Product Reviews Rated 4.5 out of 5 stars
381 Reviews
Most Helpful Positive Review Great mascara I have average lashes and they are light brown. So I always look for separating and lengthening in a mascara. This mascara does exactly that. The first day I wore it was for a full day of hiking. It went on great, stayed all day, didn't flake and washes off easily with a gentle face cleanser. The packaging is lovely and while glass is unusual for mascara (don't drop it on your toe), I love that it's recyclable. I love Pacifica products and this is a great one. The price is obviously more than drug-store, but for vegan/cruelty free etc. and great quality, it is certainly worth it.
Most Helpful Critical Review It's Okay. There's a lot of hype around this product... and it's just hype. But that doesn't mean it doesn't deserve some positive attention. The always vegan and non-irritating formula is why I only buy Pacifica Mascara. A past experience with another mascara brand caused a horrific allergic reaction - as a result all my eyelashes had fallen out and regrew as pure white. My mascara is pretty much attached to my hip now; Pacifica's formula has never done me wrong. Secondly, switching from plastic to glass is not only beautiful but aligned with my vegan ethics on our environmental impact. Love it. Is it their best mascara though? In retrospect, I think Stellar Gaze is 100% better. And there's a few reasons for this. "Fluffy" is more a marketing work than an achievable result. The thin formula does allow more even coverage and spacing of your eyelashes, making it stay soft and ideal for a natural look. But do give it time set as the formula is more prone to smearing than their previous mascara lines. This mascara did not give my lashes a longer-length appearance: it's pretty average as far as mascara goes. Again, Stellar Gaze did it better. This is all well and good if you like a natural looking lash with a trusted vegan formula, as I do. But the wand... ridiculous. What even. I can't. All I can say about this new wand style is just adapt the best you can and be patient. I hope the next gen of this mascara uses a more functional wand.
Reviewed by 381 customers It was dry! Do not buy 1
Pamela from Dallas Tx
I don't know if it was just this purchase; this was the driest mascara. I returned!
My new favorite mascara 5
Trisha from NJ
This has become my go to mascara.
Hoped it would be better 3
Elle from NC
This mascara did nothing but clump my lashes together. There are much better mascaras a lot cheaper than this one.
Wonderful products 5
LadyJay from NJ
I love this mascara. It makes my lashes long and does not clump or flake. I am 64 and love these products. My skin is aging and sensitive and these fit my budget and work great for me!
great 5
sydney56 from Kokomo Indiana
I love this mascara. It has made my lashes fuller and longer and it is great. The only thing I would say is if you get your face wet or cry or something and it gets in your eyes, it kind burns your eyes, but other than that, it's a wonderful product.
Wanted to like it 3
Jacks from Austin, Texas
Mascara went on great with wand! Packaging is adorable! However, transferred to eyelids :(
LOVE. LOVE. LOVE. 5
Kayle from Phoenix, AZ
Glides onto my lashes evenly for long, full, beautiful lashes!
Pacifica Vegan mascara 5
Lizzied from Naples, Fl
Use this product every day. Doesn't flake, creates long lashes.
Great Formula 5
Aun2003 from Canada
Its really hard to find a clean vegan mascara that doesn't have a bog price tag on it. This mascara is affordable and does wonders for your lashes! Would definitely purchase this again.
Good Mascara! 4
Rain from Virginia
Very good product. Love the glass packaging. Wish it was a little longer lasting (over 12 hours), but it's still good. Fairly easy to remove.
Great mascara 5
Marie from Southern California
Stays on all day, no clumping or flaking.
Cruelty free and lovely 5
Tofutoughness from Mount Dora Florida
Amazing length added to my lashes and it's cruelty free
Awful 1
Holly from Mia
This mascara seemed like it'd be great because I love thick voluminous lashes. It's terrible!!! The bristles are spaced out wayyyy too far so it makes your lashes stick in pieces clumps. I like a somewhat clumpy voluminous look, but this is a BAD kind of clumpy, where I look like I have 4 eyelashes. Also I cried a little while wearing it and the formula got sooo messy all over my face! With a regular mascara perhaps not "clean" a few tears would've looked totally fine. This has black streaks all down my face. If you have watery eyes probably avoid this. Everyone should avoid this. Get Lancôme Mr Big, Rare Beauty mascara, or the Milani Highly Rated Anti Gravity mascara over this one!!!
Fluffy mascara 5
Frankie from undisclosed
It's great does not clump and is true to its name Fluffy mascara
Spider lashes! 2
RachelLynn from US
I thought I was gonna love this after reading other reviews and info about this mascara, the packaging is cute, its a glass bottle and I like the heaviness. The product however, leaves my lashes in clumps, its really difficult to get the inner lashes with the brush. Its pretty thick and takes a while to dry, even with just one or two coats. I started using a different brush & got a little bit better results without the clumped together eyelashes, wont buy this again, theres better ones out there for probably less than you'd pay for this.
Best clean mascara! 5
Carly L. from Minneapolis, MN
Such a good mascara that makes you feel good about what you are buying.
Best clean mascara! 5
Carly L. from Minneapolis, MN
Such a good mascara that makes you feel good about what you are buying.
Love it! 5
Jenn from STL MO
Great mascara! It stays soft throughout the day and it doesn't rub off below my eyes.
It's nice 4
Bre from Portland, OR
I hesitated because it was a bit expensive for a Pacifica mascara, but I've spend more on high end ones, and the packaging is cute & felt heavy in my hand, so I went for it. I would say it's a bit above average, it lengthened and separated my lashes, but they didn't look any thicker, and lacked any sort of WOW factor. One positive note is that I have pretty oily skin, so I usually have a lot of transfer with mascaras, but I wore this for at least 6 hours and even fell asleep in it, but there was no flaking or transfer, even on my bottom lashes.
It's nice 4
Bre from Portland, OR
I hesitated because this was kind of expensive for a Pacifica mascara, but the packaging was cute and I loved how it matched with the primer/serum mascara, and it's still less than I've paid for high end brands. It definitely lengthens and separates my lashes which is nice, but it's not fluffy or thickening. It's just sort of average in that aspect. I have pretty oily skin and usually have a lot of transfer with mascara, but I didn't have any after several hours, even on my bottom lashes, and I accidentally fell asleep with it on, too. Also, the packaging is nice and heavy, and feels high quality.
Good product 5
LindaBP from Fayetteville, AR
This mascara really works and enhances my lashes without flaking and rubbing off. I'm very pleased, so this will be my new mascara from now on!!
Wouldn't buy again 2
Mak from NC
Wouldn't buy again. Did nothing for my lashes.
Blonde lashes 5
SCoats from Arkansas
My eyelashes are blonde and short . Using this product ,I can actually see them .
Ehh 3
Steph from Bama
Not my fav.
Love it 5
Tricia from undisclosed
Doesn't smudge or run... Great since I work in a restaurant!