Rated 3.98 out of 5 stars
Most Helpful Positive Review BEST.. MASCARA.. EVER!!!!!!!
I feel like this is my DREAM mascara! I cant believe how well it works! I saw other reviews, with terrible things to say, but for me I feel like its the complete opposite.
Personally, I like very long lashes, separated, sweeping to touch my eyebrows. Naturally my eyelashes are straight, fine, and average length. But a simple curl with a lash curler, and 2 coats of this mascara, I have superstar lashes.
I didn't have any issues with clumping, or drying. My only tiny issue, and this is with every mascara I use, is smudging, I have very oily eyelids & Houston humidity, so when my eyelashes touch my upper lid you see some smudges. HOWEVER, some urban decay shadow primer = no smudges. I urge people to try this mascara for themselves!
The mascara brush is my favorite design, its slender, tapered, and rubber wand and tips are the best design. It combs through from root to tip leaving your entire lash covered and separated.
This mascara is either a love it or hate it. I definitely LOVEEEE it!
Please see the pictures I uploaded just so you have an idea of what the mascara looks like on by itself.
Most Helpful Critical Review Ridiculous
Bought this a couple weeks ago when they were advertising it at the front of the store. Seemed pretty good when I first applied it, definitely lengthened and defined my very thin lashes. But it did smudge a lot by lunch and when I went to remove it that night, nightmare! Would not come off! Flakes everywhere including in my eyes. Gave it a couple more tries, wish I hadn't. Third day I wore it and removed it I ended up at the opthomologist with a scratched eye from the flakes! Never use again! Be warned!
Reviewed by 4176 customers Stays all night and not clumpy!!
Ellie from Tampa, FL
One coat was enough for me and it looked great. Very natural and not too heavy. The wand is perfect and helps separate lashes.
Shel belle from Melbourne FL
I use it almost daily going out or to work. It really is the best mascara I've ever used.
Roller Lash is way better
Nina from Seattle
Gave this a shot and now I'm here to tell you that if you apply more than two coats you're going to have a bad time. You're going to have a combined total of four very thick lashes and you won't be able to wipe off the product till tomorrow. Don't switch from Roller Lash, it hasn't been beat yet.
So far so good!
Madalyn from Charlotte, nc
I've always sworn by a too-faces mascara and this scared me because the wand is much different than I typically prefer. I have very blond eyelashes and this is the perfect dark black. It makes my lashes look SO long with two coats. The reviews saying it rips out your lashes are probably because the makeup remover best used to take it off needs oil in it, or just a gel make up remover that is gentle. I wouldn't recommend using a make up wipe to take these off, but that doesn't bother me because I don't use make up wipes on my skin anyways. I love this!
Okay but I've bought better
Abbie from Connecticut
The mascara looks good initially when you put it on your lashes but i don't think it holds curl well and there's a too fallout under my bottom lashes which I don't like. I recommend L'Oréal telescopic mascara and it's a fraction of the price.
Good, solid mascara...
Tina from OK
I've used this for a week now. It does what it says it does...lengthens, volumizes, and I would say that it looks like I have 33% more lashes. Not as dramatic an improvement as Thrive mascara with the fibers, but this Benefit mascara holds up through my sweaty workouts much better. No flakey fibers all over my face.
Not impressed at all.
Lauren from Clarksville Tennessee
This did nothing for my lashes.
Yavtle from Staten Island, N.Y.
I've used many brands, got this one as a gift and I'm in love!
Emma from New haven, Ct
I bought the mini one because i wasn't sure if i'd like it- but i'm going back to ulta to buy the bigger version! I love the way it applies, the applicator handle fits nice in my hand, it separates my lashes evenly, and most of all- boosts my lashes so well & they look very long!!
Worth the hype
Flamingo lover from Ft. Walton Beach Florida
Even on days you don't wear any other eye makeup this still makes my eyes wider
Best Eye-Opening Mascara
Polished Nurse from Knoxville, TN
This is one of three mascaras that I use on a daily basis. It's the last mascara I apply last at the ends of my lashes for a brightened look. It does incredible things for my lashes and really makes them look long & full. I haven't had any issues with crumbling or smearing and I've been using this mascara for well over a year (not the same tube of course). I highly recommend this mascara.
Length and longitivity
RZ from Pittsburgh, PA
This mascara is great for adding length. It lasts all day. also great at holding curls. but it doesn't add any volume.
Carriepie from Las Vegas
Excellent mascara. Goes on easy in one coat or add a second for more fullness.
Best Mascara I've tried
Starlitightjess1n1 from Hawthorne
I keep buying this mascara because it does what others can't. I've tried my fair share of mascaras but this by far is the best. I know it can be pricey but it's def worth every penny. Always get compliments when I use this mascara.
I would buy this product over and over again
Jo from Morristown,nj
Great mascara ..totally works
Best mascara out there
Meg from Georgia
This is the best mascara I have found. It lengthens and gives beautiful, clean lashes. I paired it Lancôme's CILS Booster XL primer for more volume and the result is just amazing. Been using this mascara for years and still go back to it, even after trying others. I love the sample size, also.
Lita from SC
This is the best by far.
I have really straight lashes that barely hold a curl and...
J. Romero from Chicago
This mascara did it for me! I decided to risk it for the price tag (after a tik tok) and after I curled my lashes it added length without weighing them down and man I'm so happy, after like 30 different mascaras, I've found the one!
Definitely a bad gal from Lake forest, ca
my lashes fall pretty fast they don't hold a curl. This mascara made my lashes sooo long. I curled my lashes before first coat then waited for them to dry and curled again and added another coat then again curled them & they stayed! No clumping when applied. Definitely recommend!!!
A nightmare to remove
Steph from Tampa, Florida
Even if you're patient and have a really good make up remover, this will make your lashes fall because is SUPER HARD TO REMOVE. Let's be honest, nothing makes us more sad then seeing lashes falling off🤷🏻♀️
Best mascara ever
A.n from Tn
It makes the lashes longer
CJ from Oregon
I have been looking for a new mascara that both makes my lashes look more defined and less sparse. Yes, I have sparse lashes, like many out there and don't want to wear false eyelashes on a daily basis. This mascara does the trick. In just one or two layers, you will see a difference in the look of your lashes. It is also very easy to remove which isn't often the case these days.
Raigan from Manhattan,ks
I applied about 2 layers and it made my lashes look really good, compared to ther mascaras
I wouldn't recommend
Natemah from Oregon
Giving two stars because the length is good and color but how it functions absolutely sucks, I wore it for about 3 hours and it's not water resistant, smearing and crumbling right onto my fingers definitely disappointed with this product
J from Orange City, FL
It doesn't really add volume to my lashes. Maybe a little. But it mostly just clumps. If I put in more than one coat it clumps my lashes so bad. I've been told it's the best but I like the benefit Roller mascara so much better.