Rated 4.19 out of 5 stars
Most Helpful Positive Review Extremely long lasting!
So I got ve this mascara plus the epic ink eyeliner just before a kayaking trip to the beach and decided to put them through their paces.
I started my day at 930am and was on the beach around 11am and applying spray on sunscreen.
I was certain that was the end of it. But much to my surprise, there hours later we were still going strong!
I normally kayak in white water (I am usually on the wild section of the Chattahoochee or on the Chatoogga aka "the deliverance river") so kayaking in the Atlantic ocean surf gave me ample opportunity to practice my combat rolls, resulting in many exciting moments underwater and lots of waves in my face!
At the end of the day, it held up remarkably well! The mascara more than the eyeliner. But it never ran or streaked and maintained the fun grungy look all day!
Most Helpful Critical Review Not My Favorite
I received this as part of the sample program. I wear contacts, so I prefer a waterproof mascara. This just doesn't give me everything I'm looking for in a mascara. It does give some length, but very little volume. It's also a drier formula and because of the brush, I find it harder to work it into the base of my lashes. It also flakes, though that happens later in the day, so I do get several hours of non-messy wear. The color is fine. It takes a little work to remove, but for the most part it comes off with eye makeup remover. Lastly, this contains carmine, which I'm trying to cut out of my makeup collection, so it loses some points with me there, too.
Reviewed by 214 customers WORTH ALL THE HYPE!!!
mamasbeautycorner from Illinois
The only mascara that holds my curl! Best mascara!
Nini from Elgin Il
Love it stays on for a long time definetely worth it. && doesn't smudge
I have straight lash
. from Chicago
I have really straight lashes so I always use waterproof mascara, this mascara is one of my favorites i keeps the curl and last on humid weather
Worth the hype!!!
ximena_delangel from undisclosed
I do not have curly lashes at all, this mascara does not bring my lashes down after I've curled them and it does not smudgem. One tip for people with long lashes is to look down while applying it because this mascara will make your lashes reach your eyebrows and leave some residue on your eyelid, however, you can remove it once it has dried off.
Cheryl1 from New Mexico
Love this mascara. I have thin lashes so this helps hold a curl and bring a little more life back to my eyes.
I would buy this product again.
Pearl from Southern California
I love this product! I wear it every day for school and to go out. It lasts all day, does not flake and makes your eyelashes look great. Since it is waterproof, it is a little harder to take off than normal mascara, but as long as you use a makeup remover with oil in it, you should not struggle.
Really good water proof mascara
Lpeezy from Houston
This is my new go-to water proof mascara! I love it. Buildable, lengthening and separating, it does the job well! It is very hard to get off though.
Pinktina9 from Wallingford CT
Didn't do a thing for my lashes. Very light weight formula
Worth the hype for real
Eadon from Rhode Island
Really works well. It isn't very clumpy which is nice and lasts all day long.
Mgdesignone from Chicago, IL
I use this mascara every day, as well as for special occasions. I like how easy it is to apply, it goes on smoothly. The only con is that it does clump a little.
Dry and flaky
hellomars from L.A.
I returned it the day after I bought it. Formula is dry and it started flaking in under 2 hours!
asavc from new york, new york
This is a super nice lightweight waterproof mascara that i loveeee using. It works on your lower lashes nicely and doesn't tear or flake off. The only downside I have is that, because it is waterproof, it's really hard to take off.
Great for my Short and Fine Lashes
es from los angeles, ca
This mascara is a great "drug store" priced mascara. It doesn't flake for me. I have very short and fine lashes, but this gives it some volume and helps me look like my eyelashes exist. The formula is not difficult to use, and doesn't clump when you build up the product.
Loved the results hated the smudges
bianunez from indianapolis, indiana
Super good lengthening and volume! It's a shame after a few hours it smudged horribly under my eyes.
AnjiK from Melbourne, FL
This mascara is what I was looking for! Some waterproof mascaras are difficult to remove, but this one comes off with soap and water or makeup remover. I like the texture, but tends to clump with use. The first few uses were fine, then I noticed clumping after maybe 5 or 6. The wand/applicator is good. I still like the product - will buy again.
MacyLyn from philippines
Overall its hard to apply on the lower lashes on asian
SapphirRae from IL
definitely waterproof. adds length and separation but not too much volume. natural looking
Not worth the hype
katiekates66 from Iowa
I'm a huge NYX fan, so I'm really disappointed in this mascara. The first coat is fine, but the seconds clumps my lashes together so I get a Tammy Faye effect. Not a good look. I also think the brush is too big. Sorry to say this is not a winner for me.
worth the hype
Dymnlex from Las Vegas, NV
not so much worth the hype, the application was great, the color also great, but I had issues with it flaking off during the day
Made my eyes itch terribly!
40ish Mom of two from Canton, Ohio
I bought this for use in the pool and the first couple of days were fine but then every time after my eyes itched terribly right near the lash lines. I wanted to scratch my eyes out until I could wash my face!
NOT worth the hype
Corrine from Florida
The waterproof version is not waterproof, it just crumbled off my lashes part way thru the day.
LissaP from WI
NOT WATERPROOF! I wore this to a graduation where I was sweating in a hot school gym and it was coming off just from sweating. Not even close to waterproof!! Very disappointing!
BUY IT. Definitely worth the hype
Kellskjp from East mids UK
Due to mixed reviews, I really didn't know whether to buy this or not but my gut instinct told me to do so so I did. By far the best mascara I've ever used, my lashes look amazing and no clumpiness, they have never looked so full and long. I even have people asking me if I'm wearing false lashes, I will definitely recommend and will definitely be purchasing again. I am more than pleased with this product. I cannot praise it enough.
Hated this product!
JD from Hammond, LA
I tried this product because they no longer make Le Chic Flick, which was the waterproof mascara I used for several years. It left black smudges under my eyes after a short amount of time—definitely not waterproof. It smudged just with regular use, not even water involved.
Mindi from Ohio
Doesn't grab the lashes to good it take multiple coats to get any kind of length