland
super natural and doesn't crease or cake!
zodiac lover from Minnesota
i like to put concealer on with my fingers, and a lot of the time when i use certain concealers and blend it in with my fingers, it gets very cakey. this doesn't do any of that! one thing i kind of find a little gross is the application. it is a little unsanitary, because i don't want it touching my face all the time. otherwise, best concealer if you want that natural look!
Ms.Bee86 from Garland, Tx
This is by far my favorite black eyeliner. It glides on so effortlessly and stays on all day. I've tried many but this is still my go to!
Skylar from San Diego
I'm 34 and every concealer I try under my eyes especially Shape tape settles into the lines around my eyes but not this!!! I've been wearing it for 8 hours under my eyes and it still looks good.
Not special anymore
Helen from Seattle, WA
I think the formula has changed for the worse since it was released several years ago. I remember the Age Rewind being very high coverage, thick and creamy, and applies very smoothly. It also advertised having special ingredients like Goji Berries. That has changed. The new formula seems a lot thinner, lower in coverage, and sometimes streaky. It doesn't cover my dark circles like it used to. I can still make it work well for me and I have a good color match, but it's just like any normal concealer now. I'm disappointed that my holy grail has disappeared.
It's a no for me
Sierra from Virginia
It's so thick and cakey! I bought a concealer and contour shade and didn't like them at all! Will be returning
Who Knew that Maybelline Produces the Best Cover-up?
Retired Fashion Editor from New York City, NY
This Maybelline Cover-up is the best of all of its kind. If you read the label clearly enough, you will understand why it is so effective. It's not just any old Cover-up, it's a SERUM as well. The sponge tip works as its own makeup applicator so effectively that there is no need to use a separate sponge. Yes, it hides dark circles and skin imperfections, but the most amazing thing about this product is that it doesn't accentuate the wrinkles around my eyes. I'm not sure why it glosses right over them and doesn't settle into the deeper ones, but I am not looking for answers when a product works so well!!!
Kerrie from Buffalo NY
Covers under eyes
HollyW from Springfield, Massachusetts
This works for me! Covers undereye darkness and blemishes, goes on smooth
Best concealer and under eye corrector ever!
Mom life from Mi
Love the concealer but the under eye corrector is absolutely perfect! Better than my high end ones.
HKoch from Liverpool NY
You wouldn't think an inexpensive product like this concealer would be amazing, but it is. Hands down one of the best concealers I have ever used. It blends easily and gives amazing coverage especially if you have blemishes or imperfections you want to cover up.
Lainnie from USA
I've been using this concealer for years and it always puts on perfectly and covers as much as you apply. I would recommend to anyone who needs a decently priced concealer.
Dona from Virginia
This concealer goes on creamy smooth for a nice matte finish. However. It did not completely cover my very dark under eye circles. I have a fair complexion. For best results, store product "upside down." This makes it flow out much easier !
Zero stars. Sensitive skin beware- chemical burns
SofiaD from Memphis, Tennessee
I bought this on a whim because I had seen it had won a beauty award. I typically use tarte or Lancome concealer and have never had a problem. I used this twice and have chemical burns under my eyes. It's been two weeks and they still haven't healed. If you have sensitive skin avoid this at all costs.
Always use this
Mari from Pnw
I own shape tape and have had it for 4yrs but I never use it. I always use this maybelline concealer in neutralizer. It gives me a natural finish with great blendability, I use my finger cause I'm a mom with no desire to sit forever to do my makeup. I've used this concealer for at least 8 years. It lasts a while and I love the shade especially. My skin tone was always hard to match in the 90s and early 2000s. Only til recently when brands started expanding their shade range have I found my shade. I will repurchase for life.
It's okay the scent not it
Scent not it from Ulta in pa
It worked fine however everything about the sent make me not a fan of this product. It has like a plasticky and chemically smell
Kay from Michigan
I love this product a lot more than I ever thought I would. I've spent 4x this much on other concealers, but this is by far the best I've ever used, personally. It blends very well and can be used alone or with foundation. 10/10. Will buy again. And again.
I had low expectations but I'm pleasantly surprised
Rin from New Jersey
This is my first time using this product despite it being out for a pretty long time. I was always hesitant to use it for some reason, but with the TikTok buzz surrounding this product I thought I'd finally give it a try. I thought I'd hate it but I'm actually pleasantly surprised. It went on smoothly and it was easy to blend with just my ring finger. I left off one star because I have to see how it wears throughout the day, but upon first application I think I'm going to like this. It doesn't even feel like I need to set it; it's dry enough to leave on its own, but so far it hasn't made my under eyes look dry or cakey. It actually has a nice satin finish, which I wasn't expecting. I'm excited to keep using this with different primers, moisturizers, and a beauty blender!