Product Reviews Rated 4.42 out of 5 stars
4011 Reviews
Most Helpful Positive Review All Time Favourite! I fell in love with this lip liner a few years back, but finally branched out in colours and I'm so happy I did! Pale Pink is my go to colour for under almost all of my lipsticks on a regular basis. Not only does it help keep the lipstick in the lines(no running anywhere), but it also keeps my lipstick on through straws, food, and anything else that comes my way! The selection of colours is incredible and I love the consistency of the more matte ones! I'm not a big fan of the shiny ones(like Petal), but the matte ones are so creamy that sometimes I wear them alone!
Most Helpful Critical Review Good lip liner, different color than pictured I've bought NYX lip liners before and really liked them. Recently I bought purple rain, which is pictured as a light purple, almost lilac. I received it in the mail today and it is DARK. It is a dark fuchsia/magenta. I'm very disappointed.
Reviewed by 4011 customers Too dry 1
Hillary from UT
I bought this (and one other NYX lip liner) on the recommendation of a youtuber, and I really cannot understand why these are seemingly so popular. These are the dryest lip liners I've ever used, and it was practically impossible to get any color pay-off. I returned them both.
Amazing 5
kaelyn from North carolina
I got the color nude pink and it's a perfect natural shade for my lips! Goes on smoothly and stays forever! Blends easily with my glosses.
Not as pigmented 3
KittenSixx from San Antonio TX
The color is lighter than I expected it to be. My lipstick that is a mauve color is actually darker than the lip liner. Not as pigmented as some of their other lip liners such as Fuschia , Natural and Ever.
Great budget lipliner 4
Gigi's Mom from California
I stumbled upon this liner in the drugstore. After being impressed by the formula I went on the hunt for the right color. That took a bit of trial and error as the actual color never seemed to match the swatch on the outside of the pencil. But I found Pale Pink and I love it! Its a perfect base shade and matches my own lip color well. It also is a good shade to mix with other liners that may be too warm toned. I blend this one with a liner in a Cappuccino shade and it turns out a super cool mauve I haven't been able to find in one liner. It's all about blending! I prefer this liner to the NYX suede version which is a softer formula and tends to flake off and not draw a clean line like this one does. Overall great budget friendly liner that lasts.
Yes 5
Cynthia from Chula Vista
Goes on smoothly
Don't buy 1
River from Spokane Wa
I didn't like it at all. I use Mac lip liner but thought I would try this since I was buying the lip gloss. It's horrible however. Lip gloss is great. Lip liner is not.
amazing! 5
jes from michigan
super creamy and as good (or even better) as some higher end liners. also won't get this price anywhere else!!
Beautiful Everyday Lip Liner! 5
mmm from ut
I got the shade "peekaboo natural" and it's a perfect pinky nude color. I just line my lips, add some clear gloss, and it's perfect!
So smooth 5
Callie from SF, CA
Holy moly this is in the top 3 of best lip liners I've ever used. Stays super sharp after multiple uses and glides on so smooth, giving you the best outline before lipstick application!
Lip me 5
Harmoni from Los angeles
outter lip for fill in
I like em nude 5
Harmoni from Los angeles
outer lip only
Great! 5
Piper's Mom from North Carolina
This pencil works better than many I've paid more for.
good formula 4
Belen from Fresno
it's a good product, it goes in very smoothly but the only thing i don't like about it is that it's the same as my regular lips shade so choose your shades carefully!
Its okay 3
Myra from Carson City
These went on decently, but I had to build it up to get decent color from them and it didn't stand out as much as I wanted.
I think these are a good cheap buy, but there are for sure better products out there for a similar price.
Great Quality but Bold Colour 5
SEH from Chester, VA
I use this by lining gently around my lips and then rubbing the color towards the inside of my lip to blend it in. It is a dark colour. Thankfully, by massaging it in and around my lips, my lips look fuller and darker. I only wear this colour with a medium-dark lip product. No bright pinks or nudes around this :)
Nice Lip Liner 5
Micki3 from Sacramento CA
This is a very pale pink. Goes on well, I'll use it to lighten if needed. Not my favorite as it's really light.
GET IT 5
Bea from Arizona
This is by far my FAVORITE lip product I own! The color, the texture, everything is perfect! Definitely recommend buying it!
It's fine 3
Shakezula the mic ruler from Poplar bluff mo
I just don't dig this liner. All my beauty gurus love it. It's fine. I won't buy it again though.
Ouch! 1
Carolyn from MI
Ouch! I tried to apply this and it just hurt. Not a smooth application AT ALL. Ended up returning
It's okay 2
Nai from San Bernardino
I don't think this is worth the hype. I've been wanting to get this lip liner for a long time and when I get it it's not as I expected. It actually makes my lips feel chapped even though I moisturize my lips before putting it on. Sorry but a no from me.
really wish it didn't break me out :( 2
ultaoversephora from chicago
I have so many of these liners and love them for the shades and application. but I started to notice that every time I'd wear them, I'd get breakouts around my mouth/lips. I wasn't sure if it was the liner or not so I stopped wearing it for a few weeks and not a breakout since. really sad this formula didn't work for me but it's a great product otherwise
I love this lip pencil! 5
Ellie from Pinecrest, FL
I put a thin layer of Aquaphor on my lips, then pencil, and then a little lipstick.
absolutely love 5
gigi from santa ana, ca
it was amazing, i would get this in different colors as well. it was really easy to apply
Pillow talk lip pencil dupe 5
Mel from Nc
Bought this to match my Charlotte tilbury pillow talk lipstick. Perfect match
I loveeee this lip liner!!!! 5
Myers❤️ from Florida
I got the shade Nutmeg and it's literally the best lip liner soft and feels nice in the lips definitely buying it again.
