Rated 3.54 out of 5 stars
Most Helpful Positive Review Glides on and long lasting
I have this eyeliner in the brown and the purple, and am about to get it in the blue. I love that this eyeliner actually stays on my bottom lashes all day and doesn't smudge, both when I've worn it in my lash line and in my waterline. The only cons I've noticed are that it makes a pretty thick line, and the purple isn't very bold. I don't understand all the reviews saying the pencil won't "roll up" so you can't use it once the tip is gone. It's a PENCIL- it's not supposed to roll up- you sharpen it. I just use a regular eyeliner pencil sharpener, and I've never had a problem.
Most Helpful Critical Review Impossible to sharpen.
What you see at the end of the pencil when you buy it is really all you get. I tried multiple times to sharpen it the end just kept getting chewed up and coming off in my hand. I ended up using a brush to dig it out with and try to line with that and it really didn't work. Otherwise I love the color and I love the product but It's impossible to sharpen you'll never get it sharpened
Reviewed by 172 customers Goes on easy
Lisa from Fredericksburg, VA
This eyeliner goes on so smooth!!
Long lasting wear without smudging
Amber Desiree' from Oklahoma City
I have had a lot of trial and error with eyeliner- this one stays in place from 7am-10pm with no issues
Definitely a great buy
Mom of 3 from Orange county
I was debating on whether or not I should buy a prestige brand eyeliner but decided to try this one first. I'm glad I did because this liner is great and stays on for a long time and looks great after 8 hours.
Adequate - held up through a summer outdoor graduation
E the gardener from Denver, CO
I wanted a waterproof, stay put, eyeliner for my combination skin. This product met my needs. Since you only get the tiny amount of product at the end of a plastic pencil with no ability to sharpen, I WILL NOT by the product again.
Best eyeliner ever!
Taylor from San Antonio, Tx
I absolutely love this liner. It lasts all day and the colors are great. I tried it on my hand and it lasted all day even through dishes and a shower. I had to get make up remover to get it off my hand. I'm not sure why other reviewers are having a hard time sharpening the pencil. It's pretty easy and straight forward.
A from Orange County, NY
Was able to tightline my eyes really easily and I am no pro!
Lasted all day and stayed in place despite my watery eyes (allergies).
This pencil eyeliner is great to use
Lei from LOUISIANA
I love using waterproof pencil eyeliner. It last a long time
SammiStarr from Collegeville PA
The lid was on too tight. The tip broke off trying to take the lid off. I had to sharpen it to use it. The gel was messy. I had it all over my hands and face.
Jean from Villages Fl
Have used this product for years
Tip broke when I opened it. Difficult to sharpen
JBran from Washington state
The tip on this pencil broke when I opened it and it's difficult to sharpen. I managed to get it on my eyelid it does look nice but maintain ing the pencil is a pain!
Great eyeliner pencil
TerriK from Middletown NY
This is a great eye pencil! Goes on smooth and lasts all day or night.
ButtercupTX from Houston, TX
This eyeliner is waterproof and smudge proof. My favorite color is bronze; reminds me a lot of the MAC Teddy eyeliner. I have both and can never decide which to use, because they have similar texture and it goes on very smoothly! Would order again, especially since this is cheaper. 👍🏼
Trudy from Exton, PA
Don't buy it!
I would never buy this product again
Vicki from Memphis TN
I actually paid way too much for this pencil for it not to do what it's supposed to it done I would never purchase one again
I have not found one that's better
Meg 66 from Saylorsburg PA
I love this eyeliner. I use this eyeliner anytime!
Sharpens just fine
Reesiekins from Covina, CA
Not sure why so many people are complaining that they're having a hard time sharpening this pencil, I can sharpen it just fine. Maybe they're using cheap or dulled sharpeners? I have this in Brown and purple. I love the richness of the colors and it really does stay all day long without smudging, at this price point it's now my go- to eyeliner- going to buy more colors
barbara from bridgeview, il
got a sample so i had to buy it
I will buy this product again
Sherry from Chico California
Haven't had a chance to use this yet, will be soon. Cobalt Blue is one of my favorite colors and looks great.
Good color for waterliner
Coffee lover from Crofton,Md
I like this as a waterliner to brighten my eyes. I like the color better than some others I've tried. It seems to stay on good if you put something on top of it to set it. It goes on very smooth.
Catherine from Rockville pa
Nancy from Lisbon, CT
Was so excited to try this product, since so many others that I've used smudged and didn't last very long. Infallible, Pro-Last....not :(
I wouldn't buy again
JR from Tampa, FL
I bought this to line my inner lower eye lid. It goes on nice but doesn't stay in place. Raccoon eye city. No eyelashes due to chemo and the lower liner makes my eyes look nice. Even though it's waterproof it still runs off.
Tip for sharpening
Candy from Wisconsin
Put the pencil in the freezer for 15 minutes (I just leave mine in there when not in use) use a clean sharpener then gently roll the tip on a tissue to get the point to your liking. You'll get a long life out of this pencil. I hope this helps all who are frustrated and throwing it out. It really is a good product, it could just use a better design.
I would buy this product again
Meme from Norfolk VA
Goes on smooth - waterproof best I've tried over expensive brands
Pzin from Ohio