Rated 4.67 out of 5 stars
Most Helpful Positive Review Very helpful product
I was a bit hesitant to try this product because I didn't quite believe the hype, but I'm so glad I dedited to try it out.
I love this stuff. I have hardly any eyebrows from constantly plucking since I was 9(I'm in my mid 20's now). I've tried to let them grow out for a few years, and they are super sparse and all over the place now. They simply don't seem to grow in some areas.
So I thought, this probably won't work for me. I've been drawing my eyebrows on since I was 9 years old (because I'd over-pluck), and tried all sorts of products including, more recently, eyebrow products with little mascara style brushes like this. They would dry and look ridiculous.
Anyway, this stuff looks suuuuper natural. I bought this along with the pencil. I use this first to fill in my brows and then the pencil to make them look sharper where needed.
Even my boyfriend said they looked super natural. They do, and this is exactly what I've been looking for for years.
I should mention, this isn't waterproof -which is fine;I haven't seen anything in descriptions saying it was..though for the price, I would like it a lot more if it were. I will just be using Model in a Bottle to make it waterproof.
The only other thing I noticed is that there doesn't seem to be much product in the container. Again, ideally, for the price I would hope for a little more, but it is what it is and it does work wonderfully so can't complain too much.
Lastly, I ordered this in the darkest shade, which is cool toned. I'm pretty cool-neutral, and have dark hair, so it works great for me. However, I do wonder how this would work on someone with much darker skin than mysel, as well as those with lighter, cooler toned hair. More
shades should definitely be made.
Other than that, this stuff is wonderful and I'm super happy with it. I'm very self conscious about having sparse brows and my brows clearly looking very artificial, so I'll be using this as long as it's available.
Most Helpful Critical Review Pricey & Super Small Product!!
I received a sample of this product from a friend and I absolutely loved it.... until I ordered it and saw how small this product is and I was shocked! For the price you are paying this product is SO SMALL!! Honestly, I thought I I received a travel sized one by mistake until I realized that this is the "regular size" for this product.
NOT WORTH THE PRICE and this is coming from someone who normally doesn't mind spending a ton of money on makeup
Reviewed by 15974 customers We gloppy
KB from Brookfield WI
I love the color but was very disappointed
it it comes out all gloppy on the spool brush and leaves big clumps on your brows
Love this product
Buttercup from Orlando, FL
I do not like using pencil since I can't am to get an even coverage, this product is perfect and takes no time to apply.
My daily go-to
Lily from California
I have been using this for years, and it is my everyday go-to product to make myself look more put together. I don't do a lot of makeup and I have no desire to learn how to pencil in my eyebrows, so this just makes the whole process way easier and faster for me!
I will buy again
Karen from Gate City,Ca
I absolutely love it
I'm a fan
Tiffany from Birmingham AL
Never really seriously used a brow filler product but this is so easy and lasts! It's waterproof and doesn't smudge 🙌🏼
Allie from Portland ME
This is my first time using brow gel, which is why I have it 4 stars, I have nothing to compare it to. However it made my brows looking fuller and more natural and I never had to worry about them losing their shape or fading.
Miss.Nay from Maryland
I LOVE THIS BROW GEL. THE SMALL BRUSH IS THE PERFECT SIZE. I AM NO WHERE NEAR A BROW EXPERT SO THIS IS PERFECT FOR BEGINNERS. I WILL DEF BE BUYING THE BIGGER SIZE
Mharb from Kansas City, Missouri
I was excited to try this product send sometimes I feel like a brow pencil doesn't quite do the trick. However I was sorely disappointed when using this product. The reviews were really good so I gave it a shot. My brows already have a good shape I use this product to make my brows appear thicker and to match my darkly color hair. I felt as if this product was like using a watercolor. I had to layer it to get the same effect that I would with a pencil. So the fact I had to do my brows about three times before work I found pretty annoying. Doubt I'll buy this again
Nope rubs off real easy!!
Stefanyjo from Hutchinson ks
This product is not for me.
This is my go to brow product!!
Jules from San Antonio TX
So I use this product almost every day. The only days I don't use it is because I didn't put on any makeup! It can be used alone, with brow powder, or/and pomade, depending on how you want your brows to look. Low makeup day? Swipe on Gimme brow for a little color and shape. I put it on against the grain and then brush them back into line for a little body. On a medium makeup day I apply the same way after using the brow powder. Finally, on hot, humid days or nights I apply the powder, then the pomade, then gimme brow. It lasts until I take it off!!
Thus is a great product for brows
kk from Fayetteville AR
this is the easiest to use brow product
Great for brows that need a small enhancement
Gigi from Florida
I have pretty thick browns naturally, but have a few spots that can always use a little bit of help. It is super easy to apply and covers up those sparse areas really well. I don't trust myself with a brow pencil or gel, so this is perfect for a person who rarely uses makeup! Makes my brows look great and it so easy to remove at the end of the day.
Best brow product
Meg from Delaware
I have tried a few that are less expensive but I always go back to this one. It goes on really well and has a larger range of shades than most brands.
I will keep buying this product!
Mamabird018 from GA
Love this product. I have Essential Tremors, so I cannot use a brow pencil but this works great.
t from edmond, oklahoma
this is literally my go to, my mom got me this and it's phenomenal. this works extremely well and it smells so good!
madelinedoesasmr from Denver, CO
I was using the NYX Tinted Brow Mascara previously which I love but I find they don't really have a lot of hold for my super unruly eyebrows which even though I wax always have a mind of their own…. This product has beautiful color and I love the hold for my brows. I also love that they are one of the only companies that actually carries a color for redheads since I dyed my hair auburn, I actually have a brow product that matches my hair now. Thank you Benefit!
Kate G from Gainesville, FL
This is my go to for quick, easy brows. Love it.
Jess from PA
Good brows fast, I love this product.
I'll definitely buy this product again
Ginny from Yakima, Wa
Now that I have gone gray I felt the need to have a gray brows, unfortunately gray is not a very easy color to find which I feel is unfortunate because it looks fabulous!!
I hate eyebrow pencils. This looks much more natural.
Jeannie from South Carolina
I love the small size and easy coverage.
Didn't Like It
Destiny from Washington
I really like Benefit for other things so I thought I would try their eyebrow gel and pencil. I didn't like either of them, especially for the price. I have another eyebrow gel that I like better and I only tried this one because I like to try different things. I don't like how it applied or how it looked with my eyebrows. Maybe if I tried a different shade it would be better, but still not worth the money in my opinion.
I'm in love,
This all I girl will need from Woods
I'm in real hardcore love, I have red hair and I never found anything that matched. Everything was too red and unnatural-looking. This is the only product I will use. I tried everything, everything. Nothing compares. I love your benefits, u make me smile every morning.
Love at first use. I have crash on benefit
Makes my eyebrows look 12,000 times bigger than they are
ML from US
It's not a cruelty free makes my eyebrows look 10 times bigger than they actually are and honestly worst product I've ever tried from benefits. If I could go back in time and not buy it again I would. And if I can also make there's a zero star review I would.
Not what I expected
Mer from Western NY
Tried to use as recommended by staff. Really not applicable for thinning brows which are sparse at the ends towards temples.
I would not buy this product again
Tarah from Spokane, WA
I'm not used to using a mascara type brush to apply color to my brows so this is probably a great product, but not for me.