Product Reviews Rated 4.57 out of 5 stars
218 Reviews
Most Helpful Positive Review Gorgeous colours from Pérsona Hi Sons
From Sydney Australia
I purchased the palette a while ago and have enjoyed mixing and matching the matte and shimmer shades as eye shadows, highlights and even lipglosses
The colours are amazing and the actual products are smooth and light ...
Thank you And keep up the good work!
Love Joanne Navarra x
Most Helpful Critical Review Wanted to love this I had such high hopes for this palette because of Tati (Glam Life Guru). The palette packaging is beautiful and looks promising. The shadows blend nicely with little fallout. Here is why it only gets one star from me: the shadows dull and disappear within an hour. I tried using a few different eye shadow primers and nothing works. I even used fix+ when applying the shimmers and again, they apply beautifully, but disappear within the hour. So disappointing. I bought two of these (one for me, one for a friend) before even trying it. Stupid mistake. Oh well, I'll use it for those natural/work days when I don't care if my eye shadow looks fade fast.
Reviewed by 218 customers Obsessed 5
Emerald from Richmond, VA
Absolutely one of my favorite pallets. Good for everyday, but also has some shimmers if you want to kick it up a notch.
good formula, but 4
msh from san diego
The formula is pretty good. Blends fairly well, although a couple of the colors start out a little patchy. The palette really leans cool, so it washes my olive skin out quite a bit.
everyday beautiful 5
Amy from Philadelphia PA
I was so impressed with this formula. the mattes blend so well and are buttery. the shimmers are smoothing and elegant. they remind me if Sydney grace shimmers. I can't stop using this palette. love the packaging too. it feels kind of luxe
Great buttery soft palette 5
Cecilia from Los Angeles
I am so happy with my purchase! I love how soft the pigments are and stays on all day.
STAYS PUT! 5
Eye palette junkie from Ohio
I honestly do not understand the negative reviews (even though they are mostly positive). I just got this palette for half off, and debated whether or not to order it. Then when it came I thought it looked so basic I almost didn't try it and considered just returning it. SO happy I didn't! Everything creases on me. With primer, without, concealer, setting powder, high end, drugstore, everything eventually creases on my hooded eyelids! After twelve hours it's still going strong and the colors, oh my. Really surprised me. The tones are beautiful and blend like a dream! Everyday or full glam this one has it all.
One of my faves! 4
Steph from Home
I bought this is one of the 21 days specials. It's so pigmented, creamy and smooth. The shimmers are beautiful without being glittery, and it definitely had the longevity to last all day. Love it!
Great Pallete! 5
Jenn from Fresno, Ca
Pallete is easy and great for beginners. It is soft, creamy, pigmented and blendable. I use the shimmers with my fingers, there's not much fall out. This is an upgrade from Tarte in Bloom due to the shimmers packing a punch. This is my everyday palette. Eye looks in this pallete are more for evening unless I use any of the top shades and charming as a transition for daytime looks. Get this when they run a sale, price is high.
Arrived damaged, unacceptable 2
mg16003 from St Louis, Missouri
Arrived with 4 of the shades broken. Returning. I've never received shipped items damaged before from Ulta.
Blendable and Pigmented 4
~Juliet from Midwest
I love this palette for its multiple eye looks I can create. The shadows are creamy and easy to blend, the palette comes with a nice sized mirror and is travel friendly. But my only complaint is the steep $price tag, so if you can get this on sale it's worth the buy. Overall it's a great pallet, the formula of the shadows is wonderful and pigmented and bendable, so I knocked a star off for the price tag.
Change price 1
Hi from FL
I got around $30 I don't why the price is higher. The shimmer is creamy and super pigment. It just the matte is not so pigment
So pigmented and blends so well 5
CL from San Francisco, CA
This is an AMAZING palette!! I've been eyeing this palette for the longest time but felt I had too many similar palettes to justify the purchase. I finally bit the bullet and got it last month and am so happy I did! The quality of this palette is 100% and could possibly be the best I've used in 10+ years. I love my urban decay naked palettes, tarte palettes, and my ABH palette, but this is seriously the best in terms of pigmentation and how smooth and buttery the colors are! The mattes are so easy to blend and the metallics are sooo pigmented. They are amazing for a night out look. If you like more subtle shine, the metallics are mostly very glittery, but trust me, they go on so well and look so good. You could definitely use a lighter hand to work with it. I am so happy with this palette and this gives me so much more confidence in the brand that I might just try more from them.
Hands down the best quality palette! 5
Marty mom of 3 from TX
I am 40 with a huge infatuation with all things beauty and I am so sad I waited so long to try this eyeshadow palette!! The pigment is akin to colourpop shadows. Deeply pigmented yet smooth like Natosha Danona palettes. These shimmer - I hesitate to call them "shimmer" are better than super shock shadows more similar to LM caviar sticks but they're powder. Insane in a totally good way. Highly recommend! Do not let this so called neutral palette fool you!
So so so good! 5
Chloe from Washington
I own a lot of palettes, so it can be very hard to find a unique one that really adds something to my collection, but this one did it! First of all, the quality is amazing. The metallics are so reflective and pigmented and the mattes are easy to blend and buildable. I also really love the shades in this palette as there are definitely some more colorful shades but they're muted enough to where they work for everyday looks. Love this palette so much!
5 star for persona 1 star for ulta 5
nj2nc mom from cary, nc
I ordered the persona identity 1 palette on sale along with big sexy heat protectant. The packaged arrived this morning with the palette and spray in a bubble wrap bag. I was really annoyed as soon as I saw the can had a dent but I could move on and deal with it. When I opened the palette the gold digger shade was broken and several shades around it had cracked. I managed to repress everything back into place just because I wanted to test the palette. The palette is beautiful and perfect for day and evening looks. The colors lasted all day with no fading or creasing. I am definitely going to contact ulta to exchange the palette.
Great palette 5
Viv from Phx
I've heard positive things on this palette, so i decided to get it. Wow! It's so pigmented and all the eyeshadows are beautiful.
Why did I wait si long to buy this? 5
Michelle from MI
Wow. This palette is stunning. All the colors are SO pigmented and vibrant. The mattes blend out flawlessly and the shimmers are creamy. This palette blows me away with quality. Doesnt look that excited from the naked eye but when used and swatched....incredible!
100% Worth The Money 5
Kdubpharm from Chandler, Az
When I read less than stellar reviews on this palette I am truly dumbfounded. This palette is stunning and ranks up there with ALL of the high end shadows including PM/ND/Viseart/Nars etc and I have several of their palettes) in terms of formulation, pigmentation/saturation, blendibility. The shadows are buttery and they blend seamlessly. You do not need a finger to swipe on the shimmers, a brush works great. I would say these are very similar to Sydney Grace shadows and that line is perfection. I think the price is fair in relation to the quality, plus you could always wait for a 20% off sale. I would give it more stars If I could.
Terrific all-in-one palette 4
Katie L. from Oakland, CA
I hemmed and hawed about buying this product for a long time. By the time I decided to, it was out of stock, pending the re-packaging project. I just received mine, and have really enjoyed it. Everything I've tried from Persona so far has been high quality and reasonably priced. I do think this palette is a bit rich for what it is, even though the packaging is very good and the mirror in it is ideal. Most importantly, the shadows are very buttery, and work well with brushes or fingers. The shimmers are very special - unique and foiled, but no too much at all. The cooler toned shadows in here are a little patchier than the warmer shades, but they can be built up, and they last all day.
beautiful 5
mikachu from tx
this palette is the same as the original. all she did is redo the packaging. the colors are very pigmented. they are beautiful. she said she didn't change the formula. so it's the same as 4 years ago. the colors hold very well. in think it is worth the price. last all day. if it doesn't then you are not using eyeshadow primer. trust me I have bought this more then once. that's how much I love it
Why the hype 2
AmyM from KY
I have heard loads of good reviews on this but honestly I returned it. It blends poorly and patchy. I have had way better quality drug store palettes.
Nothing special 1
Kp from California
There is nothing really special about this palette.
Love this! 5
Mary from New York
Colors are perfect for me and they last!
Beautiful on my brown eyes, though shimmers fade 4
Joy from USA
All the shades look great on my brown eyes! And I love the selection of shades too. My only issue with this palette is that the shimmer shadows don't last as long on me compared to other shadows (like ABH, tarte, UD, etc). They start fading after 6-7 hours. I've never had this issue with shimmer shadows before (I use NARS eye base and set it with Rimmel stay matte powder, for reference). Otherwise, great palette!
No 1
Jillian from NM
I returned it when I received it in the mail. When I opened it the colors didn't strike me as something I would like. The all seemed to have a gray undertone.
Okay Neutral Cool Tone 5
Hi from FL
When I got this palette I was happy. But later it was hard to created a look. I only can think of a smokey eyeshadow or cut crease and a snow glob eyeshadow look. The shimmer yellow and matte purple eyeshadow look great together. I would say it best palette. This palette look good on colour eyes instead of dark brown eyes.
