Rated 4.12 out of 5 stars
Most Helpful Positive Review Amazing I love this Product
I am not a big fan of Mascara but this one I fell in love with it doesn't take a lot but it has big pay off. I got this in a gift set that I got for my birthday. It makes me look like I have on fake lashes when I don't so that's a plus! What's not to love it's Too Faced! I am doing this review as part of and Influenster contest.
Most Helpful Critical Review I used to love it
I used to love this mascara, it was lengthening and waterproof but the last one I bought smudged all over and it was super clumply, I do t know if they changed the formula but is totally messy now, will be looking for another one
Reviewed by 25632 customers Not good
K from NY
Not good, my lashes are not what it says it should be! My eyes got swollen. I am going to return this!
The worst mascara I have ever tried
Blizzy920 from Worcester, MA
This is the worst mascara I have ever tried. It does not stay on my eye lashes all day. If I touch my eyes, I instantly look like a raccoon. It is very difficult to wash off. You are better off with a drugstore product.
Alice419 from Oklahoma City,Oklahoma
I don't wear make up. I have been wearing eyelash extensions for the last few years. The young lady who does these suggested going to eyelash lifting and tinting. And using mascara.
She recommended Better Than Sex and it is great mascara! After all these years of not using anything on my eyes this is so simple. And the look is amazing! It goes on so smoothly and my lashes are fuller and longer than they were with the extensions. Great product!
This is my FAVORITE mascara - and I've tried them all!
Jenny from Ohio
This is a great mascara and I use it daily. It's well worth the cost, as it does a better job than anything else I've tried.
Julie from Hopkins Mi
I bought this for work. I work alot with onions and my eyes water. This mascara doesn't run when my eyes water. I love this mascara and wear it everyday now not just for work.
I love the formula.
Kit from Oregon
I love this formula! When I asked for a mascara that is rain proof and cry proof I got it! I live in the PNW. It rains here... a lot.
The volume i get from the mascara is a definite plus as well.
Pam from PA
The only mascara I will ever buy. Love it!
Not what I expected
Donna from Seattle, WA
I complimented someone on her mascara and asked her what she used. She said this one. That was a couple of years back, so maybe that's why I didn't get the results I was looking for. I've had 8 dollar mascaras perform better than this. I'm going back to my Clinique one.
StephaniemL from HAWKINSVILLE, GA
Love it and worth the money
LauraD from Mechanicsburg, PA
The only thing I normally wear is mascara and this stuff is my go to. I recommend it to everyone who asks. Goes on smooth and goes clump my lashes.
Annie from California
I just got this as a gift from a relative. This mascara is pretty great. I just had a really rough day where I ended up crying a good amount and this stayed on! I was surprised to see that there was literally no mascara running down my face even after I sobbed and rubbed my eyeballs a ton. 10/10 would recommend.
No No No
Lex from New Jersey
I used to love this mascara and used to use it every single day. I recently repurchased it even though it is much more expensive than other mascaras I use. I used it for the first time today and absolutely hate it. It is clumpy, doesn't create length, and gets EVERYWHERE. It took me double the time to apply my mascara. I will not purchase again and will stick to my $10 mascara that works way better. Do not buy.
what's with the bad reviews? miracle mascara 100%!!
suzy from florida
this is the only mascara I will use, after wasting tons of money trying different ones out. I have very light eyelashes and very thin. without mascara you can't see my eyelashes. this is definitely a miracle product my eyelashes look awesome, nice and FULL. other mascara fail to do this for me, they just coat my little bit of lashes giving like no effect when they claim to do so.
as for flaky as someone said, I've never ever had that issue with this mascara and I've been using it for years. someone else said clumpy which I really don't have an issue with that, I mean every once in a while you may get a clump but what mascara doesn't do that. just simply comb it and it's gone. also I will say combing does not mess with the effects of the mascara either. it DOES hold the curl from my eyelash curler too. and it IS easy to remove, maybe the not easy comment was meant for the waterproof (which I've never tried). I also have small eyes and have no problem with the brush. I've always used a magnifying mirror and tilt it bottom up a bit, maybe try that if you have a hard time with bigger mascara brushes.
just try it out, seriously. don't let the bad reviews sway you..I honestly don't understand how those people get flakes etc, maybe doing something wrong like combing dry lashes etc? it's a best seller and has mostly great reviews for a reason- it's just amazing!! I do wish it wasn't so expensive but I can't complain it works wonders. it's unlike any mascara I've tried. so really, it's worth every penny!!
Therinoa from Macon, GA
Got this in a holiday gift set and decided to try wearing around the house first. Thank God I did. It smudges all around my eyes with just normal wear. I looked ridiculous..... Plus I really don't like the brush. It's huge and clunky and makes it hard to add definition to lashes.
Use to love
Gabby M. from Pittsburgh, PA
I use to really love this mascara but I don't know if the formula or something changed but the past few times I've bought this it was extremely dried out and always flaky.
Audrey from PNW
I paid much more money for this mascara because people rave about it. Much to my surprise, it is very clumpy and leaves a mess. I'm going back to my Clinique mascara that goes on easily and has a very clean look.
leah from greensboro, NC
I've been using the regular better than sex mascara for years and loved it but i just ran out and when i went to ulta, i decided to try the waterproof version. This works just as good as the original and it makes my lashes look so good!
Waste of money
Heidimac from SC
I had gotten an Ulta gift card for Christmas so I decided to treat myself for this mascara . I like my Maybelline magna 1000 times better! I actually had to go over my eyelashes with the Maybelline mascara. I was not impressed at all.
Pretty decent product
Makeup mom from Spring Hill, Fl
Overall a pretty good product, probably in my top 5. Was a little hard to remove but definitely lasts a long time
Love it! It is a must have for me!
Love from Ohio
I love everything about this mascara and am always recommending it to my friends!
Waterproof but clumpy from East Coast
The product tends to be clumpy and I can never seem to comb out my lashes in time before the mascara dries. Waterproof for sure and that's why I love it.
paige from louisiana united states
first of all the product is in a weighted tube, you get no product in there it just feels like you do. the brush is way too big for small eyes, and it makes a mess. the formula itself doesn't hold a curl and is flakey. packaging is cute though i guess
dominique from florida
i expected more from this being super expensive, and the reviews should have said enough before I damaged my lashes but it's terrible. super clumpy, the brush shape is bad, no volume at all.
I would buy again makes my eyelash longer and holds all day
Cidny from Chicago
Wand brushes lashes very well and separates them. Product lasts all day. I love that it makes my lashes longer and look like fake lashes. Product is not sticky and dries perfectly. Very light formula
Dry and itchy
Belle from Ohio
I bought this mascara for a year (maybe twice). It looks great the first few weeks but it dries out quickly. You do have to apply it very gently because it's pretty thick and can get clumpy. I have pretty sensitive skin and realized this was why I started getting flaky itchy skin under my eyes and was drying them out. I also had an issue with fallout and smudging. I switched to Perversion by Urban Decay because it's made for sensitive eyes and I love it!