Rated 4.3 out of 5 stars
Most Helpful Positive Review A solid everyday mascara
The two things I look for in mascara are how well it lengthens and thickens the look of my eyelashes (both with and without using a curler first), and whether or not it smudges on my face throughout the day. This mascara is excellent on both counts living up to the claims of being smudge proof and clump proof. The brush has a nice contour that adds some lift (although, I sill recommend using a curler first), and adds thickness without clumps. It isn't going to miraculously make you look like you are wearing fake eyelashes, but it does a nice job and absolutely didn't smudge during the day. Bonus points for the cool design.
Most Helpful Critical Review I wanted to love it...
but I don't. Biggest complaint is that it flakes really badly. After just a few hours I had noticeable flakes under my eyes. I tried it for a full week, hoping it was some fluke, but it wasn't. It's also fairly clumpy. I'll be returning it.
Reviewed by 1870 customers Too much for not lasting that long
Ag from Boston
Literally wears off in 30mins and the amount of fall out makes me look like a raccoon
GREAT WITH PRIMER
Britt from State*
I love this mascara with lash primer underneath. Otherwise it flakes.
long eyelashes after one coat!!
Sophia from Louisiana
I curled my lashes then put one coat of this on and it did not clump and made my lashes very long
Yessssss everyone should get it
Juju from Josh
It is so good in volume wow i was shocked, usually I use better than sex but this is even better if you don't want to look crazy.!!!!
Love love love this!
Jojo from Mississippi
Probably my favorite mascara ever! I normally wouldn't pay this much for mascara but I got a sample of this and I fell in love with it and I have been buying it ever since, it lasts so long and it doesn't clump like most mascaras do. I would definitely recommend this! Of course it's a personal preference and every one likes something different but if you are having a hard time just get it and try it!!
Disappointed in this Mascara
cielbleu from Wyckoff, NJ
I'm disappointed as it was highly recommended by Ulta Staff in-store
It was not what I expected
Neri from SLC
I purchased this mascara, because it was recommended by a store clerk as best mascara that gives you lift, definition and full lashes... I'm sorry to say that it does not. I will still use it, but will not purchase second time.
Meg from Philly
Mascara is the one makeup item I'm picky about and when I got a sample of this I stopped using the other expensive full sizes I had because this was so good!!! The biggest thing I notice is the added length to my lashes and I don't even need to use my primer! This is great and I want to continue using this one exclusively
Love! Love! Love!
Jakicakes from Ct
The wand is perfect and my lashes don't clump together like some other products. Best mascara I've ever used!!
I AM OBSESSED
Sarah from Dearborn Michigan
I use it for my everyday makeup. Which is just mascara and lipstick. It's easy to take off and the formula is just AMAZING
Better than Better Than Sex!
K S from NOLA
I've been a BTS user for YEARS and never thought I'd deviate. I'd been having issues with BTS starting to clump too much or smear, and wanted something similar but less clumpy. This is IT! I love this mascara. It gives crazy volume, but less mess! Highly highly recommend for those who are looking for a replacement BTS.
Really really good
jkay from Albany, NY
I normally use the Milk Kush Mascara but an employee recommended this as a dupe. The brush is almost identical and the mascara it's is awesome. Great for longwear. It is however really clumpy if you aren't careful while applying it. But other than that it's awesome!!!
lemon slice from chicago
Makes my eyes itch and my eyelashes fall out like CRAZY when removing gently with micellar water
Seriously my favorite
Jess from Dallas, TX
Obsessed with this, doesn't dry out and I feel like my lashes explode 💙 highly recommend
Good mascara in the beginning
Alison from Reno, NV
I really liked how it separated my lashes and definitely gave volume and length. Only problem was at the end day I did notice flaking under my eyes, enough to probably not buy it again sadly because I loved the look when I first put it on.
Just me from Louisville KY
I am really liking the Nars products!!
Darkkittykat from Connecticut
I bought the mini to try and I love it. I bought because my favorite make up Youtube make up guru likes it so I thought it must be good. It makes my eyes look so pretty and I love that it never gets little fibers in my eyes. I did use better than sex which is great also but, I always got little fibers I'm my eyes which is very annoying. This one does not do that whatsoever.
I LOVE IT
Erica from Los Angeles
A great mascara, but the lasting power is not there. It smudges and transfers too quickly.
LaReine from Brighton, Michigan
I received a sample of this mascara and it blew me away. Everyone was asking me if I was wearing false eyelashes. Really! I thought my eyelashes looked extra special, but when several people asked about my eyelashes, I knew it was not just me. It lasts all day. It is not waterproof, but I do not care!
Average quality and super smudgy
Ashleigh from South Bend, IN
I used this for a week as an everyday mascara. Halfway through my workday looks like I have black bags under my eyelids from the mascara! I don't touch my eyes during the day and am teaching, so no heavy work/sweating.
Coco from New York
This just ain't it. The brush does an awful job at grabbing lashes, it just turned into a smudgy blob of eyelash.
My Ultimate Favorite
SJGN from Phoenix, AZ
I love the soft formula, holds a curl, brush shape, but then my eyes started to become sensitive to it 😭😭😭 That's the only reason I docked a star. Right around 3pm everyday, my eyes would start to water and become irritated
Spider leg city
Hayyyyyleeee from San Diego ca
Okay- if you have time to finess this mascara it's not horrible. But it's truly not worth the effort. It's nice and black- the applicator has a nice thick brush with a ton of bristles. But you have to apply so many layers of product to get the same result as a mascara like bad gal bang.
Amazing volume eyelashes!
D.Cald from Conroe, TX
I got a free sample and loved it! Gave my eyelashes amazing volume and curl and thickness look. Not clumpy.
Sarah from Phoenix
This is such an incredible mascara. I love NARS but I was nervous to try at a high price. I'm SO glad I did! Easy to apply, great formula, and beautiful packaging. I could not ask for more. Does not run or flake. Worth every penny!