Rated 4.36 out of 5 stars
Most Helpful Positive Review Great long lasting lipstick
I pretty much loved everything about this product. The packaging was nice, it was easy to open, felt nice in my hands, the tube itself seemed like it was better quality- I've easily cracked lids on other eye/lip pencil-type products but this seems like it would hold up nicely, the lid didn't come off in my purse (another thing that happens with other products), and it even comes with a built-in sharpener (on the other end/bottom). I was really impressed! It was easy to use, easy to apply, you can wipe off "mistakes" easily (I did it right away), it feels nice when applying it, and when wearing it, it actually lasted all day too! Sometimes the long lasting/stain lip sticks don't actually last very long, but this did! I've noticed with other long lasting lip products, it really dries out your lips, but this wasn't too bad. My lips felt a little more dry than usual, but not to the point of it being really uncomfortable to use/wear. So far, it's my favorite long lasting lipstick! I really recommend this product! There are several shades to choose from :) I thought it was funny that my favorite shade I sampled, was called "hustle in heels". So I enjoyed using it, and we got a laugh from the name of this particular shade. [product:maybelline-superstay-ink-crayon-lipstick] I received this product complimentary for review purposes.
Most Helpful Critical Review Love the formula of these-The smell not very much!
I received 3 of these lip crayons for free for testing purposes, however my review is 100% honest nonetheless.
Now, the shade that I like the most is Stay Exceptional. It is in the mauve family and I can see it being a very universal shade to wear for a wide variety of skin tones for sure. The shades of all three lip crayons that I got are nicely pigmented and they glide on very smoothly as well. The only thing that i'm not found is the smell. It is quite perfumey and not really pleasant to smell, in my opinion. I honestly wish that they were either made to be fragrance free or at least had a more pleasant scent to them instead. If you are someone who's okay with quite perfumey scented lipsticks, the I would recommend you see to give these lip crayons a try, otherwise I would recommend giving giving it a pass, unfortunately.
Reviewed by 665 customers Stop at Nothing
D28K from Bay Area
This is a great warm color, and it's very comfortable! I love that it's more of a cream finish, not glossy, not matte. Because of the built in applicator it always goes on easily. It's not transfer proof but if you care more about comfort and color pay off, this is a winner!
I wanted to exchange but couldn't
AB from Mount Pleasant, South Carolina
It's nice as an all over color and is soft at first, but dries your lips overtime and comes off/ fades. Also this color was way to orange for me.
Cute colors but does not super "stay"
Brooke from Nashville
I really liked the crayon application and the color. But unfortunately this smears everywhere. It takes a LONG time to matte down and will move less once it does, but even then- it's definitely not long wear.
New to this but starting to enjoy the look
Busy mom on the run from OKC, OK
So I am not a make up expert by any means but I would definitely say this is helping me get a more defined look than just lip gloss or lipstick. I feel like my lips looks better when I use this over lipstick. For what ever reason my lips almost look fuller when I use the crayon.
Excellent Lip Color
Barb from Oklahoma USA
I recently bought several of the SuperStay Ink Crayon specifically to use for lip liners in order to make my lipstick last longer. I am beyond happy with this product because of the staying power and the beautiful color. The Ink Crayon delivers long lasting lip stain in which I am a huge fan. Most reviewers call their fave beauty products "holy grail". This lip color is my holy grail. I bought four lip colors with Ulta's but one get one half. The high end lipsticks cost 20-40 dollars, and these from Maybelline deliver beautiful lipstick and lip color for less money without sacrificing quality. Please Maybelline don't discontinue these SuperStay Lipsticks, you hit a home run with this product!
Ummmm I'm confused
Emmie pie from La grande, OR
This product has a nice selection of color, but the one I received has a rough sandy texture, almost although it has fiber in it. And it only lasts around half an hour before wiping away and leaving my lips looking quite ugly with the residue.
Creamy but not for long
XOBABYCAKE from IDAHO
I loved it with a matching lip liner. After putting it on I realized it only stays on for maybe an hour if you do a lot of talking.
Love this product.
Britt from Columbus, ohio
Nice when you add shine
Hashmi from Pearland, TX
I really like how easy this is to apply and use. I wasn't sure how the finish would be because it was a crayon, but it still gives a very matte finish, which I love. The formula is creamy, yet the finish is matte, so it doesn't leave your lips dry like some other products.
Pretty good but not the best
Hiz from Houston Tx
The application is very smooth and almost feels creamy but still like a crayon.. The pigment is also very nice. My only complaint is that after a bit it feels really dry on my lips. Its not that bad that it gets dry because I usually put a gloss over it clear/semi clear and it still looks really nice.
Hil from San Antonio @ South Park mall
Lip stain does not smear when wearing your mask .
Okay but not Great
KRL from Arkansas
After seeing so many people rave about these lip crayons I was so excited to try them and bought two different colors. Unfortunately, I don't love them. Very easy to apply and the color does last for a little while but after half an hour my lips looked patchy and dry. I use a lip moisturizer before I wear matte lip sticks and even that didn't help, it actually made it harder to apply. Probably will not buy again.
I like that it stays on well and it's my lip color.
Annie from Allentown,pa
It comes off a little bit on my face mask but washes out in the wash!
I want every color
Tara from Columbia, South Carolina
I have used the Maybelline Superstay Matte Ink in several colors and always liked it, however, I wanted something slightly softer and easier to apply as I feel like that sometimes feels sticky on my lips and I have to get it on just right because of the staying power. This crayon glides on so nicely and was so easy to use around the edge of my lips with the pointed end. The color was so nicely pigmented and stayed on my lips so well - even after mask wearing and having the four course meal at Melting Pot. I want to get almost all the colors they have now! The color in the picture is Treat Yourself
Color doesn't match packaging
Emmaaaaa janeeeeee from Waco, TX
My friend purchased this and due to covid we had to go with the tube color as there is no testing allowed (for obvious reasons). We both thought it would be a deep red color as she chose the last shade available at our Ulta but my god, it was bright, nearly neon, pink. I have purchased this before and loved the shad I got which was a nude so just be careful ig.
Ann from Us
Stays on for hours
Pigmented and comfortable on the lips
PiGirl from Texas
I heard good things about the Maybelline SuperStay Ink Crayons and I wasn't disappointed. I got the shades Live on the Edge and Settle for More. Both are beautifully pigmented and comfortable on the lips. A great drugstore find for me.
I would buy this product again and recommend
Mel from Midwest City, OK
Wore out for errands. I use a lip liner first then apply crayon lipstick. Love it.
Favorite go to!
Jennifer from Lititz, PA
This is my favorite go to lipstick. I usually buy high end, and I have tried so many, but nothing as good as this stuff! Stays put most of the day, and doesn't come off on a mask. Have many many colors :)
Love the color, love the staying power
Lindsey from KY
I got this item in the shade Lead the Way. It is beautiful! I love the staying power of this and it is a super comfortable to wear.
Super cute color
Riah from Dayton
Was a tad more pink than I thought it would be, but still is a very pretty color. It stays in my purse as my "go to"
Stayed on even while wearing my mask. No drying out of my li
Terry from Az
Jenn from Michigan
This stays on great. Since we're all wearing masks I have worn this for hours at work with a mask over top and it's still on pretty good at the end of the day.
Megan from Tulsa
Love it goes on good stays on for hours
I wouldn't call this a superstar lipstick!
Facial nurse from Hurricane, WV
It doesn't stay on very well.