Rated 4.38 out of 5 stars
Most Helpful Positive Review Great long lasting lipstick
I pretty much loved everything about this product. The packaging was nice, it was easy to open, felt nice in my hands, the tube itself seemed like it was better quality- I've easily cracked lids on other eye/lip pencil-type products but this seems like it would hold up nicely, the lid didn't come off in my purse (another thing that happens with other products), and it even comes with a built-in sharpener (on the other end/bottom). I was really impressed! It was easy to use, easy to apply, you can wipe off "mistakes" easily (I did it right away), it feels nice when applying it, and when wearing it, it actually lasted all day too! Sometimes the long lasting/stain lip sticks don't actually last very long, but this did! I've noticed with other long lasting lip products, it really dries out your lips, but this wasn't too bad. My lips felt a little more dry than usual, but not to the point of it being really uncomfortable to use/wear. So far, it's my favorite long lasting lipstick! I really recommend this product! There are several shades to choose from :) I thought it was funny that my favorite shade I sampled, was called "hustle in heels". So I enjoyed using it, and we got a laugh from the name of this particular shade. [product:maybelline-superstay-ink-crayon-lipstick] I received this product complimentary for review purposes.
Most Helpful Critical Review Love the formula of these-The smell not very much!
I received 3 of these lip crayons for free for testing purposes, however my review is 100% honest nonetheless.
Now, the shade that I like the most is Stay Exceptional. It is in the mauve family and I can see it being a very universal shade to wear for a wide variety of skin tones for sure. The shades of all three lip crayons that I got are nicely pigmented and they glide on very smoothly as well. The only thing that i'm not found is the smell. It is quite perfumey and not really pleasant to smell, in my opinion. I honestly wish that they were either made to be fragrance free or at least had a more pleasant scent to them instead. If you are someone who's okay with quite perfumey scented lipsticks, the I would recommend you see to give these lip crayons a try, otherwise I would recommend giving giving it a pass, unfortunately.
Reviewed by 590 customers The only lipcolor that I wear
Kay from AL
Love, love, LOVE this lipstick. It's very long lasting, similar to lip stains, but without the overly drying sensation of lip stains! I have fair skin and red hair, and the "lead the way" color is my year-round go to.
Just ok not super stay
Maestra from San Diego
I like the way it feels doesn't dry the lips. However, it does come off during the day. The inside of my mask is stained and I have to reapply in the afternoon. It does stay better than regular lipsticks, but I need more staying power.
Perfect Shade of Red
Ama from Cedar Falls, IA
Hussle in Heels is the perfect shade of Hollywood red. It has a lovely matte and does not bleed. It has excellent staying power. If it helps, I'm 44 years old with ivory skin.
Reminds me of fall !
Yoyo from Modesto ca
I love it its long lasting and the color of fall !
Makayla Eyeshadow Lover from San Antonio, TX
The product stays on! I applied it as soon as I purchased the lipstick and it stayed on throughout the day, even through my evening workout.
Must have in every shade!
Linz from Jesup, Ga
I love this as my everyday work lipstick.
New fav lip
Kate from Indiana
I tried this in the shade "Trust your gut" after I saw that some influencers had called it a dupe for the CT Pillow talk. While I can't tell you if it is a dupe (because I don't have a pillow talk) I can saw its the PERFECT everyday nude shade. It lasts a few hours before needing to reapply (most of the time I'm reapplying in an hour or two!). It's also the MOST COMFORTABLE tinted/colored lip product I've ever worn. I'll definitely be purchasing more colors (and Trust Your Gut again when I run out!)
Such a good matte lip
pinguaim3 from Phily
Don't know why it didn't stay on for others but this is so transfer proof. Passed my greasy food test too. I got it in "Live on the Edge" which is a beautiful fall shade. I can't wait to buy a few more calls
Pretty, more pink than red
jk from Oregon
Pretty dark red but when blotched, is more pink magenta tone. Goes on nice, stays well i think :)
This is my everyday lipstick
none from Wisconsin
I tried this a while ago and boom! Just what I wanted. I use Enjoy the View, which is just perfect for
my coloring. Stays on well, doesn't transfer much (even with a mask!) and doesn't slide around.
It transfers a little to a glass, but not like a lipstick would. I would buy this again - and I have! I use a little lip balm with it when my lips feel dry.
Ms. Buttons from Burleson, TX
Love this and we'll worth the money. it lasts all day.
I love this product so much!!!
Ann from tennessee
I have bee addicted to these lip crayons since they came out. I wish there were more colors.
I love these
LaMoya from Florida
Maybelline has come out with amazing products for so long and these are no exception. I'm a matte lipstick kind of girl and these look great under gloss or on their own and don't need a lip liner. I own 3 different colors and these don't dry out my lips at all, a very very comfortable matte that glides on smoothly. Love that it comes with a sharpener. These have great color payoff and stay on for a long time, at least 6 hours with no reapplication even after eating. Highly recommend if you like matte lipsticks or don't necessarily like the feel of mattes but would like something more long-wearing.
Rachel from Milwaukee
Mix with another frosty lip stick or stain and a clear top/shine coat to minimize/hide the clumpy
Monti the fashionista from Rio Vista
Saw it in an ad
Bev from Hue
love this stay on lipstick
I will definitely buy more
Valerie from White lake mi
I put it on just to check it out. After 3hrs cleaning the pool, drinking constantly. I completely forgot I'd put it on. Until my daughter asked for my new lipstick.
Went on great but didn't stay
Kris from Atlanta
Not for me
Angela from Ft. Worth, TX
I enjoy lip crayons because of the ease of application. I haven't always had the full time of wear as promised, but that usually happened when I ate something within maybe 90 minutes after application. Still, I would recommend this product.
I really liked it
Ss from Lincoln
If you are looking for 8 hour of 6 hour, this lipstick is not for you. If you are looking natural looking shades that feels like nothing on the lips .. and doesn't make your lips dry , then this is for you. I am not much of liquid lipstick person it makes my lips tacky... I love this
I absolutely love this lipstick!
Brit from Greer, SC
I put it on for a date the other night and it stayed on the whole date.
Nice, Creamy Lip
Minimalist Maiden from Maryland
I wish this was a little more long-lasting, but it reapplies beautifully, and it's very comfortable and pigmented. It also doesn't dry out my lips like so many other products.
I would not buy it again
Sherrie from North Carolina
See above con
M & M from Riverside
Was disappointed that it comes off when drinking or eating. Was hoping it was like the super stay matte ink lipstick that stays all day
Do not buy!
D from Dallas, TX
Very disappointing...comes off when you eat, comes off in your mask, comes off when you wipe your mouth.