Rated 4.37 out of 5 stars
Most Helpful Positive Review Great long lasting lipstick
I pretty much loved everything about this product. The packaging was nice, it was easy to open, felt nice in my hands, the tube itself seemed like it was better quality- I've easily cracked lids on other eye/lip pencil-type products but this seems like it would hold up nicely, the lid didn't come off in my purse (another thing that happens with other products), and it even comes with a built-in sharpener (on the other end/bottom). I was really impressed! It was easy to use, easy to apply, you can wipe off "mistakes" easily (I did it right away), it feels nice when applying it, and when wearing it, it actually lasted all day too! Sometimes the long lasting/stain lip sticks don't actually last very long, but this did! I've noticed with other long lasting lip products, it really dries out your lips, but this wasn't too bad. My lips felt a little more dry than usual, but not to the point of it being really uncomfortable to use/wear. So far, it's my favorite long lasting lipstick! I really recommend this product! There are several shades to choose from :) I thought it was funny that my favorite shade I sampled, was called "hustle in heels". So I enjoyed using it, and we got a laugh from the name of this particular shade. [product:maybelline-superstay-ink-crayon-lipstick] I received this product complimentary for review purposes.
Most Helpful Critical Review Love the formula of these-The smell not very much!
I received 3 of these lip crayons for free for testing purposes, however my review is 100% honest nonetheless.
Now, the shade that I like the most is Stay Exceptional. It is in the mauve family and I can see it being a very universal shade to wear for a wide variety of skin tones for sure. The shades of all three lip crayons that I got are nicely pigmented and they glide on very smoothly as well. The only thing that i'm not found is the smell. It is quite perfumey and not really pleasant to smell, in my opinion. I honestly wish that they were either made to be fragrance free or at least had a more pleasant scent to them instead. If you are someone who's okay with quite perfumey scented lipsticks, the I would recommend you see to give these lip crayons a try, otherwise I would recommend giving giving it a pass, unfortunately.
Reviewed by 639 customers Best nude
MCLW from Walkersville, MD
I read so many positive reviews on this product that I had to try it. The reviews were absolutely correct! This is an easy to apply, awesome coverage, amazing nude-pink shade. It is very natural looking, does not dry out. It's a good tube for higher end nude shades. I have a neutral skin tone dark hair and brown eyes and this does not look orangey.
YOU NEED THIS!
Kaylee from FL
I bought this becuase it just happened to show up in a video I was watching on YouTube and the girl was talking about it so I figured I'd try it out since what she was describing sounded like the perfect product for me. I'm not great with lipstick but this isn't huge so it's extremely easy to apply. It glides on with beautiful color and is not drying AT ALL. plus it smells like chocolate, buy it you won't regret it.
Linda from Concord, NC
Did not stay on like it said and it bleed over my lips even with a lip liner
Literally in love!!!!!
Kaylee from FL
I saw this mentioned by an influencer and i was immediately interested, I'm not very adventurous when it comes to lips so I stick to nudes and I HATE a dry feel. This product is SOOOOO creamy and wears beautifully. It's easy to apply and even looks great topped with a gloss.
Kristi from Pensacola FL
For a matte it isn't drying on lips and this color is universal.
Rise To The Top
Doe from Illinois
I love the color (which is more a terracotta and NOT orange) but do not understand the hype. I put this on and no matter what I do it will not stay on my lips. The top lip will immediately transfer to the bottom lip leaving a blank spot. It refuses to build on itself, whether freshly applied or done a few minutes later. This stays on my lips 5 minutes top! I always end up removing it and choosing a matte bullet lipstick that actually lasts under masks. Will never buy again, the liquid version is okay.
Good matte lipcolour
Adrienne from Atlanta
This lipcolour is very matte and I find I have to wear it with a little gloss
The colour is very deep fushia, I wish it was more of a bright pink
Sav from Prattville AL
Loved this lipstick but it definitely can come off pretty easily so I'm not sure it could wear for 8 hours. However, it's super easy to apply and dries well and doesn't have that weird feeling on your lips like a lot of matte lipsticks do! I honestly forget I'm wearing it most of the time.
RKMS from NC
I recently bought Reach High and On the Grind. They're great neutral nudes. Before this line had too many brights for my taste.
The colors on the pics are different
Marisol from Sylmar
I wanted some nude lippies and ordered 2 and when o received them they were more pinky and on the pics they look nude nude
Perfect lip crayon!
Ohemjen from Tennessee
I have it I three different colors. I love it. Most of all it doesn't dry out my lips like some matte lippies do. For the price and size it's a great deal! I can wear it all day at work with my mask on with very little rub off.
love this shade
Shay from TN
I got this in the shade "rise to the top" and I'm obsessed with it! I recently got my hair colored coppery red, and this shade is very complimentary for me. I also have very fair skin. I would recommend using lip liner with this for staying power and to keep things neat. It does transfer so if you like super matte, completely transfer proof lippies, this isn't for you. I want to try more colors!
New Favorite Lip
KLamArtist77 from St. Louis, MO
I purchased "On the Grind". I have fair skin & it is the perfect pink hue for me & just a little darker than my natural lip color. Right now I just needed a lip color that stays put & doesn't rub off on my mask & this is it! This is my new favorite lip product! The color, the staying power, the creamy texture, the fabulous scent....It's a five star rating from me! Can't wait to get more colors!
Offensive scent and no staying power
MakeUp4Me from MI
I was looking for something with lasting color and staying power. This isn't it. I've used the product twice and had to discard it. First, the color is lovely, and it applies smoothly. Those are the only positives. The first problem I noticed was its unpleasant odor. Trust me, it's not a scent; it's an odor, reminiscent of PlayDoh. If you don't mind the smell of PlayDoh, you might not mind this product. However, be forewarned that although the product goes on easily and has a nice appearance, it dries soon after and feels unpleasantly tight and dry on the lips. A clear lip balm applied on top made almost no difference. As for staying power, there is none. After a meal the color was almost completely gone. I might have kept the product, but the other negatives in addition to the bad odor made this one I simply had to trash.
Would not buy this product again
Miranda from Salinas ca
The color was pretty
Kelley from Philadelphia, PA
I love the crayon for easy application. Stayed on for a while for me. I think some of the colors look a lot different online vs in person, but that's not specific to this product.
Easy to apply, comfy
SC makeup girl from SC
I bought 3 (Run The World, Own Your Empire & Change Is Good) and they're nice shades, but RTW and CIG doesn't remotely look like the tube! OYE is an amazing red shade though! I returned RTW because it is "barbie" pink! Eww.
I recommend testing them, or buying all to test at home and return the ones you don't like!! Yay for AMAZING return policies!!
Colin B. from Houston, TX
My wife loves the color. It really looks good on her.
Am looking forward to buying this product again
Lippies a must from Monrovia
Woke up w lipcolor still in place. I typically don't wear makeup to bed but wanted to test this product. ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐
I LOVE LOVE this product!
Jaime from Roanoke, VA
I can't wait to order more colors! For the price, you can't go wrong!
Favorite lipstick formula
Momo from New Mexico
This formula is pretty impressive. It lasts longer than a lot of LIQUID lipstick formulas. That's crazy to me! It really doesn't budge and isn't drying at all. Definitely doesn't suck all of the moisture out of your lips. Transfer-proof/mask-proof as well! At the end of the day my lips do get a little chapped, but that's about it. It lasted through multiple greasy Christmas meals and many snacks and desserts and it was still there. I only reapplied maybe once toward the end of the night. Definitely worth the money!
Haylee w. from Pa
I like this. The formula is matte without being drying. It lasts longer than other lipsticks I've tried.
I would buy these product again and again..I love my crayons
shari from Staten Island
I love my crayons and i will continue to buy them..thank you...
A little drying, but stays put!
Amanda from NC
I use this product daily to add color to my lips. Nothing fancy, just making myself look a little more alive for work.
Gia from Poplar Bluff Missouri
"trust your gut" is my favorite shade!! applies easily and looks amazing on my skin tone. 🙃 if anyone's looking for a lip liner to go with this i recommend the "Milani color statement liner" in the shade "04 all natural" 🙃 definitely my go to lip combo ! 💖