Rated 4.14 out of 5 stars
Most Helpful Positive Review Amazing I love this Product
I am not a big fan of Mascara but this one I fell in love with it doesn't take a lot but it has big pay off. I got this in a gift set that I got for my birthday. It makes me look like I have on fake lashes when I don't so that's a plus! What's not to love it's Too Faced! I am doing this review as part of and Influenster contest.
Most Helpful Critical Review I used to love it
I used to love this mascara, it was lengthening and waterproof but the last one I bought smudged all over and it was super clumply, I do t know if they changed the formula but is totally messy now, will be looking for another one
Reviewed by 12423 customers Love it!
Pats from Topeka, KS
This mascara doesn't weigh down the lashes. Your leashes will still lift and curl after application. Staying power was a bonus.
I love it! Definitely waterproof
Monica from Shade, OH
As a dental professional, I need a mascara that is waterproof. I have kind of skimpy eyelashes, this mascara definitely makes my eyelashes look amazing!
I will not buy again as it flakes off. Too expensive for thi
D from Michigan
Flakes off, definitely not worth it, too expensive
Q from Q, ca
Did nothing for my lashes. Doesn't keep a curl, looks like no product is applied, flakes every where and leaves you with racoon eyes. Dont know how this is highly rated.
Bold BUT also ADHESIVE!
Aimz from online
I was very excited by the packaging. Every time I open it now, a giant chunk of messy black gunk gets everywhere! All over my hands and eyes... I wipe it off but the giant glob of mascara that I have to wipe off the brush has to go in the garbage every time I apply it because it doesn't go back in the bottle. It's super duper chunky on the eyes and don't dare to blink while it's drying or else you will get a glob of this waterproof paint all over your finished makeup and it's a giant hassle to clean up. I have to wipe it off my eye lids which hurts to do after needing to everyday. I like the product but I will never ever buy it again and I'll probably look into getting refunded because it's false advertising.
Suzi Q from Los Angeles
This mascara surprised me with quick application and superior results!
Sarah from Northeast
I love the regular version of this mascara so I wanted to try out the waterproof version for my wedding. This is very clumpy and does not build volume as well as the original formula
Not worth the cost
JCB from NC
Not as good as it used to be
Em tv from Pennsylvania
I remember loving this mascara a few years ago. I tried it again but it just wasn't the same. I had black flakes below my eyes after a short time wearing it and it smudged (even though I only applied 1 coat.) However, I'm giving it 3 stars because I like the brush and it is waterproof like it claims.
Finally found the perfect waterproof mascara!
Deb from La Quinta, Ca.
I am completely satisfied with this mascara.
All of the other mascaras claim that they are waterproof, but unfortunately they would run with a little sweat. After putting this one to the test, it stayed on without running. I'm hooked & I love the stylish tube!
Will not buy again
Jen from Kansas City
Nothing like I thought it would be. Very disappointed.
I recommend this product!
Izzy from St.Louis, MO
this mascara is nice. however, it can make your lashes look really chunky and stuck together; at least in my experience!
NOT WATERPROOF AT ALL !
J from Los Angeles
it is not waterproof at all if you don't want panda eyes don't buy it
I am very unhappy
Awelliver from Long Island, NY
I bought this because I love Too Faced and wanted a great waterproof mascara. I finally tried it 2 times and both were exactly the same results:
Globs were stuck to the brush
Could not get rid of said globs
Putting it on each time I needed a bunch of q-tips to take off the transfer from the lashes to the corners of my eye and on my eye lid.
Too much work for mascara. I am really disappointed 😔
Better than Sex Mascara
Connie from Madison, Wi
This waterproof mascara is AMAZING. I wear gas perm contact lenses. The fibers do not flake off in your eyes. No smudging and removal at the end of the day is simple. I swim regularly so waterproof is important. Love this mascara!❤️❤️❤️❤️
Messy messy messy!
Lynden from New York
I bought this product from hearing good reviews about it, but it clearly was over-hyped because it was messy and I did not like the wand at all! It pretty much sets you up to have a messy application, even when you try your hardest to not get it on your eyelids. Oh and it clumps quite easily as well!
Gigi from Boston
I really like the mascara a lot but I hate that it runs. It's like within a couple hours there's mascara under my eyes, even though it's supposed to be waterproof. It's a bummer because I love the volume and how the brush fans out my lashes perfectly.
This is amazing!
April A. from UTAH
This mascara is the only mascara I will ever use, it makes my lashes so beautiful and also makes falsies look real. Only problem I have is when I either have 1. Oily lashes. Or 2. High humidity, sometimes the mascara will kinda "melt" on my eyelids. I have hooded eyes, which could be the problem. Other then that, highly recommend to anyone! Don't use a makeup wipe cause it won't come off.. it's tougher than the original better then sex!
Beck from Pikeville Ky
Baby oil or eye makeup removal product is a must when washing your face to get it off
Waterproof and a great mascara
Florida Mama from West Palm Beach
Daily use bc as stay at home mom of two young boys we are outside and active despite the Florida heat.
I would buy this product again
Christine from Tampa,Fl
I use it every day. Love how it makes my lashes look.
Miy from Wisconsin
FYI: I have oily, hooded eyelids and straight lashes
I have been testing out mascaras for my wedding day and so far this is my favorite! Most mascaras weigh my lashes down after I've already curled them but I'm happy to say this one didn't! I wanted to love the non-waterproof version because it does wonders for my lashes but it sadly flaked and smudged. I'm so thankful for this version! Dare I say, my holy grail and I've tried Chanel Le Volume, Lancome Monsieur Big, IT Superhero, and much more!
Kota from Iowa
Not flaky and Easy to apply.
It doesnt get better then this
D thats me from Lafayette,IN
Always my go to mascara, leaves my lashes thick and full of volume
I would buy this product again!
StarryNights from El Paso, TX
I had heard good things about this mascara and I wasn't sure about it so I got the travel size and oh I regret not getting the full-sized one! I am a big fan of trying a bunch of different things until I find the perfect one for me. I have tried so many different ones at ULTA and this one right here, is worth it entirely 100% will be buying once my travel size one is finished.