Rated 4.32 out of 5 stars
Most Helpful Positive Review Wig: Snatched
I am SO glad that I was able to get my hands on this product! I love the fact that this palette was curated for those with darker people who are often an after-thought in the beauty community. SO proud of Jackie and appreciative to Anastasia for giving her a chance. xoxo
Most Helpful Critical Review Vibrant black true matte liner but not waterproof
I love how a cat eye looks on me & only use liquid liner to help me create a precise fine line with a flicked out wing. I received this liquid liner vox box complimentary in exchange for my honest opinions I was thrilled because liquid liner is a staple in my makeup bag. The new liquid liner by Anastasia Beverly Hills is formulated to be highly pigmented water-resistant with a matte finish. I have to admit that this liquid liner has a better color pay off than my current favorite liner. It does have a true black matte finish. The formulation does stay wet for a little while but once it dries down it stays put & doesn't become dry or flaky throughout the day. One difference I noticed for abh's formulation is that it is labeled as water resistant instead of water proof. What this means is that it's a water based formulation & will not withstand watery eyes crying or rainy weather which is a little problematic as far as creating a winged liner that lasts all day in certain conditions. This means that when it becomes wet this liquid liner will smudge & rub off completely so keep that in mind. Another feature of this liner is the the soft felt-tip applicator. It claims to allow you to make thin precise lines. I have to say that this applicator is not friendly to beginners as it's a long soft & thin applicator making it flexible which I find makes it hard to give you stability when attempting to draw a thin line. I personally am not a fan of this applicator compared to my favorite liquid liner because I find it harder to be precise with this long & flexible felt tip applicator. When it's not wet this formulation holds up well during the day & survived me rubbing my eyes throughout the day. Overall this is a nice vibrant matte finish liquid liner but does not replace my current favorite because it's water resistant not water proof and the applicator makes it difficult to create even thin lines. I rate it 3.0/5.0.
Reviewed by 906 customers Best eyeliner !!!
Mary from Downey
Best eyeliner it's super black and stays on all day and doesn't smudge... I tried a lot of different ones but this is the best I've tried
Jennifer Lopez from Escondido ca.
Love it!!!! No smudging and lasts all day , glides on easy.
Will Buy Again and Again!
Khoney from Sacramento CA
I don't usually write reviews but I had to let others know how great this product is. I've been doing a winged liner long before it was so popular, and this product is the best I've used! The felt-tip applicator makes it easy to draw the SHARPEST winged liner and allows you to really control your application. It also doesn't flake off or run. This will be my go to from now on!
Beva from undisclosed
I am unhappy with this product, I got an allergy reaction my eyes are puffy and watery :(
One of my favorite liners
abhfan from Fredericksburg
This liner definitely has a learning curve if you're used to the usual felt tip pen. Its formula is not very quick drying, but don't blot at it because it ruins the liner's pigment. My only complaint is that it's easy to waste/lose product so it has only lasted me 6 months, though now I know how to waste less. It definitely beats Stila or KVD in its pigment and longevity over shadow and glitter
Clar from Dallas
It's true to color very solid black and a little goes a long way
Laurenm3114 from Greenville, SC
I got this in the Norvina collection box that I purchased and fell absolutely in love with it! I love liquid eyeliner and have used them for years. This one goes on flawlessly and is very easy to get the perfect point with! Highly recommend!
Stephanie from Illinois
I use eyeliner daily usually on top of powder eyeshadow. This is the first day I used this and am so impressed! It went on very easily and stayed on all day! Washes off super easily also
Don't waste your $
Cyn from Orange County
This is way overhyped. It smudges everywhere doesn't even stay on for an hr. I wish I would've just gotten the stila one. Don't recommend.
Lu from Arlington Va
I love this eyeliner. It's very solid black and beautiful. I use it on my inner upper lash line and it's great. I used to use the Anastasia one that they have it the little glass pot but throughout the day it would go to the corners of my eyes and not be good but this doesn't do that and I'm so happy I bought it
Klint from San Antonio, TX
REALLY nice eyeliner. Worth the money! Dries super fast and does not smear. Very pigmented and precise for sleek and precise application.
Queenlovie insta from Los angeles
Great eyeliner nothing bad to say 5 stars I'll be purchasing again
Where have you been?!
Essi from Chicago,IL
Perfect lines and stays on for a long time. Everything I have been looking for in an eyeliner ❤️
I love Anastasia
Joanna from Palmdale
Obviously, I love the product but the shipping is so expensive
Jmommy from California
Really nice and dries super quick, so no smudging.
Julie from kentucky
The formula is very wet and I find it hard to control. Could just be a learning curve because I'm used to more of the pen style. I wish it was more water and smudge proof.
beautiful opaque matte black
babi teeth from Florida
the tip is wonderful, it's long and applies like a dream. its not too watery and not too thick. the tip doesnt dry out before you finish your wing like most eyeliners, and I wear big wings. my only complaint is that it's not waterproof at all, and I have to touch up around the outer corners of my eyes, but only once per wear. the tip could also be a little sharper, I mostly use this eyeliner to fill in the space and use a bent needle to give myself the perfect sharp line to begin with. it's a perfect matte, and not sheer at all. I def reccomend.
Dare I say wow!?
Alaesa from Minneapolis, MN
I moved from using gel eyeliner to liquid eyeliner from fenty, I was having so many issues with fenty that I needed a new eyeliner. I used one of stila's liquid liner which was good but I wanted something different. Someone suggested this and this is the best eyeliner ever. I love that it dries matte and not shiny like the rest. It does take a second to dry but that's fine with me! It also stays on forever but comes off so easily and doesn't irritate my eyes! Love it.
r from Portland
i was a felt tip liner lover, but this liner made my life so much easier! using liners like this, in my experience, usually create a heavier set liquid that's hard to build up. the anastasia liner isn't like that at all, it's so easy to build and fix, and gives you the ability to create! stays in place, will continue to buy :)
Not as great as I hoped
Tarah from undisclosed
This comes in a sleek little tube and has a nice brush to apply but it smudges really easily. It's hard to correct a mistake because any bit of water that touches will mess up the whole line. I probably would use something else If I was going to buy it myself I ended up being able to make it look decent in the end
Good but not waterproof
Amanda from undisclosed
I love this liner ira perfectly matte. With that being said it is NOT waterproof and the slightest amount of moisture causes it to run. It's also now beginner friendly as the felt tip is hard to apply. Once you practice it gets easier and it's become a staple in my routine. It lasts throughout the day as long as water doesn't come in contact with it.
Overall good liner
Kate from undisclosed
This liner is great because it is so opaque and the formula of the liner is fantastic. The handle of the liner was a little too small for my likings being that it is a dip and not a pen like I am used to so it was hard for me to properly apply. I ended up getting the hang of it and really liked it! I received this product complimentary
My new go to eyeliner!!
chrissydh from undisclosed
This is a really great waterproof product. The wand is precise so it takes a little practice. I've used a pen for years so it took some adjustment. Once I got the hang of it I couldn't get enough! Its my new favorite! It stays on for a good part of the day and still is easy to remove at the end of the day-which is what I mean by not 100% water proof. Will it smudge a bit ignore it gets wet and you wipe it yes. But for me this is more of a pro. The removal is a breeze. It's lovely and matte and doesn't flake!! I'll buy it again and again. 4 stars because the wand takes some getting used to but I love it.
Jess from undisclosed
Good eyeliner. Love using the felt tip. Nothing to complain absout
The BEST eyeliner out right now
Kae from undisclosed
This product is AMAZING!! I received this product as a free sample and I'm use it EVERYDAY!.. Completely obsessed with the finish of the product.. so beautiful. One of the BEST eyeliners out. Definitely recommended for daily use