Product Reviews Rated 4.26 out of 5 stars
1315 Reviews
Most Helpful Positive Review Like this mascara I have short lashes and can get longer ones with this mascara.....and, although my lashes are NOT curly, I never using an eyelash curler because I feel that may weaken the lashes. This mascara may flake just a little here and there or not at all, but for the price and results, I can deal with that. I also love the way it makes my eyes look......so dark......never had a mascara give me that "look" before. It says in instructions on product not to let dry between applications and they are right....."if" you let TOO MUCH time go by between applications, BUT, if you just concentrate on getting the look you want on the first eye you do, you will never achieve it.....you need to apply to first eye, then let it dry up during the few seconds you're doing the second eye, and then go back to the first eye, etc., until you get the look you want....I find doing 3 applications between eyes gives me the look I want. I would definitely give this mascara a try if you have short lashes because I haven't come across a mascara yet (not that I've used them all) that has given me the length I'm looking for. You don't have to worry about volume because the dark look you get provides that.
Most Helpful Critical Review NOT WATERPROOF Stiletto After applying this product before going to a pool party with my friends, I was confident that it was going to last me through the day, after all, it's waterproof! ABSOLUTELY NOT! The moment I had jumped into the pool, my mascara started to run and because I had so heavily applied it, clumps of it ran down my face leaving not only grey, blotchy circles under my eyes but black globs all over. The substances in the foundation of the mascara are cheap and wear down when it reaches heavy chemicals and liquids such as chlorine and salt water, yet as for the rain, in my experience it should be fine. I was greatly disappointed with this product.
Reviewed by 1315 customers Love this! 5
Nessa from 707
I've been using this mascara for years and I love how the formula never changed. It's my favorite and gives me the length I need.
Surprised! 5
cselb from Missouri
I typically go for a plastic brush, however these bristles are amazing. Such a beautiful coat of mascara that is effortless! Would give way more stars if I could!😍
Very good 4
Dukediesel from Philadelphia PA
This mascara works for me which surprising because I usually don't like drugstore mascara. The shape of this brush works best with my lashes. I do use an eyelash primer because my lashes are short and curled so without primer, I make a mess with mascara. I also have to wear waterproof or it gets everywhere. I don't have an issue with clumps but again, I think this shape brush works best for my lashes.
Not what I thought 3
Allee from Yonkers, NY
I was expecting it to make my lashes look different
Hated it! 1
AL from United States
I hated this mascara. Did nothing for my lashes except make them clumpy. Will not buy again.
Very good as a secondary mascara 5
Uptonogood from Ep
The reviews say it's too light and natural, and I think that's why I love it. I use this on top of telescopic mascara once it's completely dry. And one coat on top of my already long lashes thanks to telescopic, makes them absolutely beautiful. I don't always buy this one, but when I have extra money. I buy it to put on top of telescopic and my eye lashes are the bees knees item 9.
Great for length! 4
Kristen C. from San Antonio, TX
I've been using this mascara for months and it really does what it's supposed to do - which is lengthen your lashes. Definitely not for volume though, but it's not advertised for that. Personally, my lashes don't stay up on their own, so if yours do then you'll get great results. I get lash lifts and when I put on this mascara my lashes look amazing. I've experienced little flaking and it does dry out somewhat fast though. Not too big of a deal to me.
Not a fan 1
Kristi from CA
Too much work to get it to look good.
Only mascara I use. 5
Balways from Oceanside, CA
I've used this for years and I'll never change brands! It makes my lashes so long. I've tried the expensive brands but always go back to this. Really surprised it has so many bad reviews
Great for Asian lashes 5
Hi from FL
I buy bcuz of youtuber idk which one. It does make my lashes longer and curled it. I used L'Oréal primer first than the stiletto mascara. It doesn't volume it lot only a little bit.
Meh 1
No from No
It doesn't lengthen that well and it clumps. The worst part is how badly it flakes off and transfers
Love the looks but it transfers 3
YS from Oregon
I like how this mascara separates my lashes and make them look really long, and there is zero clumping! However, by the end of the day, it always transfers/smudges to my lower eyelid!! This is a major no go for me. (I tried it with a waterproof mascara base too, but the same result.) It doesn't transfer on the upper lid, so I'll still keep using it and will just have to find something else former lashes.
meh 2
SF from everett
The bristles aren't great, lashes tend to clump together. One coat isn't enough, two coats helps with lengthening and separation but then lashes seem to remain sticky and wet, they never dry. I'd keep looking if I were you.
It's ok 4
Luckie4us from South Carolina
It is comparable to other mascaras, but not seeing anything over and above.
This is NOT waterproof 2
Shelby from Dallas
Just a heads up if you're actually buying this for the waterproof purposes - look elsewhere! I bought this because I've been using the Buxom waterproof for forever now and wanted to switch it up. And guess who's going back to Buxom! This is far from waterproof. Throughout the days, I'll have black smears under my eyes and black dots along my eyelid. This also does a horrible job at fanning out the lashes and making them look nice and full. My lashes get stuck together when using this and they look short and spidery. The price is great, but it's not worth it.
Disappointed 1
Jaz from Washington
This mascara doesn't add much length, or anything for that matter. I dislike it so much I'm returning it
DOES EXACTLY WHAT IT'S SUPPOSED TO 5
Sam from Florida
I personally LOVED this mascara my lashes are short/medium length and only a little curly. This mascara lengthens it so well it can be seen from far away. The brush also separates the hairs which give it a natural look. I do use another mascara to give volume when I want a dramatic look but I can wear this all on its own and be content. When I do my combo I always get eyelash compliments!!! So definitely use a lengthening one and then a volume one!!! Will buy again!!! Thank you!!
Great brand! 4
Singy060 from Windsor, CT
This is a great over the counter brand mascara! Reasonably priced!
Trash 1
SARAH from Jeffersonville
Absolute trasshhh.
Best Waterproof Mascara 5
Sydney from Florida
I heard about this mascara on tik tok and had been wanting to try it. I got it before vacation since I was going to be at the beach and the pool and it lasted all day. It makes your lashes look sooo long and beautiful! I absolutely love this mascara.
best Mascara ever 5
desi from Orange County
I have short eyelashes and it'd literally makes me lashes look so long.
too light?? 2
mar from WA
It does not grip your lashes well enough to lengthen, I have to really make a mess for it to even grip my lashes. I've always had pretty good luck with mascara, I have small/medium length lashes and sparse/ not full. I've always been able to get them really long without making a mess with other mascaras. The bottle and the wand seem too light to be able to control how much, or I should say how little to put on. There's better mascaras out there for length.
Best Drugstore Dupe! 5
Nicole P. from Erie, PA
This is literally the best drugstore dupe that I've found! I have a hard time getting the dramatic length and volume I like for my mascara, and was a firm believer that paying more meant getting a better product. I was using a $25 mascara the worked good, but holy cow, this works better! My lashes have never been so prominent! I love this formula and it is my new go-to!
Love this mascara 5
Sheebz from Oceanside, CA
I bought this because in my makeup class I was taught that waterproof mascara holds the curl in your lash better than regular mascara. Sure enough, it does hold the curl all day. I love this mascara because it is what it says: waterproof. It does not smear, streak, or run. It lasts all day and sometimes the next day if I forget to remove it before I got to sleep (oops). My only complaint is that is a little clumpier than I like but it's not that big of a deal for me. I love the price point as well!
Love it! 5
T_Storm from Texas
I have been using this product for a few years and it is my go to mascara! It doesn't clump and make my lashes pop!
