Rated 3.91 out of 5 stars
Most Helpful Positive Review Perfect for the perfect wing
The brush on this is SO thin it makes the PERFECT lines for winged liner. It doesn't get weird if you go over the line you've already created when you bring your wing back down, and the color is SO opaque. Still waiting for non drug store brands to get on this level. < 3
Most Helpful Critical Review It wouldn't come off
Okay so I put it on over some eyeshadow and I went to go take it off but it wouldn't come off. Instead it turned green and just stayed.
Reviewed by 190 customers Really good
Dragonfire from Norway
Its really good, Black, liquidy but not så it bleeds and lastes ok but if you get a bit sweaty or oily in the warmth it can transfer a bit but is really easy to fix🖤 Love it
Rubbed off my eyes
Mily G from Naples FL
At first I was like omg this is really good the pigment is nice but I noticed it would smear even if i was super careful and i kept having bald patches i tried it out on my older sister and it smeared really bad its cheap and i would rather save up to buy something else
Holy grail eyeliner
Debi from Maryland, USA
I've been using this for years to do my wings and it never fails me. It does have a slight shine since it's cheap so I'll usually pat some black eyeshadow on top to help :) This eyeliner has survived 10 hour shifts, festivals, and concerts. I love her work.
It's fades after awhile
Adri from California
Easy application, I noticed after a couple of hours the eyeliner fades away. Next time I'll pay more to buy from NYX.
meggmcn from Chelmsford
For the price this goes on so good, it's better than even some of the other high end products. Would recommend
ik this is cheap but come on
nope from nyc
was broken in the package and opened before i even took it out if the packaging
next time ill spend $2 more for colourpop
This will be my new go to Eyeliner for my wing
Baby from Madera,Ca
I love it, glides on easy and makes my wing sharp ive tried high end eyeliner and this works just as good
k from Georgia
its lacking some pigment. I'll do a wing, and have to fill it in with a lot of product. It's also hard for the product to come off and it has a thick brush that makes it harder to do a winged liner.
sophia from sheboygan
can't beat that price! especially with how good it is! easy to manipulate and dries down quick!
Cheap and reliable
Rain from Palm Springs
I have been using this for years and never failed me ! Love the super thin point for my wing eyeliner and cat eyes !
By far my favorite
Alli from Iowa
Doesn't run and precise eye liner brush!! I would 100 PERCENT use this over any high end brand eye liner.
I always buy this product. For the price it does what I need
Kristie from Ohio
I use a felt tip liner first then I go over it with this for pigment. Great price and does what I need it to do.
Cheap and not worth it
Mary the merrygoaround from Raleigh, NC
I used this eyeliner both with primer and without, still wouldn't stay on and didn't stop it from flaking after 2 hours. The tip can be gimmicky, so try to wipe off excess ink before you apply. It provides a sharp and pigmented swipe, but just know that it won't stay like that throughout the day. I have oily monolids, so i don't recommend buying this if u have the same thing.
Marissa from Saint Louis
Pretty liner, but I have used it three times now on my eyes and it has BURNED
K from K
Pigmented and doesn't smear
date from oregon
This is something and I would say is great for a beginner who flirting but to warn them it bleeds it doesn't have good coverage, and The applicators not my favorite. Person a about it so I could try it and see if I lights eyeliner, that's the only thing I think it's good for.
Andrea from Wichita,ks
Love this eyeliner I use for my cat eye or dramatic look last all day and night
Made an account to shame this product
YIKES from Raleigh, NC
Literally awful. It goes on well enough but within 20 minutes it's a bright smurfy blue. From there, there's not way to take it off. Tried THREE different makeup removers. Eventually, had to go about my life until it flakes off DAYS later. My eyes also were allergic to use and have become red and irriatated. Worst product I've ever bought.
Easy to Use
Jamaica from Upper Darby, PA
Easy to Apply
My go to!
Amy from West Virginia
Forever my fav liquid liner and you can't beat the price no runs to smudging!my wing be flawless
Abbey from Florida
- cruelty free
- very saturated pigments
- doesn't dry down fast and is prone to getting everywhere
this eyeliner is amazing!!!
Claudia from Knoxville, Tennessee
this is the best liquid eyeliner i've ever used! i've always had a hard time applying liquid eyeliner because i have hooded eyes, but it came out precise. would definitely recommend to beginners.
Midnight stains something fierce.
Blep from None of ur beeswax
I bought midnight a little while ago from a store. Liked it, it didn't move on my hand (when getting new products I always swatch on hand and leave it on for the day). End of the day comes and I wipe the eyeliner off and,,,, it stained my hand blue. Like smurf blue. Usually that's fine if I can scrub it off but this was such a bright and stuck on stain. I won't use it on my eyes because I'm scared of looking weird when I wipe it off. I warn you it might stain.
Precise & Sharp Lines
Blessed 2Q2Q from Ohio
Sharp dark lines, will try with the Line & Define Eye Tape.
Pretty Much The Only Eyeliner I Can Trust
Helen from Myrtle beach
This is the only liquid eyeliner that I have trusted for almost 10yrs. It stays on all day, doesn't smudge of flake, and DOESN'T TRANSFER!!! And for the price- it's perfect.