Rated 4.29 out of 5 stars
Most Helpful Positive Review Works GREAT on the fine invisible lashes
This is an excellent product for anyone that can barely see their eyelashes. My bottom ones are fine and very light colored. Until I used this, I didn't realize that I had so many lashes. The brush made it very easy to apply at the base and reach each individual lash. I originally bought this because I liked the idea of having a liner and mascara in one product. Sadly, I can not get the eyeliner effect as it advertises. I wear it alone (natural look) and under mascara (dramatic look) and my lashes always get noticed. Other than it not working like a eye liner for me, it began drying out after only 3 weeks of use and started clumping a little. It is also more difficult to remove than waterproof mascara. STILL, I intend to add this to my make-up "must haves" because the look of my lashes when I wear it definately out weighs any negotives I have found on it.
Most Helpful Critical Review Misleading bottle size
I received a sample and fell in love with the product. So went to buy the actual real size. Was shocked at the amount of product is the exact same as what's in the sample size.
Reviewed by 846 customers It helps with coverage
PK from Fort Myers, FL
It helps to get the lashes close to the lid. This is important to me because I have blond lashes.
I would reccomend this mascara. Great product
Lea from OK
Best mascara for fine, thin eyelashes. No clumping.
Can't live without my Tightliner!!
Carol from Illinois
I use this everyday as part of my very simple makeup routine. I am over 50 years old and feel the need to apply makeup daily but have worked out a very simple and natural application. Tightline applied just to my upper eye lid waterline instantly makes my eyes look bigger and awake. I don't really apply to my lashes other than what naturally gets on them when tightlining. I use another mascara immediately after tightlining so the primer is still wet. I found that works best.
I like it.
Phyl from Philadelphia
I haven't used this one yet. But I've had it before. It adds just enough mascara for my age. I like it a lot. Every mascara ends up under my lower lids though. When I use this one, think I'll try a setting powder there.
Not impressed at at all
Missjo from Brookings, Oregon
I've used several primers but this one makes your lashes crunchy feeling and just about impossible to put a layer of mascara on top of it. Do not recommend
I would NOT by this product again, not what it is claimed to
Randi from Vancouver Washington
Does not fill in the lashes, cant even see the product once applied.
Adorable size and works beautifully!
Bee from Clio, Mi
I'm not gonna lie, the petite wand/brush of this product caught my eye when I saw it in store. I absolutely adore mini, and deluxe size sample products for their size. So cute!!!! I read some reviews and waited a couple weeks before ordering it online.
I absolutely love this product! Works beautifully on my lashes and does not irritate my sensitive skin/eyes. I have worn this alone and as a primer under mascara. I will purchase again.
Just what I was looking for!
misskitty0 from NJ
I wanted the conditioning properties of a natural primer, but with color - this is exactly that! My lashes are long already, so I don't need all the extras of mascara, which can be clumpy and irritating - plus looking unnatural. This goes on smoothly and darkens lashes while containing healthy ingredients. Does not bother my eyes. The brush is very, very skinny and as it advertises, you can press/wriggle at the root to create a subtle "lined" look. Highly recommend (and already have recommended to several friends). I'll definitely be buying more, and making this my only mascara. For those who want "more", remember it IS a primer so you're free to also add regular mascara. I love the look of it alone, though. Great product!
AJ from Burleson TX
I put this on first to coat my lashes from right at the root. Then I go back over from the mid lash line up with another mascara. Works great
I will buy this again!! Loved it!!
Tm from Alabama
Loved this product
Very very satisfied - I keep buying it
Christie from Oklahoma City
This product is excellent. I started using it when I wasn't able to get the clinique version and have liked this product much better. I use it like a light touch of "hairspray" for my lash extensions on top and it isn't heavy but keeps them perfectly in place. On my bottom lashes the fine brush is wonderful and I get a full look. There is no smudging at the end of a long day and it washes off effortlessly.
Feels like cheap mascara
Nell from Florida
The brush was far too thin and flimsy for proper mascara application. My lashes didn't have any volume, thickness or pop after using.
Love this mascara!
Steph from Reisterstown, MD
Love this mascara! Gets the hard to reach lashes and isn't heavy!
Perfect for Bottom Lashes
Kristy from Arkansas
I use this for my bottom lashes only. The brush coats and colors my bottom lashes perfectly. All the other mascara wands are much too big and leave my bottom lashes clumpy or with extreme fallout. I use this for my bottom lashes because it just colors them and lengthens them ever so slightly. Great product for that use!
I like this product.
Vickie from Harrisonburg Va
I like this product for days I am not dressing up. It colors my lashes but doesn't add bulk. On special days, I use it as intended and add a volume producing mascara.
Pretty great overall
Erin from Wyoming
I really like this mascara overall. It finds and defines each lash and separates them well. I would suggest adding the next layer of mascara (whichever one you choose) rather quickly because this dries somewhat hard. Also a little disappointed that the formula dries out in the bottle rather fast.
I won't buy this again
R from Illinois
I was looking forward to using this as some of the reviews were really good. I've not had that experience in the two weeks I've been using it. I don't think it's helped with volume or fullness. I don't like giving these types of reviews. Maybe I haven't let it dry long enough and put enough on to get the fullness/volume I'm looking for.
When you're in a hurry
Pat from Memphis
You can line your eyes at the waterline with little effort, then smush up to enhance your lashes. Doesn't have fibers to lengthen lashes but wouldn't work anyway
Will continue to use this
Reesie from NC
Love love love it. Keeps lashes separated. Can wear w/o other mascara for a light casual look or add blow out mascara
Excellent as primer or as stand-alone mascara
RetiredMom from Orange County, CA
I like a natural look. I am in my 60's and heavy make-up looks very harsh on older women. This is perfect as a stand-alone mascara. I use a product yo cause eyelash growth and this product to create full, natural eyelashes.
Fantastic mascara but ...
AR_BeachGirl from Rogers, AR
I love this mascara and have purchased numerous times. It is very buildable - you can wear one coat or three, depending on how big you want your lashes. The tiny wand helps me reach my tiny lashes in the corners and on the bottom lid. My only complaint is that the amount of mascara in the tube lasts for only about 2 months of regular wear (the wand is 2/3rds of the length of the tube). I guess that's about right according to the timing "they" say you should use a mascara for health reasons, but it seems to dry out and empty much quicker than other mascaras I've used.
I love this mascara brush
KD from Minnesota
The brush helps get all your tiny lashes and I love that part of the product. It is said to be like an eyeliner too but I still use my regular eyeliner.
Lots of Lift Without Needing to use an Eyelash Curler!
HilariousMarie from OR
I have incredibly sensitive eyes and this is my go-to mascara! I love that it lasts ALL DAY, doesn't flake or clump and I don't have any allergic reaction to the ingredients. Without bashing other brands, there are lots of "sensitive" formulas that I have tried but this is the only mascara I've been able to consistently use. The few times I've fallen asleep with it on, my lashes still looked great the next morning! Even though this formula isn't waterproof, it still takes a little work to get off but I swear my lashes look healthier and longer since I started using this.
Really I'd give it 3.5 stars
AET1214 from BROOKLYN, ny
I'd give it 3.5 stars because (1) the quantity/cost (.118oz vs double+ in most other mascaras and (2) I couldn't get the look for which its marketed. It definitely defined my lashes, still with a natural look. And it didn't smudge, which is a miracle on my oily face. But did not get the tightline-look. So a decent mascara overall, but I feel like I'm not getting what I'm paying for bc of the failed liner
Facetime from Nj
Cant say enough good things about this product. As i get older my lashes are diminishing. Tightline lengthens and separates my lashes so that when i apply mascara my lashes appear longer and fuller. Cant live without this one!