Rated 3.32 out of 5 stars
Most Helpful Positive Review Yes yes yes yes yes
I could not be more thrilled with this eyeliner! I was skeptical as most felt eyeliners always seem to bleed when I try to do wings or my eye shadow clumps up on it and renders the tip useless but this eyeliner holds up!
I live in Florida home of humidity and thunderstorms and work outside no matter the weather every single day. My first day wearing it to work I sweated my butt off as usual, got caught in the rain, felt the sweat and water run down my face, and feared for the worst. Checked in a mirror a few hours later and you'd think I had just reapplied it was still so crisp!
Gotta say I don't do smokey eyes just a classic wing every day but if you want precision this is your savior.
Not sure what unicorn blood this is made of but it's totally worth a cursed life.
Most Helpful Critical Review Great Eyeliner....but gave me an allergic reaction
I love this eyeliner for the price, it glides on and stays put. Very good for a 3 dollar liner, however I sadly cannot use it. This first time I washed it off with my regular neutrgena makeup wipes I noticed tiny red flecks around my eyes. But I didn't pay attention to them bc after about a day they were gone. I didn't use the eyeliner for some time and I recently used it again and this time the spots covered my eyelid and the area surrounding my eyes. IF YOU HAVE SENSITIVE SKIN DO NOT BUY. Just a warning because the flecks around my eyes are itchy and are taking forever to go away.
Reviewed by 247 customers Would not buy again!!
Jen from CA
Hate this product!!!
Really not great.
Cbrochu from OK
I have tried this twice, and it's more like a watercolor. I had to swipe several times to see anything. It's not waterproof at all.
waste of money
j from n
it came dry! not even 1 good use from it !
please take this off the site its not worth the money.
i has to use another eyeliner on top ... will never buy again and don't recommend it !
That's a no from me
Lenzielew85 from Peoria AZ
I've been looking for a liquid liner with a longer application tip (hopefully that makes sense) it helps me to line up my eyeliner easily. This was perfect in that aspect but, literally used it once and didn't work on the second eye! I thought maybe it was the eyeshadow underneath but, it didn't make a difference.
Dried up + Patchy
Amy from Miami, Florida
It came like dried up and it pisses me off because it's brand new. I thought I was the only one with this issue, but seeing that other people had the same problems means that the company messed up with their formulas.
Norma from Arizona
It seems like the ink doesn't travel all the way down to the tip therefore it's super patchy, I had to cut half of the tip for it to actually work. I had this eyeliner a while back and it was super juicy and awesome. They might of changed the packaging or formula
Emmy from Co
I didn't like this at all I could't get it to work I tried shaking it leaving it tip down nothing worked for me the tip was dry and scratchy when ever I tried to use it
Maria from Pennsylvania
I opened it, used it on one eye, and it dried out. I store it upside down to at least get some of it out but it doesn't last for longer than one eye at a time. I would just recommend saving up to buy a more expensive liner.
J from U.S.
I wanted to love this product so bad. Unfortunately I did not. This pen has a very flimsy tip and also barely any product comes out. When you want to go over any like you created it doesn't go over well. It literally just starts to take it off.
Brit from Tennessee
I received my first one 2 weeks ago. The tip is extremely flimsy and overall it was dried out would not make a line unless I mashed down to the middle of the felt tip. Ulta sent a replacement and same thing with the new one. Very sad about this because the formula itself seems great, it would not wash off my hand.
Dry and the Tip is Flimsy
Ashley R. from Northridge
I used it like once and its dried up. The tip is so flimsy.
The tip is so flimsy you can't use it.
Kelli from Tennessee
The tip is so flimsy it is unusable. I use various Essence products and have been pleased. This eyeliner was a waste of money but thankfully cheap enough I didn't lose much.
Em from Pennsylvania
I think they changed something about this product since I last bought it. The tip is too long, to the point where it's too flimsy to draw precise lines. I can't really draw wings with it since it is so bendy. On top of that, the liquid doesn't come out sometimes. I literally accidentally erased my wing the other day while trying to fill it in... one positive is that once it's on it stays on. Would have formerly recommended this, but not anymore.
Vi from Ca
Super dry tip and couldn't use it at all.
Really long lasting
Marianna from Minnetonka
I really like how long it lasts and that is so easy to do a wing with it, but HATE the fact that it's not that pigmented, It's not as black as I would like it to be
Megz from Tucson, AZ
You have to press really hard to get product to come out, thus making a thin line impossible.
Did not stay put
Hs from Pittsburgh,pa
Bought this to wear to a funeral knowing I'd be crying. Wear test had it all over my face with 1 drop of water. Goes on well, I just wont be using it if theres a chance of moisture
I wouldn't buy this again.
Katie from Colorado
I was trying to find a good liquid eyeliner. This was NOT what I was looking for. Its a felt tip liner but the actual liquid eyeliner wouldn't come out. Its almost like its already dry. It does not apply well either.
Liz from Macomb
Not black enough dries out fast. Okay for a few uses but after that toss it. Save your money up to buy a better eyeliner or color pop bff liner/ L'Oréal telescopic carbon black for a way better result. In the long run you'll waste your money because you have to repurchase so much
strwbry_xoxo42 from CO
I love this waterproof eyeliner! inexpensive and can make my wing in a snap. I do use UD eye primer because my lids are oily and then apply this on top!
Great for the price
Stephany from Norman, OK
I love to create a wing look but I hate not being able to get close to my lashes for it to look proper, for $3 this was perfect to help me get close to my lashes. The very tip wasn't dry either which is something I have run into with other fine tip felt liner pens. Definitely recommend and will buy again.
Horrible eyeliner quality
Jay M from Indian Land, SC
Dried out quickly and the felt point wasn't precise
Patchy translucent dry
Yaya from Bay Area, CA
Bought this in hope of using for my trip to Oahu next week. Your eye area has to be extremely dry free of any oil before applying this. The tip is long and hard to make a point it doesn't go on smooth very patchy and translucent. Tried to go over it to make it darker and it only lifted up what was already applied. I wouldn't recommend this item
Dry. Not a fine tip.
Sarah from Ohio
I bought this hoping it would be a good, cheap drugstore option to replace my expensive waterproof eyeliner. I didn't like this from the very first use. First of all, I don't know why it's called "Super fine". The tip is thicker than their normal liquid eyeliner. It's just a super long tip which makes it hard to work with. The tip does not work well if you want a thin or sharp line.
On top of that, it was very dry. It didn't go on smoothly, I found myself trying to make it work for 5+ minutes. It felt like I was using an old eyeliner, even though this was brand new. I tried using it a couple more times but it's just not worth it. I don't advise buying this at all. Maybe try their normal waterproof eyeliner, but this is no good.
Love how easy it is to use
Kp from Orlando Florida