Rated 4.05 out of 5 stars
Most Helpful Positive Review Incredible
I bought this a few days before I saw a concert, not expecting much for the price. I had been using the Tarte liquid liner pen and the Kat Von D Tattoo Liner. I ran out of both and I picked this up, and I'm shocked at how much I love it. Not sure if it is waterproof, but it is definitely cry proof, I shed some tears at the concert I was at. 10/10 would reccomend. (the attatched photo is me wearing the liner)
Most Helpful Critical Review Allergic reaction
I bought this product because it has nice tip for more defined look, but I am having severe allergic reaction with swollen, red and itchy eyelids. Please don't use this product!
I am giving one star because it stays throughout the day, but I could not continue after one time application.
Reviewed by 643 customers Great eyeliner emergency!!
anne8 from Virginia
Bought this eyeliner one night bc i was in desperate need for one just for the night and definitely did the trick. i wouldn't choose to use this every day bc when you apply it, it isn't as dark and looks kinda grey and faded…
Dry and painful
Maureen from Charlottesville, Va
This pen was very dry. I had to press pretty hard to get anything out of it, even after wetting the tip with some water. Not comfortable to apply that much pressure to your eye lids. Luckily it didn't cost much, because it's going to the trash.
Not Pigmented Enough
Carolyn H from Knoxville
I'm use to a very rich black color. But this was a light grey. I didn't like it.
Melimel from Tucson,Az
I love me cat eyes! And since middle school ive purchased so many eyeliners, have wasted so much money on some but this eyeliner right here. WOW did not expect it to work better than any other eyeliners I've purchased throughout the years! And the price sheeesh thats nothing! Will buy again!
ttc from saw
not even black.. literally looks brown. good price ig.
I have been using for years
Athlete25 from Ala-Freakin-Bama
One of the most inexpensive products that works well and is overlooked. I have been using this eyeliner pen for years. It works amazing and stays on all day. Just wore for a wedding the other day. Don't waste your money on the name brand when this works just as good. :-)
I like this eyeliner, glides on the lid and easy to remove.
Abue from SCV
Easy to use and remove.
ashleyk from DOTHAN
horrible. everytime I buy this it feels dry. I used to enjoy this but the last 3 I bought barely had any product. I'll stick to wet n wild pens.
Do NOT Buy
Make-up Enthusiast from Phoenix, AZ
So disappointing. I love Essence products but this one REALLY missed the mark. Barely any pigment and not waterproof or smudge proof as promised. I know it's only a couple bucks but now I have to waste my time returning it. I would not recommend anyone buy this. I don't know how anyone else is saying this eyeliner works for them but it didn't perform for me. The color was gray and the staying power was non existent, it wipes right off. So much for me being able to look cute at the lake.
not the best but not the worst
xixi from san diego, ca
first off, not waterproof. simply running water over it causes it to fade so rapidly. the applicator is fine to the point where it's hard to be precise. it stays, dries a little slow, overall would not purchase again. it is cheap, tho.
A from Wyoming
I bought this pen with little hope that it would be anything decent- boy was I wrong. This goes on smooth, doesn't budge, and the application is even! I would definitely recommend and I'm going back for more.
Don't Regret Buying
Mich from United States
This eyeliner is thin enough for me and lasts throughout the day especially if i put setting powder over. Love it sm for the price and what it offers. Amazing product
Don't waste your time
Jenn from Houston
I had higher hopes for this. Not what I was looking for. Don't waste your money on this.
E from SoCal
I've owned many of these throughout the past few years, for the price it's amazing! It last pretty long, I stick it in my bag to touch up throughout the day; also, I dipped it in rubbing alcohol as it's not sealed and I don't want to risk getting an eye infection.
It's quite black and last fairly long. I definitely recommend this product!
tiffany from Michigan
it's black for anyone who's confused on the color. it works great. draws smooth and does not wash off in water unless you scrub it
Anamal from Phoenix
The best thing about this WATERPROOF is that it stays on through the day and will come off easily at night.
DC4L from Tx
Would never order because the description does not tell what color it is...
Lilly from Mi
Takes so long to draw and it keeps on drying out. I would not recommend this to anyone.
Naz from Germantown
This product is so good for the price! I have literally bought so many of these eyeliners and they do NOT dissappoint. It stays on all day and is waterproof plus it had nice tip to make a sharp wing. Definitely worth it and is even better than some high end eyeliners. It will take a few shakes at the beginning to get the product working well but it turns out great and has a nice bold black pigment to it.
This is a stable in my makeup routine.
T from PA
I have used this eyeliner for the past 5 years and would recommend to people who are looking for eyeliner that lasts a while or are trying to do bold eyeliner for the first time and aren't confident to use liquid eyeliner.
Dr.Dy from New Hartford, NY
It's easy to use but no pigment. So it's kinda useless and would not recommend
I love it!
Jen from Euclid, OH
This eyeliner is fantastic! It's easy to use, it has great pigment, and it lasts all day. It doesn't irritate my eyes at all. I wish I could get it in brown, too. will definitely buy it again!
I will purchase this one again
H. Hurtady from Banks Oregon
I don't usually wear eyeliner but I was picking up the mascara and decided to try the eyeliner was pleasantly surprised it was easy to apply and I even got a straight line for me that's amazing so that tells me that this is going to be a new favorite of mine
H from PA
goes on very smooth, love it
Great but not the Best
Bianca from Virginia
I liked the tip better than the Maybelline Eye Studio Master. I personally like the tips to be stiffer. The pigmentation is great but I noticed some shimmer peeked through where the eyeliner was sitting which is somewhat okay with me. However, after basing my eyes out, I can say that this eyeliner is not waterproof. But for its price, I'd recommend this on the go or for a beginner. And this also lasted me a while until it went dry. I personally like this better than the Kat Von D liner that's for sure.