Rated 4.62 out of 5 stars
Most Helpful Positive Review Love this!
I love this product. The brow pencil has a very fine tip so this is very precise and fills in great. I like that it's an automatic pencil, so you never have to sharpen it. I really liked the color options as well. I have dark brown hair, but I don't like using a harsh, dark brow pencil that makes my eyebrows look crazy drawn on. These colors are so natural, smooth, and blendable. My only problem with this product is that with as thin as this pencil is there's not hardly any product in there. It runs out really quick and for 20 bucks you should really get two in a package. I probably won't repurchase this because I think that there are less expensive brow pencils that are of equal quality, but I would recommend this to someone if price was not an issue.
Most Helpful Critical Review Serious Quality Issues
I am writing to you as a loyal customer of your Anastasia Brow Wizard. I have loved this product for many years and have faithfully spent my money purchasing it. However about a year ago or a little over, you changed the plastic you use to make this product. You lengthened the brush side to match the pencil so the user cannot easily tell which end is the brush and which is pencil. I understand that was probably more cost effective. But the worst result of your "cost cutting" is that the brush piece now breaks off after only a few uses. I have now bought 5 new brow wizards and every single one has this problem. You have a quality control issue and I wish you would correct it. I will no longer purchase Anastasia products and I will leave this review on every makeup site where I have purchased your brow wizard until you correct this quality problem. That makeup product is not inexpensive and your customers deserve better.
Reviewed by 7783 customers I love it, but not a lot of product.
Jessica from Glendale, AZ
I've been using this product for years! Goes on well and lasts all day. Perfect for light, hairlike strokes to give that natural look. The only downfall is that there's not a lot of product. I have to buy a new one every 1-2 months. At this point, it's basically an investment.
Perfect forced Colourpop upgrade
Natural brow queen from OR
I was recently devastated by the discontinuation of Colourpop's Precision Eye Brow Pencil in the color Granite. I'm super picky and had tried so many of their colors to find the right one. So many brow pencils are too red relative to the average brow color which is more muted. Granite was the PERFECT shade and that pencil had the coveted buildable, creamy texture that goes on easy and stays on. I had experimented with other brow pencils from NYX, Maybelline, Estée Lauder, etc. and none lived up to the Colourpop one. So when they discontinued it I was embarrassingly distraught—but this Anastasia Beverly Hills replacement in Granite hit the nail on the head!!! Exactly what I needed. Only downside is the price point. I am so glad I didn't have to go fishing for my perfect shade during lockdown. I did my research and found it on my second try. Wrote this review for others in my situation. Best of luck!
I gave these items as gifts. The recipients seemed to like t
Sharon from Mason, OH
I bought these items as gifts for granddaughters. They are back home with the items which is out of town.
I have a comment. Almost every time I try to use an Ulta coupon, I can't for one reason or another. The eyebrow pencil price should have qualified the coupon, but as too often happens, the brand I choose can't be applied to coupon discount.
On the other hand, an associate told us one of the nail polishes was on clearance. When we were checking out, it was Not on clearance. All very frustrating.
Love this item!
B from Birmingham
Makes my eyebrows look more natural! However, I wish they offered a "refill," because the pencil is rather pricey!
NO.. it breaks OFF to easy, way to $$$ to waste like that.
p mason from Atlanta
It breaks off every time you use it ,waste so much when it 's $$$$$$.
My favorite brow pencil!
Bendi from Greer, SC
While I'm far from a brow wiz, this product certainly helps me try to look like one! I appreciate the small wispy strokes you can make so that the brow doesn't look heavy. As an older lady, I just need enhancement with thinning brows.
Jenn from Maryland
I initially bought this brow pencil on recommendation from a beauty influencer. The product is okay, consistency is fine, and I like the thin applicator for creating hair like strokes. HOWEVER, the first pencil broke after a short amount of time. I eventually bought another one when they went on sale, and after only a handful of uses, the new one broke. The picture I attached shows the two broken pencils. I see no reason to continue to buy a brow pencil at this price when you only get a few uses out of it. Hard pass.
Michelle from Washington
This product is GREAT for eyebrows! for those who like a more of a natural eyebrow I would highly recommend, because the fine tip works so good. But for those who would want more of a fleek brow use the Anastasia Pomade. You could still use this eyebrow pencil but personally it takes me longer to get more of a bold brow. I still 100% recommend this to whoever though.
Easy to use
Clydiebear from Roselle Illinois
I love the Brow product. Easy to use and blends perfect with my shade. The spool is really nicely angled.
My go to for brows
Meagan B. from San Antonio, TX
This product is amazing, especially for blondes. I switch back & forth from this to the dip brow pomade, and only for 2 reasons:
1) The dip brow is more waterproof
2) For roughly the same price, the dip brow will last me an entire year; this pencil will last me 5-6 weeks.
It's my absolute favorite, but if you use it roughly every day, it's so creamy (which is a plus) that you'll run out within 2 months. Therefore I try to not to use it all the time! But the application is easy & forgiving. Highly recommend.
Perfect defining tool
Iris from Saginaw, MI
Perfect strokes for naturalizing the inside brow
Claudia from Willis tx
So far I have been using it forever I like it but sometimes I feel like they have downgraded the product but who knows
Jax from Los Angeles
I've bought a couple during the sales to give as gifts because everyone loves these so much, but I've tried the myself and they suck. There are drugstore brands that work much better at half the sale price. I keep the one I have in my car just in case I forget my makeup bag at home.
Great color and texture
Carrie Ruth from San Jose, CA
I like the way this pencil goes on smoothly without clumping.
:) from .
this pencil is great for outlining and filling your brows for natural definition without looking too dark. you don't have to use a lot of product for it to show up
Surfer girl from San Diego, Ca
I went shopping and the girl at the cash wrap had the most beautiful eye brows. She recommended this product to me and I'm so thankful for that interaction. I normally use a mac eye shadow, which can look really dark. When I used this pencil, it made my brows look naturally thicker without looking like I painted them on. My only vise is you cant tell which side is which on the pencil. You end up taking both sides of the caps off, to see which side is the pencil or the brush.
pretty good !!
seraphine from New jersey
this is super easy to apply but you have to be careful with the pressure because it's really easy to mess up. otherwise, it's really good because the tip is very fine so you can get details. there are some drugstore pencils that should do the job as well, though
Comb breaks off
Stacey from Miami Beach
The comb part has broken after a few uses on each one I've bought. I was hopeful and kept trying, but now it's not worth losing money over
Can't Live Without This
Sierra from Ohio
I've been using this in conjunction with the ABH clear brow gel for about 5 years and it's the only thing I'll use in my brows! I can't say enough good things about this product. It will forever be my favorite eyebrow pencil. :)
Massie from Monroe, LA
It pairs perfectly with the brow definer.
Tried & True Go To
NewEnglander89 from New Bedford, MA
I have used this product for a couple years now. My favorite brow product hands down.
Great for my eyebrows
Chelsea from Florida
This is a great product to help fill in your eyebrows. No one can tell you used it. My only negative, I think it's a little too expensive.
Great eyebrow pencil
Pariska from Utah
Love the Brow Wiz, the thin pencil goes on easy, stays on and the product itself lasts for months. The color covers eyebrows that are going and fills in nicely.
hard, breaks off with slight pressure
Katie. from ohio
save your money, the only way it could be a worse product is if it were marketed as a lip liner
SML from NY
I only had to apply a small amount in order for it to show and it was easy to remove! The shade I got was ebony which is a great shade of u have black hair. I would totally recommend!!!