Maybelline Colossal Bubble Waterproof Mascara

Most Helpful Critical Review

It's ok

[I received this product in exchange for my honest review] I was excited to try the Bubble Colossal Mascara Waterproof because I love the idea of big, dramatic lashes that can handle anything. It definitely delivers on volume – my lashes looked thick and bold with just a couple of coats. The brush i...s great at separating and building, and the initial look is really impressive. But unfortunately, for a "waterproof" formula, it doesn't quite live up to its promises when it comes to staying put under the eyes. I noticed that after a few hours, especially in humid weather or if my eyes watered even a little, there was noticeable transfer and smudging along my lower lash line. By the end of the day, I often had dark smudges under my eyes that made me look tired. It's disappointing because the volume is so good that I really wanted this to be my go-to mascara. But for those looking for truly budge-proof, all-day wear (especially if you have oily skin or watery eyes), this formula may not be reliable. Pros: Big volume Easy to build Intense black color Cons: Transfers under eyes Smudges despite waterproof claims Needs touch-ups or under-eye setting to avoid raccoon eyes Overall, I'd call it a decent option if you're careful to prep and set your under-eye area well, but it's not the most transfer-resistant waterproof mascara out there.