Product Reviews Rated 4.54 out of 5 stars
105 Reviews
Most Helpful Positive Review You're gonna love these..... To say I love these would be The Understatement of the Year. The PKLLs are dense mousse lipsticks that can provide everything from a soft blurred wash of color to a more opaque, stronger effect. You can create a sharp edge with the wand applicator or diffuse with a lip brush, your finger, or just by smushing your lips together. One coat will dry down slightly, preventing excessive transfer. Two or more coats will leave a softer balmy feeling, but with more chances to transfer and pill as the day wears on. These will also smear a bit if you are wearing your mask for an hour+. I have extremely wrinkly lips and these do not settle, crack or crease. However, they also do not leave much of a stain behind. I didn't find the online swatches helpful at all. I bought 3 "blind" (MACSMASH, Devoted to Chili, and A Little Tamed), loved them so much I bought 3 more (Over the Taupe, Make Love to the Camera, and the More the Mehr-ier) and loved all 6 of them SO MUCH I literally just ordered every single other color during the Black Friday sale. The photos below were all taken in natural light. I have light/medium skin with both yellow and red undertones — for reference I can wear most foundations running NC20 to NW35 (I'm mixed race european and asian). Of course, YMMV and everyone has their own preferences regarding color, texture, scent, longevity, etc. but I really think most people will like these, as they are just the perfect liquid, bullet, powder hybrid. And if you liked but were somewhat underwhelmed by the original bullet Powder Kiss Lipsticks, and enjoyed the Pony Effect Limited edition mousse lipsticks even tho they don't last long, you will LOVE the PKLLs because they blow both the bullets and Pony out of the water in terms of performance, comfort, and color-saturation. The photos are: my lips no product, then using Over the Taupe, More the Mehr-ier, A Little Tamed, Devoted to Chili, MACSMASH, and Make Love to the Camera.
Most Helpful Critical Review I am SO bummed I had SUCH high hopes for this when I initially tried it on! I purchased Date-Maker (because you can't try on in stores currently) and instantly fell in love when I tried it on in my car. It has an extremely light and soft weight. The color is BEAUTIFUL... a perfect warm nude that I have been searching for forever... (I typically wear Hitch Hiker or Uptight in the Urban Decay comfort mattes, but I've been on the hunt for a liquid lipstick that could survive wearing masks). However, by the time I got home from my 20 minute drive... the color disappeared! I thought maybe I didn't apply enough. The next day, I did full makeup and applied this... only to find it disappeared an hour later! So. I want to love it. I DID love it... but it frankly doesn't last longer than an average chapstick. If there is a trick to get this to last... lipliner or lipgloss or anything... I would try to purchase again. As of now, I returned it. If there is a long lasting lipstick in this same color, I would love to purchase it!!!
Reviewed by 105 customers You're gonna love these..... 5
Dagirl from Texas Y'all!
To say I love these would be The Understatement of the Year. The PKLLs are dense mousse lipsticks that can provide everything from a soft blurred wash of color to a more opaque, stronger effect. You can create a sharp edge with the wand applicator or diffuse with a lip brush, your finger, or just by smushing your lips together. One coat will dry down slightly, preventing excessive transfer. Two or more coats will leave a softer balmy feeling, but with more chances to transfer and pill as the day wears on. These will also smear a bit if you are wearing your mask for an hour+. I have extremely wrinkly lips and these do not settle, crack or crease. However, they also do not leave much of a stain behind. I didn't find the online swatches helpful at all. I bought 3 "blind" (MACSMASH, Devoted to Chili, and A Little Tamed), loved them so much I bought 3 more (Over the Taupe, Make Love to the Camera, and the More the Mehr-ier) and loved all 6 of them SO MUCH I literally just ordered every single other color during the Black Friday sale. The photos below were all taken in natural light. I have light/medium skin with both yellow and red undertones — for reference I can wear most foundations running NC20 to NW35 (I'm mixed race european and asian). Of course, YMMV and everyone has their own preferences regarding color, texture, scent, longevity, etc. but I really think most people will like these, as they are just the perfect liquid, bullet, powder hybrid. And if you liked but were somewhat underwhelmed by the original bullet Powder Kiss Lipsticks, and enjoyed the Pony Effect Limited edition mousse lipsticks even tho they don't last long, you will LOVE the PKLLs because they blow both the bullets and Pony out of the water in terms of performance, comfort, and color-saturation. The photos are: my lips no product, then using Over the Taupe, More the Mehr-ier, A Little Tamed, Devoted to Chili, MACSMASH, and Make Love to the Camera.
Silky smooth! 4
Mary from Arcadia
Loved this product and it did moisturize. You cannot apply it completely with the wand as you will need an additional lip brush. The wand itself leaves too much product on your lips. But overall I am going back to get more colors.
I am SO bummed 3
Ty Ty Girl from San Diego, CA
I had SUCH high hopes for this when I initially tried it on! I purchased Date-Maker (because you can't try on in stores currently) and instantly fell in love when I tried it on in my car. It has an extremely light and soft weight. The color is BEAUTIFUL... a perfect warm nude that I have been searching for forever... (I typically wear Hitch Hiker or Uptight in the Urban Decay comfort mattes, but I've been on the hunt for a liquid lipstick that could survive wearing masks). However, by the time I got home from my 20 minute drive... the color disappeared! I thought maybe I didn't apply enough. The next day, I did full makeup and applied this... only to find it disappeared an hour later! So. I want to love it. I DID love it... but it frankly doesn't last longer than an average chapstick. If there is a trick to get this to last... lipliner or lipgloss or anything... I would try to purchase again. As of now, I returned it. If there is a long lasting lipstick in this same color, I would love to purchase it!!!
I love this! 5
LeeLee from Augusta, GA
I was very apprehensive about buying this stuff only because I was unsure of how the colors would show up on my skin (I'm a very tan/caramel brown, biracial woman with olive undertones). I bought the Over the Taupe and Mull it Over, VERYYYY apprehensive about buying a nude and a bright coral but I must say paired with the right liner, I AM IN LOVE! The color pay off if very nice but also seems to blend well to my natural lip color and the finish is almost like butter. I bought the MAC liner in Cork to pair with this and I am really loving the look. Very subtle yet sexy. Will definitely buy more colors!
Perfect red for fall 5
NayTay from VA
Perfect for fall date night. Formula was great - but did stick to my mask (crazy times). Would but this in other colors
i absolutely LOVE this! 5
Mary from Riverside, CA
I use this lip color every day! it's the perfect color on me and the formula is so soft. The unique applicator allows you to never miss a spot. The product lasts pretty much all day on my lips and is great even under masks.
Lovveeeee and a little goes a long way! 4
Kaelee from Clayton, NC
Make sure your lips are moisturized first!
A worthy companion in the "Mehr" line. 5
Vinnie from Sandwich, Mass.
Love the hourglass-shaped applicator, excellent coverage. Rich, vibrant color.
Will definitely buy this product again. 5
Vicki from IL
The color is awesome. Very rich deep berry. Feels really light and not matte. Stays on and doesn't bleed
Pleasantly surprised 5
Mac lover from Tustin
Love his the products goes on and looks.
Definitely a positive but for me 5
The girl who loves lips from Sacramento, CA
It allows a soft finish without being absent of color.
Applicator is tricky 4
Rocky from Goleta
Applicator is flimsy and product goes on in clumps. It takes a few rounds to smooth and even the color out over the lips. Once that is done I will often blot it. I love the color!
N/a 3
Makeupbyrosinda from New jersey
Didn't like the feeling of it on my lips
N/A 3
Makeupbyrosinda from New Jersey
I was not impressed with the product!
Amazing lipgloss 5
Tinkergoofy from Phoenix,AZ
I was a little apprehensive as to whether or not a powder gloss would be but was more than pleasantly surprised at how much moisturizing this gloss is. I absolutely love the color and it does last long as described.
Coverage 5
taylortisha from Chicago
Nice color that stays. Layering with a shimmering gloss makes the color look especially festive.
Great product poor packaging 1
Sarah from Fayetteville, NC
I purchased this online along with another color in the same formula. I love the nude color! It is soft, natural, blurring, and it feels moisturizing on with that sought after matte finish. My only complaint is that less than a week after using this product I dropped it on my tile floor and the packaging broke.
Way too thick and drying. 1
S22michelle from MI
I thought I would love this as I am into a matte lip for fall and winter AND MAC lipsticks are amazing. But this is just very thick and drying to me. I did not like it at all.
Awful 1
Bee from San Antonio
First of all, the color I purchased "Mull it over" looks nothing like the online swatch. Color in person actually looks darker but pretty. My main issue however, is that it's advertised as lasting 8 hours. Really? It didn't even last 8 minutes let alone an hour or so. I also hated the feel of the product, and didn't like how it looked on my lips. It actually resembles powder. Not particularly attractive. Needless to say it's going back.
Sales lady told me it was an all day color. It is not! 1
Pml from Ann Arbor MI
This lip color goes on smoothly. It is NOT a long-wearing all day
Lip color!
Nice But Too Perfumey 4
Betts from Raynham MA
I liked how it applied, smooth and didn't feel dry, pretty color. However, I am sensitive to smells and this one was strong and never dissipated. I could not keep it so my daughter is going to try it. Really wish manufacturers didn't feel the need to add perfume to lipstick!!
Love!❤️ 5
MACandme from California
Like another reviewer said this formula is a game changer! Beautiful colors, easy to apply, moisturizing, and if you blot after you apply, the color stays put.
Whoaaaahhh..this lipstick is a HIT like no other!! 5
BaldDiva77 from Brooklyn
This lipstick is the ONE!! Just as I thought the MAC Powderkiss solid lipstick was a HIT (I have 7 of them...yikes!), MAC has honestly out done themselves with this liquid formula..just perfection in a tube, smooth nourishing formula, rich color pay-off & easy to apply, especially for the woman who rarely makes time to apply their makeup..HELLO! It goes on extra smooth like a mousse formula with a color pay off that's stunning but not over the top, you can even use it without a lipliner (the wand is superb for lining the lips!) & it's still pretty with a diffuse look if you don't put on too much. I did NOT have to re-dip the wand for my initial application of the GORGEOUS true RED color -MAC SMASH & the color pay off was rich..it's looks SUPER pretty on my MAC NC45 complexion & easily smooths my lip lines. I also picked up a more neutral nude/mauve color - "More the Mehr-ier" which is equally beautiful..I am already wanting MORE colors such as "Sorry not sorry" & "Over the Taupe"..
Amazing product 5
Coco from Texas
All I can say is wow!! Matte lip color has come a long way in the past decade and this raises the bar even higher. Application is superb, from the applicator itself to the texture of the product gliding on to the lips. Best to coat the lips with the applicator and use a lip brush for precise, even distribution. Color payoff is second to none - GORGEOUS. Serious staying power and feels like heaven while wearing - does not dry out the lips whatsoever. Finally, I LOVE the packaging. I'm amazed at the level of quality I've received in this lipstick at an unbeatable price point. Bravo!
DOESN'T LAST, TRANSFERS LIKE BASIC LIPSTICK 2
Chelsea from California was
Beautiful color and hydrating but doesn't last AT ALL. Transfers like normal lipstick but worse because I feel like it wouldn't fully dry. I even tried to put a lip sealer over it and the weird formula made it flake. It's a shame because I loved the color (got a callback) but I'm not wearing a dark color that doesn't even set and easily transfers to where I would need to constantly touch it up.
