Rated 3.46 out of 5 stars
Most Helpful Positive Review Fairly Light Neutral
Tarte's best concealer imo. Super emolliant- great for aging eyes/dry under eyes. Great shade range. Blends great ~ I use a brush & immediately set w/trans loose powder. I have a TON of concealers & I always come back to this one especially when I really want my makeup to look flawless.
Most Helpful Critical Review worst
This is not creaseless! It's super tacky. It settled into my under eye creases even with setting it, and started creasing right away, only to crease worse as hours passed. It also caused my mascara to smudge under my eyes because it was so sticky it just grabbed it. Because of all the creasing it made my under eyes look even more aged. It also appeared extremely cake even though I used bare minimum and blended well. I'm not sure how, but somehow this concealer seems to grab every possible concealer flaw available and put them all right under my eyes. Definitely a no for me. I have very dry under eyes so this should have been a good concealer for me, it just wasn't.
Reviewed by 428 customers Love
Stamper from Ky
I have naturally really dark circles under my eyes and now that I'm a mom of 4 those dark circles are nearly impossible to cover. I ordered Creaseless and Shape Tape and the Creaseless covers so much better!! I love it and will never use anything else
Cyntiap from Albuquerque NM
I purchased this based on Hot N Flashy's recommendation as her new holy grail concealer and, although I usually love her product recs, I think this is a miss for me. Maybe Tarte's concealers just aren't good formulations for my under eye, I don't know. Both this concealer and Shape Tape (which I know lots of people love) are very thick. I've tried working with this concealer for several weeks now, making sure my under eye is moisturized, applying small amounts, using a dedicated concealer brush to blend it out (my usual methods for concealing this area) and it immediately creases. I then have to spend a extra minute resmoothing the area and THEN it looks okay and will be somewhat creaseless for maybe 6 hours, after which the creases are back. It's too bad because I do get good coverage and I have a good color match but I think I'm still looking for my own holy grail concealer.
I'm pretty impressed
Kendra from Seattle
I have some fine lines that popped up in the past couple years and normal concealer just sits in the lines and makes them more noticeable. I've tried EVERYTHING to get rid of them and the under eye concealers that I have tried for fine lines ended up not lasting very long if they did work because i have such oily skin.
This product works rather well! It does make fine lines less noticeable and doesn't budge all day even on my oil slick skin. The only down side is that it doesn't cover dark circles as well as regular shape tape. But if i'm picking and choosing my battles, I'll take fewer fine lines and slight dark circles over the crease city most concealers create under my eyes. Will be purchasing again!!
Too thick and greasy
Mari from Chicago
This concealer is WAY too thick and greasy. It is also very hard to blend since it is too sticky.
Bee from Saint Charles. MO
I love tarte products, but this concealer definitely creases if I don't blend it well enough. Great coverage though.
Love/hate relationship. Returning it.
Curljunkie from NC
I used this as my under eye concealer because I have dry skin. It's tacky, but I didn't mind that because I liked the way it covered and the luminous brightening finish. I lightly dusted it with setting powder because I read that would help it last throughout the day. It's gorgeous for the first 3 hours. Covers SO well. But after a few more hours, it creases like crazy!!!
Works great on my older eyes!
Melissa from OK
I love the texture of this concealer. I use it under my eyes and it really resists creasing throughout the day. Best concealer I have tried so far!!
Meant for Undereyes...GREAT for Acne
Keara M. from New York
I love this concealer for covering cystic acne or even just super red and swollen spots on my face. It's super hydrating so you don't get that "flaky" skin look, but it will not budge. As a super pale, and naturally red person, this covers better than most other (and more expensive) concealers I've tried.
CC89 from Annapolis, MD
This has been the best concealer I've ever used. I have dry under eyes and it's the only one that doesn't crease on me. I have trouble with concealer/foundation matching my skintone but this one matches perfectly. I use a dot in my inner corner and a small dot on my outer corner and use my ring finger to tap it in. It turns out beautifully as a tiny bit goes a really long way and looks very natural. The problem is that this concealer STINKS so bad. I thought I could power through it but no. It smells like the UD All Nighter spray. It smellls like dried spit and it's repulsive. If I can smell it all day then I'm sure other people can too and they think I smell like spit. How gross. I'm not sure if I can finish this tube. I definitely won't be buying this again and it's such a bummer because I really loved this. I'm just really sensitive to smells.
I would never buy again
Janice from Florida
too hard to blend
Wanted to love it, but nope.
Meg from Colorado
I really wanted to love this product because it has so many positive reviews. But sadly it doesn't work for me. It's too think and chunky. It doesn't blend smoothly (I think because of how fast it dries) and it ends up looking very unnatural.
Katy 🌺 from Fl
I love this product covers my red spots so good and doesn't feel heavy under my eyes and also love the color range
Best concealer I've used!
Nat from JBLM, WA
This is by far the best concealer I have ever had! I've used another tart concealer and never loved it. This one is amazing! Feels good on, not heavy and blends perfectly!
Best concealer I've ever used
Not Kimmy from Thermal
Im one to enjoy a new a concealer and I wasn't so sure about this one when I bought it but I fell in love it, I have acne prone skin and it's perfect, doesn't crease or dry up right away, it blends very well, i personally love this concealer better than the shape tape, i will definitely be buying more
Lfavara from Staten Island, NY
Best under eye concealer
kyndal from none yee bidnessss
it's better for dry under eyes otherwise don't get this product
Wonderful concealer for dry undereyes
TrainerDi from KCMO
I had avoided this concealer due to negative reviews by a YouTuber. But a different YouTuber that is more like me gave a more descriptive review of who this concealer is aimed at. This concealer is for those with dry skin. It's too emollient for oily skin. I do my best to plump and hydrate my undereyes before application. A little goes a long way and I only apply it toward the inner undereye where there's more purple. Then I tap it in with my ring finger. I set it with Pat McGrath under powder and it lasts for about 9 hours.
Not for me
SammyJo from Washington
Depending on what you are looking for in a concealer, this could work for you. I don't like how sticky it is once applied and is too dewy looking. I only apply to my under eyes so I don't want it looking super wet. You could add powder on top but I like a more simple routine. I tried Nars concealer and that was more what I am looking for.
myboo from NV
This is the BEST concealer I have ever used - it actually covers my dark circles and helps the appearance of my sunken eyes. I have tried EVERYTHING on the market - nothing really does the trick. I do use some light pink (Becca) corrector first and then top with this concealer. I even was able to top with a light dusting of powder which I never do because it will settle in my fine lines
Tarte creaseless vs bye bye under eye
pinkbrown23 from California
I like it alot I use it the same way I would us bye bye under eye concealer very little goes a long way. I'm torn because I like both concealers but I like the fact that the tarte is in a tube its convenient and easy to use.
Good medium coverage concealer
Lizzostan95 from Inglewood, CA
The formula is very radiant and moisturizing. A lot goes a long way. I wouldn't recommend using this under your eyes if you're going for a high coverage look because it does become cakey. I recommend this for a natural look because it brightens the face and makes it look more awake. Make sure to get a good shade match because it can be hard to blend out if you get the wrong shade
All Natural Look from Buckeye, AZ
This was my second purchase of this item and I enjoy and appreciate this time just as much as I did the last time.
my favorite concealer ever!!!!
Ulta Lover from Minnesota
I use this instead of makeup I use for spot coverage and due to the great color choices it matches my skin perfectly. I have tried many concealers and this is the product I always go back to. Product blends very easily and does not settle into my wrinkles.
I would buy it again but not if it's broken
Chena from New Jersey
I use it to cover dark spots and old acne scars!
LG from Las Vegas, nv
This is a pretty good concealer. It's difficult to blend but stayed on for hours.