Rated 4.25 out of 5 stars
Most Helpful Positive Review Amazing!!
I was looking for a long wear matte lip cream and was directed to this. The salesgirl was super helpful and told me that Patina was a shop favorite so I tried it and loved the color right away! Patina is a great neutral color, like a dusky rose. Anyway, I wore it today to my family's early Thanksgiving dinner and it lasted all day!! I drank water and beer & ate a full turkey dinner. I am truely amazed by this lip cream. It isn't drying at all and it's been on for 8 hours! I will definitely be trying other colors!
Most Helpful Critical Review Zero stars was not an option; HATED this item!
We purchased this item to use for competitive cheer after explaining we needed a red matte color that would stay in place during long days of cheer competitions because the sales clerk said that it would stay in place and "won't come off without a good makeup remover." A few teammates purchased it for the same reasons. This did not end up being the case for us. It smeared all over faces, clothes and anything that even brushed across their lips. It DID however require a lot to get the color the smearing caused off. It wouldn't let me give zero stars, so 1 star it is.
Reviewed by 3289 customers It doesn't stay on all day
Kimmy from Muskogee, Okla
It doesn't stay on all day
Doesn't last at all of you eat or drink anything
Francie from Portland oregon
I've purchased Fiery several times. I absolutely love the color and it seemed to hold up ok, not great to eating or drinking. I recently purchased a new one, different color, and love how it looks but it doesn't last at all if you eat or drink. I've purchased Rimmel ones for half the price that last much better. I love the stila colors but the price is too high if it doesn't hold up at all.
I was disappointed
Kass from Florida
I've been looking for a good red lipstick and I bought this in Beso, which is a beautiful color. But this lipstick doesn't last, despite its claims. I've tried using lip primer under it, I've tried lip balm, I've tried it with a liner underneath, I've tried it on its own. Nothing works for me. I don't expect it to last through a meal, but even with drinking it smears. Now with wearing a mask, it's worse. It smears more and ends up looking messy. The edges don't stay clean. It doesn't break down and pile up in the corners of my mouth, which is one good thing. It also doesn't feel heavy or too drying like many matte liquid lips. But I still had higher expectations for staying power.
Stays all day
Blue from Houston
Loved the color and the fact I didn't need a liner loved so much I bought for my mom and sister oh and very kissable!
Color is Deceiving
Sarah from Utah
The color does not really have any pink to it. More of a lighter terracotta clay color. Still looked good on me but not a nudish color or color for spring. Will keep for the fall. Also the applicator holds a lot, so it's easy to put too much on. Does have great lasting power. I work in a hospital and wear a mask all day. It didn't rub off on it at all, which is the main reason for buying it!
Best Lip on the market,stays on,never dry nor cracks
Poppi's Happy Wife from AZ
Love Stila Lip, Amazing
Fantastic Wear for all day or night!
T. Marie from Dallas, TX
I bought the Beso and the Caramello. Beso was beautiful and vibrant! it definitely was true to color and the best lipstick I've ever had. Caramello was the same great formula, but was more grey/beige and didn't go well with my olive skin tone. I was hoping the caramello was more of a pinkish nude, like natural lips, but was a little disappointed. I will definitely keep buying Stila and trying different colors.
Product lover from Galt, Ca
I tried using this several times but had to return.
Not what expected
Artist from 3/23/21
This lipstick is nothing like what I expected. I thought it would me matte and comfortable which it was but it was not long lasting. I took a small sip of pop, and then the lipstick get everywhere. It got smudged all over my lips/Cupid's bow. It was not long lasting nor smudge proof, but it was comfortable on. Wasn't drying on the lip, nor uncomfortable to have on, but not a good long lasting liquid at all.
Tagged it wrong or different formula!!???!! IDK
Rosie from Plainfield, Illinois
I love it, it is the one I usually use, BUT something weird happened. When I put it on it was a different color, the tag said PATINA, but different shade.
I'm not sure if STILA tagged it wrong or they changed the formula. I went back to ULTA to get the correct shade, but they didn't have more.
SO, make sure you are getting the correct product before you get home.
Buy if you like a true matte lipstick
Sexy Mama from Anne Arundel County MD
I bought this lipstick because I liked the shade. Well I thought I would. It didn't happen. The shade was too dark for my fair complexion. If you want a lipstick to wear under your mask this is a good one. The color stays on and on and on. I couldn't remove the color until I used a makeup wipe. I matte finish is very drying. So I returned it. If you want a matte that stays on this is the one for you. Use a hydrator before you put in on to save your lips.
I'm very disappointed in this product.
Skeeter from Oklahoma
I have been using a less expensive product which worked great but wanted a color for spring that that brand did not have. I expected it to "stay all day" but found when I ate and drank, it came off and had to be reapplied unlike the less expensive brand. I put it on in the morning and have to take it off with makeup remover in the evening after eating and drinking all day. Won't be buying anymore of this product.
I love this!
Steph from TN
I bought it because of an interview with AOC, as I'm government as well. Wasn't disappointed.
The perfect red lip
Jen from Chicago
Okay this lipstick is amazing. I normally wear very simple, subtle make up but wanted a red lip for my 30th birthday! It made every picture pop and I got so many compliments. Only had to touch it up once after eating dinner but it stayed on perfectly for 8+ hours
GirlMomma from Dallas, TX
I'm a mom of two and love that I can still give my babies kisses without smudging my lipstick all over their cheeks!
My favorite lip product!
Meggs from VA
This is my absolute favorite lipstick I have multiple shades and they're all so beautiful. It stays on when I eat and I love to eat so that's great. Kissable, stays on all day. Would love it if it came in a black shade as well.
Patty Cakes from Wisconshoen
The only liquid lipstick to outlast my munchies. 🥳😋 An absolute must.
Staceisthename from West Virginia
I bought this lipstick because of the good reviews and I'm not sure if I read far enough or what, but I hate this mess here. Goes on very smooth and foolproof but it doesn't stay on. Within seconds, I noticed blank spots where I'd applied it and just thought it was where it was settling and darkening but it literally disappears within seconds of application. Aside from that, it happens to be messy and gets on your face and everywhere else and it stains anything but your lips (LOL). I'm still trying to figure out how it got all over my hands and face...
Now, I have some other stay-all-day lippies that I'm not crazy about because they're drying and for the most part, they last at least half the day, but I thought this one would be an exception, what with the cost and all. Wrong! I'll stick with Stila (lasts ALL day!) and continue to spend a little more for what I know I'm getting my money's worth. I will continue to purchase NARS' foundation but never will I go for any other product and especially this lip pigment. It's going back ASAP.
Find something else; don't waste your money.
Blanca from brownsville
I bought due to it being highly recommended. I didnt even get through the beginning of my meal, when this lippie was gone! no transfer or smudge proof. it ended up everywhere making me look like a clown.
Dark way too dark
Caroline from Nyc
Ok so I've purchased 2 different colors 2 different times online. And both the colors which look light online are soooooo dark! I look like a vampire... I will unfortunately have to return again..
I would buy this again in different colors
kc from CA
Overall I like the product and did try some other colors. What I would say for sure is that once I apply the product the color becomes much darker looking. I still like the color and it does last well just keep in mind that it does look much darker when applied. I still recommend the product.
It Gets Everywhere
Tiffness from Nevada
I was looking forward to a dark lip color that stayed put, didn't fade, and didn't transfer (all claims by Stella). This lipstick is none of those things. I let it dry for a considerable amount of time and didn't apply anything on top of it. It was on everything. My mask, my face, my drink, my napkin, my hands. The color lasted enough to be annoying. Since it was everywhere I eventually tried to wipe off the remainder and not worry about it. But when I tried to remove it, a dull and lifeless color was left behind.
B from Michigan
I have purchased several stila stay all day liquid lipstick and for whatever reason this color does not stay on as good as my others. It constantly came off onto my drinking cups and whenever I happened to touch it or kiss my fiance. I LOVE the shade but wish it would STAY ALL DAY.
HollyG from Arkansas
It truly stays on and didn't rub off on my mask! But it applies much darker than anticipated.
I love this!
Maggie from Ohio
This is one of the best liquid lipsticks I've ever used. The color is vibrant and does not move, and it doesn't dry out my lips (which is amazing because I usually have very dry lips)!