Product Reviews Rated 4.42 out of 5 stars
876 Reviews
Most Helpful Positive Review I am not very familiar... I am not very familiar with how to shape eyebrows, so this was a challenge for me and I do wish the packaging provided a bit more details about this aspect, but, my lack of knowledge isn't going to affect the review of this item, as that would not be fair. As for the product, very nice! You are provided with a filler, a shaper and a definer, all in one, which makes things very convenient and compact for any travels. The filler goes on rather smooth, so it doesnt feel like you have to press very hard to get anything on, which is nice. I liked that the product lasted me all day, even with having oily skin. All in all, I'm pleased!
Most Helpful Critical Review One of the worst products I have used so far Within the first use, the pencil repeatedly broke off. The powder is useless after one use. Also the application is inconsistent. I had to read the packaging to find out if it was a single use product. It is not.
Reviewed by 876 customers I would buy this product again and again and again 5
greatbrows from Greenville, NC
I love how well it lines the brows, then the powder fills in and then the brush smooths out the brows!! It last all day!!
I did not like 3
aidaa34 from undisclosed
I did not like it. The pencil/crayon did not meet my expectations. I did like the powder.
Back in the early 4
missourimissy from undisclosed
Back in the early 2000's I tweezed my eyebrows down to nothing, and now they're so thin that I need a brow enhancing product. I have been using this one for a couple weeks. I love the idea of a pencil, filler, and brush in one tool. I think the filler and the brush work great, but I wish the pencil was a little more firm. I like to make defined, hair-like strokes with a pencil to get a more realistic look, and this pencil is just too soft to pull that off. Also, if your face gets oily, this product will smudge. However, I'm picky about my eyebrow products, and I do think this brow creator tool is an excellent addition to my makeup toolbox!
For the price this 4
aprilb137 from undisclosed
For the price this is a great product. If you need a little help with your brow game, give this product a try.
I absolutely love and 5
myya from undisclosed
I absolutely love and will recommend this brow creator to anyone that will listen ! I love the creamy feel
Oh my goodness ladies!! 5
italianlushie from undisclosed
Oh my goodness ladies!! This is what I've been looking for!! Super fine point and is a waxy pomade texture that goes on easily and smoothly. When you go over with the powder swab and fluff w spoolie; voila!! Long lasting, non-smudging and natural looking!! I will buy once this runs out and I recommend to everyone!!
I'm really pleased with 4
tamardbradshaw from undisclosed
I'm really pleased with this product. My eyebrows are hopeless, they grow in so oddly and so I just keep them from going wild and use Revlon Colorstay Brow Creator so I actually have nice eyebrows! Easy to use, wide range of colors, and it has staying power so you won't have to worry about re-applying or touch-ups. I definitely recommend.
I've been buying this 4
nicholeg27 from undisclosed
I've been buying this product for 4 years.. It's nice to outline shade and also color in with powder Easy to use easy to apply and It stays out all day.. I have Brown eyes and I use the dark Brown or light black. I will buy again and continue to buy it's the only thing that works on me makes my eyes look great with beautiful brows.
I always use this 5
gabym135 from undisclosed
I always use this product. I recommend it a 100 percent. Is very effective. The price is reasonable.
Waste of money 1
anneliz from Ohio
Very disappointed in this product. Used it twice and the tip fell out and there doesn't seem to be any powder left.
My new brow creator 4
Dee from Annapolis, Md.
I like my new Blonde brow Creator pencil. The only problem is the pencil has broken off into short little pieces. So, I am not sure how long I can use it. Maybe packaging could be better.
Thank you, D. Wimbish
Best everyday brow cosmetic so far 5
BigRed from VA
My brows are very sparse. Most pencils and pomades leave a crayon like shine. Powders alone fade quickly. Using both together gives the best result and having them all in one tool is ideal!
I love Revlon colorist 5
loria33 from undisclosed
I love Revlon colorist brow creator. It has five benefits in one tool. Fill, define, sculpt, diffuse and shape. It unscrews and the define is on the other side of the the fill. I really think this is perfect. I would buy this again. I'm thinking this is an upgrade from the original colorstay brow pencil.
I love this revlon 5
lilibethl5 from undisclosed
I love this revlon pencil because it works very well the eyebrows look already beautiful and natural and it is so inexpensive I recommend it
I like this product, 5
makaylac50 from undisclosed
I like this product, not my favorite but itll do the job , not that long lasting for me. I would make it more creamyyy..
Delicious! I absolutely love 5
stephanief206 from undisclosed
Delicious! I absolutely love this product it is so easy to make and one of my favorite go to meals! Absolutely no critiques it's amazing and authentic compared to other products I've used. 100% recommend using this
The brow creator has 4
pamg10 from undisclosed
The brow creator has staying power. Can go on. Dark so use sparingly. Go with a lighter color than you normally would
Loved this product but 4
ariyellahh from undisclosed
Loved this product but I had trouble with the applicator but I love this I just wouldn't give it 5 stars because I wish it was easier to use
My go to brow 4
amyv79 from undisclosed
My go to brow fill in product. Color stays on throughout the day. I'm not a fan of the powder part of the pencil, as it appears smudgy.
Bad Quality 1
ZM from New York, NY
I really wanted to like this product, given all the good reviews. Second time I went to use it, it fell apart. I couldn't get the cap off and when I pulled, it split open and I can't get it to close again. The spring in the middle won't let me. Extremely disappointed in the product as it was nice on the cheap end considering it's a drug store product.
Love the powder 4
-n/a from -n/a
I love the powder and the applicator was very nice for applying it. However, when I first bought it I didn't know there was a powder. The first time you open in it is kind of hard to but then it is easy. I also think that the pencil itself is a bit too thin for my liking. I also got soft brown and it had a very red undertone but the powder was a more useable shade for. The spooly also isn't great.
Love the sponge tip 2
dandksmommy from Fair Oaks, CA
Although this pencil is priced inexpensively for a three combo product I myself would pay more for this item if Revlon reworked the product formulas. I love the sponge applicator head, but the powder has excessive fallout like previous reviewers stated. Also, the pencil tip is fine and I was able to create hair like strokes, but yet again the product itself did not last on my skin for more than a few minutes. Last but not least, I was happy to see a spoolie attached, but it is a very rough spoolie. This could be a great product. It just needs some tweaks. I would pay $20+ for this product if the formulas were on point.
Nice dispenser 2
dandksmommy from Fair Oaks, CA
Not quite sure about all of the great reviews. For the price it's nice to have a pencil and a spoolie. But the product itself is not very good. The pencil tip is thin which is nice but the product bodies not last after you apply for more than a few minutes. The powder tip applicator is a great idea and size and I really like the sponge tip. But as others commented there is way too much fallout and it too fades away quickly. The idea of the pen is great. They just need to work on the formulas. I would definitely pay more money for this item if they reworked the formulas.
Great pigment 5
Nat from Coral Springs, Fl
Seen a YouTuber using this so I purchased and I don't regret it so far.
Easy to use! 5
Judi59 from Bedford, NH
Colorstay Brow Creator is great. Super easy to apply, the secret is press lightly when using the pencil tip and the powder tip. You can always apply more. If you are breaking the pencil tip, you're pressing to hard. My hair is ash blonde, so the soft brown is just right for my brows. Will definitely be using this product from now on.
