Product Reviews Rated 3.4 out of 5 stars
884 Reviews
Most Helpful Positive Review Midnight brown What the heck r you people doing to me ive been using midnight brown for the past 20 years , it make my brows perfect .... I need this color back , i have my husband looking at every pharamacy to buy up all the stock in montreal
Most Helpful Critical Review Zero stars I don't know why they decided to replace Midnight Brown with Rich Brown but it was a terrible decision. Midnight Brown was the ultimate neutral brown but Rich Brown is way too red. So disappointed because I've been using this product for at least 20 years!
Reviewed by 884 customers I love these crayon eyebrow pencils! 5
Laura the cook from Texas
These crayon eyebrow pencils are so nice and easy to fill in your eyebrows ! And the manager at Ulta in Harker Heights was so helpful and found me what I needed! Thank you 🥰
brow filling 2
raniah8 from undisclosed
I was happy to buy it I thought it will solve my problem but it didn't as it didn't fill the spaces and was more loose not to mention the color was too dark for me
brow filling 2
raniah8 from undisclosed
I was happy to buy it I thought it will solve my problem but it didn't as it didn't fill the spaces and was more loose not to mention the color was too dark for me
brow filling 2
raniah8 from undisclosed
I was happy to buy it I thought it will solve my problem but it didn't as it didn't fill the spaces and was more loose not to mention the color was too dark for me
Long lasting, controllable color 4
GrammaBebe from Akron, Ohio
I've been using this before pencil for as long as I can remember. I use the rich brown. I also like the color of the medium brown, but for some reason it doesn't go on as well as the darker shade.
I've tried many other kinds to see if I'd like them better, but always return to Cover Girl. The others talk a good game but never quite live up to what they say they'll do.
I just became a Great-Grandma and I'm changing my hair from medium brown to its natural gray. The rich brown shade of brow pencil is just too dark now. The medium might be ok, but the consistency of it is weird and it doesn't go on right.
I wish Cover Girl would make a taupe shade that is the consistency of the rock brown. I've had to switch to another brand even though I don't like it as much.
I would definitely give this product 5 starts off it came in as shade I could use.
It's great but... 5
Imai from Vegas to Hawaii
I have been using this same product for over 15 yrs. The rich brown is my color and I love it. But I have to sharpen it to much lately or it runs out fast when there can definitely be more product that goes to the bottom of the pencil. Love that it has 2 pencils in a pack and I dont think anyone has as many sharpners as me lol... ps moving back home to hawaii what stores are you in over there?
good product 4
parands1 from undisclosed
Like the brow fill but it's not as easy to apply and you'd need a couple layers for a full coat ! Stays on well and looks good, the color is also great! Good for touch up for a night out since it's small and fits in a small purses
very loyal product 5
tabathamm from undisclosed
Only eyebrow pencil I'll use. It is easy to use and easy to find at stores. The shades are very accurate to the description and very affordable. I have blue eyes and I feel the brown shades work best on me
Why three stars... 3
tina_try from undisclosed
Why three stars because 1. This product is limited in the color range and 2. The color oxides to a bright orangish/red color. If you are a red head this will work for you in the darkest brown color. What I truly love about this is the shape of the pencil. It is retractable with a slant that is not a triangle. I love this product. The shape of the pencil reminds me of the Valentino brow pencil. This is a creamy formula that is not waxy. It glides on nicely and provides an awesome arch. It also lasts all day and does not flake off. If only it was available in dark brown, i would be a fan.
brows on fleek 5
kasiag7 from undisclosed
Works great if you want pigmented eyes brows very soft and easy application I really liked this product
I use this for more than just my brows 5
melissat196 from undisclosed
I really like this pencil. I actually use the black one as a liner because I feel it stays put longer than other liners.
After using this... 5
annam541 from undisclosed
After using this product I can honestly say I did not like it and would not recommend it. The pencil was harsh and very hard, almost like it was stale.
ok 5
kristenm151 from undisclosed
10/10 would buy again application is so simple and I recommend it to my friends price is good as well won't break your pockets. I don't have issues with smudged looks throughout the day either!
eyeliner 4
kateearlston from undisclosed
I don't normally do waterline eyeliner, but when I do this is my go to. I absolutely love it, and wouldn't change a thing about it.
eye no 2
anjelitabella from undisclosed
Smudges easy. I prefer to use a pomade now a days with a brush. I used this when I wasn't as experienced in my makeup journey
What do I think about... 5
thinredlinewife from undisclosed
What do I think about this product? It does what it's suppose to do! Cons? Not really and there isn't really anything for this brand to change to make it better. Also, affordable ? Not really all make-up brands are expensive I feel. It doesn't matter what kind of make-up it is all of it is expensive because it is a want not a need. This is a great brand, I have nothing bad to say on this brand so 10/10 worth trying a brand even if it's once ! So here is your sign to try out new make-up brands :)
super good 5
janer33 from undisclosed
I loved this product. I would buy it again a thousand times. I highly recommend it to my friends who look for it, I know they will also love it
The best ! ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ 4
camillal9 from undisclosed
i strongly believe that this eyebrow pencil is an amazing, and cheap alternative for the anastasia ! the only thing i would improve is how long it would last ! You have to keep in mind how cheap it is. i would most definitely purchase again ! Easy Breezy Brow Micro Fine Fill Define Eyebrow Pencil
Very disappointed!!! 1
JMSJ from Plymouth, Michigan
I have used these pencils for a long time. However, lately something has really changed!!! They are awful!!! They are sooooo soft they break all the time. You can use up one in one application!!! Also, the color pencil part is so off center of the pencil, all you have on one side is wood!!! Very disappointed in the last few I have purchased.......searching for another brand.
Great 3
emilieelizabeth-9aa1b0d0 from undisclosed
I think if I would of went with a brown that I would of like it better but over all the product was nice and I would recommend to other will buy again
#bestProduct 5
rebecar61 from undisclosed
It is a beautiful product that makes your makeup and your face look perfect. I like how the makeup lasts and above all it is very perfect.
Olde but a goody. 5
ingridr0c71 from undisclosed
I have all kinds of brow enhancing makeup but Covergirl Easy BreeY Brow fill seems to always come to the rescue. If I overplucked in one side, I can easily hid it with the brow fill. Works great to fill in weak brows.
it's okay 3
nadjeic from undisclosed
The price is great but I feel like the pencil was a bit dry. Maybe it was just the one I bought but I had to use a heavier hand which made it look like harsh lines so I ended up spending a lot more time trying to blend and feather it out
I recommend this product 5
selener30 from undisclosed
I love this product it's totally worth it and it lasted for about 2 month and it's also affordable, this product gives me more of a natural look when I don't want to put much on, I would recommend it for biggeners and I'd like to say that this saves so much more time because is easier to use.
love it! 5
selenaamgib from undisclosed
My favorite brow filler! It looks so natural on, and it's so easy to apply. Such a good price as well, love it.
