Product Reviews Rated 4.14 out of 5 stars
12936 Reviews
Most Helpful Positive Review Amazing I love this Product I am not a big fan of Mascara but this one I fell in love with it doesn't take a lot but it has big pay off. I got this in a gift set that I got for my birthday. It makes me look like I have on fake lashes when I don't so that's a plus! What's not to love it's Too Faced! I am doing this review as part of and Influenster contest.
Most Helpful Critical Review I used to love it I used to love this mascara, it was lengthening and waterproof but the last one I bought smudged all over and it was super clumply, I do t know if they changed the formula but is totally messy now, will be looking for another one
Reviewed by 12936 customers Simply Fabulous 5
ReneeFromTol from Toledo,oh
I LOVE this mascara! I have used mascara over 20 years, so I have definately sampled the inventory.
This mascara is perfect!
I also love the size because the wand fits perfectly in my hand to apply the product.
I love the smaller travel size, over the larger one.
I even give it as gifts to my family and friends because it is so nice.
They all get a kick out of the name!
doesnt stay on my lashes 2
somewhere in between from Louisiana
after about an hour i noticed that i had black smudges under both my eyes. The only new item was the mascara. I didnt wear it the next day, and no black smudges. So nope, not for me.
I would not buy this again. 1
Connor from Myrtle beach South Carolina.
The mascara was clumpy. It broke the skin out around my eyes. I will not buy it again.
Stays On 5
Denise-loves Ulta from New Jersey
This is a fantastic mascara. I also love the waterproof version as well!
Really opens your eyes without clumping and I use this on a daily basis!
My granddaughter got me hooked on this. I love it! 5
Dian from Harbor City
I use this daily and love it.
Not the best 3
D from Michigan
I tried the sample size for better control of wand, I liked the smaller wand but did not like style of brush, I was looking for something new and glad I bought the small one. I felt like I had to do 2 layers, and it went on clumpy.maybe it was an older tube. Overall I was not impressed
highly recommend, yet disappointed 3
kak from Ontario, OH
I purchased this after having a bad experience with a Lancome mascara. it was highly recommended online and by store associates. I tried this product 7 years ago and never had an issue.
I was disappointed as this was hard to apply, was clumpy and finding I have to clean up my skin after applying. the formula is very hard to clean off and I am not happy. I will be returning this product to Ulta. I dont know if it's just the formula or both that and the applicator but I'm disappointed.
Undecided 3
Betsy from Tehachapi
When applied, little remnents of the mascara get underneath my eyes no matter what. So I have to check that none came off underneath my eye. It will come off but then I need to reapply my concealer. It really lasts as far as the water proof part...
Not worth the hype 3
Valeria from Arizona
I wanted a waterproof mascara so I tired this product and the wand wasnt it , it was clumpy, dry . I would not recommend this product to anyone .
My favorite mascara for years! 5
Sammy from Savannah, GA
The Waterproof Better Than Sex mascara is my all time favorite and has been for years. Nothing tops it (trust me i've tried). I like my lashes to look big and dramatic, this does it. A littles goes a long way which I appreciate. I can't say enough pro's about this product. One con is that when the tube gets low the product does tend to dry out and flake.
Does Not Budge! 5
Gd from NH
I have been using waterproof mascaras for years and was always resistant to paying a little bit more for brands like this. I found that the drugstore brands however either had harmful chemicals in their products like paraben and many non-paraben brands were not truly waterproof. I decided to give this one a try after reading all the rave reviews. I was not disappointed! I was impressed with the large brush that worked well on my longer lashes. This mascara provided a lot of volume that didn't fade at all even after 14 hours. I also did not have any issues with clumps or the mascara irritating my eyes like some brands do. If you are hesitant like I was to spend a few extra dollars on this product and want quality, definitely give this mascara a try.
Awful Product 1
JW from Ottawa, IL
I ordered one and it arrived and it was so clumpy and gross it was unusable - Ulta replaced it, and the second one arrived and the applicator brush was broken. I just tossed it and called it a lesson learned. Would not recommend.
Love at first application.I ended up disappointed. 3
Wendella from Oregon
Loved this mascara when I first put it on. It was Julie at like the original. The main reason I buy waterproof mascara is so I don't have mascara under my eyes. Like football player.
After only a hour I looked in the mirror, and to my utter disappointment I had the biggest smudges under my eyes. I had to buy a different mascara. I willNEVER buy it again.
A-MAZE-ING 5
Danny from Dallas TX
I love this mascara, it lasted all day long and when applied I honestly felt like I didn't need false eyelashes! Definitely a fan of this product!
Smeared a couple hours after applying 1
Kal from Wisconsin
Disappointed as it smeared so easily after applying. Will not buy this product again.
Like it but don't like the brush shape 4
Brittalinks from PA
This mascara goes on really easy. Nice color and you don't need to go over it a million times to get it to stick. I'm not fond of the brush shape though but I'm sure other people are, so I'd recommend that people give it a try!
Only good for lengthening....lost some lashes!! 2
Larissa from Pennsylvania
I've used the original better than sex a couple years ago and it was OK but i recall the formula being a little clumpy. But that was 2015 and I was not the greatest with makeup, so I decided to give their waterproof formula a try. It unfortunately is still clumpy. It does lengthen and it does hold somewhat of a curl, but it gave me serious spider lashes. On top of that, i noticed i had several lashes on my makeup wipe after I took it off at the end of the day! Super disappointed. Back on my search for a good mascara....
Very Clumpy, Ugly, Hard to Remove 2
Jenni from New Jersey
I want a waterproof mascara the looks like my real lash. After one sweep, it's just clumps my lashes together making it look so ugly. quite disappointed that it's totally not "better than sex"
My Go-To Mascara 4
LAL from San Antonio, Texas
I wear this mascara almost every day. I like how it lifts and separates my lashes. It makes me feel put together without feeling over done. I enjoy the waterproof formula to prevent any smudging through the day. I experienced irritation around my lash line from a couple of brands that I used to use. I have never had that experience with Too Faced products.
Very very good 5
Marissa from Minnesota
this product holds the curl so well but i have yet to test it in water.
Not waterproof 2
Gail Ann from Wausau, WI
I have deep set eyes and always get raccoon eyes from mascara. Thought waterproof would be better, but this was even worse for me.
HORRIBLE 1
Betty from Ohio
My lashes felt like they never "dried" or "set", it was cakey and it was under my eyes and on my eyelids where my lashes touch below my brows in an hour. HATE IT
Very clumpy 3
SUE from Illinois
I have to use a makeup wipe to get off all the product. Looks very clumpy ( like maybe it's been on shelf too long. Some times it dries and then gets in my eye causing irritation
bet waterproof ever!!! 5
sandy from Mckinney,Tx
only use this waterproof mascara
clumps 2
araz from GR
I wanted a waterproof mascara. This mascara clumps like crazy. I would not recommend.
