Product Reviews Rated 4.24 out of 5 stars
1371 Reviews
Most Helpful Positive Review Stays all day I have light blonde hair and years of waxing and over plucking have left me with sparse brows. I usually use a form of dipbrow with a brush but its time consuming and the color never matches my skin and hair color. This was super easy to apply and the color was perfect, I used the blonde one. It blended easily and didnt smudge, even thru humidity and rain and swimming!! This has taken so much time out of my makeup application, because its one step and stays. I want to try a color darker just to see how it looks, but im happy i finally found a shade that doesn't look ridiculous! Best part, Its half the price if the leading brow makeup.
Most Helpful Critical Review Defines brows, but smudges I'm always looking for brow products to define my brows. This brow pencil goes on very smooth and really helps define your brows and give them better shape and a fuller look. The brush on the opposite end helps tame your brows too, but also really helps blend in the color for a more natural look. I'm not very big on brow pencils because they tend to smear. Although this brow pencil doesn't come off as easily, I still noticed it does smudge especially when you sweat. Very rich in color too.
Reviewed by 1371 customers Too Waxy 2
Daisy from Phoenix, AZ
I thought this going to be a good eyebrow pencil. But it's way too waxy. After putting it on and trying to use the spoolie, it completely came off onto the brush. Not buying again.
Too heavy 3
Ro from MD
This brow pencil consists of everything I DON'T like in a brow pencil. It makes your brows look heavy made up and not natural. I like very dry formulas. This was too waxy and dark and was different than what I'm use to. Its definitely too pigmented to give off a natural look.
Best drugstore pencil 4
40 characters from VA
I didn't know that they still made this. I'm glad it's still around. I have black brows, but I'm fair and my hair is like a medium/dark brown. It's difficult to match brow products bc black can be harsh but a lot of browns, most of them really, don't match. They look very obviously brown against my brows. This is one dark brown that works really well. It's cool enough to blend in with the black, giving a really natural look.
I don't like that the pencil is sort of thick, which can make really harsh lines. Then again I don't like micro pencils bc of how easily they break. Honestly I wish there were more traditional pencils for brows and not so many mechanical pencils, but I digress. Anyway I just use a light hand w this and it's fine. Also I really only shape my arch and tail. I leave the front of my brows alone. It looks way more natural to me that way.
I will probably repurchase this in the future. It was a great color match and like all colorstay products, it lasts all day.
Don't buy it 2
KeenB from Chicago
I hate this product. I LOVE Revlon Colorstay eyeliner. The browliner should be that, but in hair colors--PERIOD. This is angled, making it awkward to hold and apply. When I tried to fill in darker in spots I didn't push as hard, a whole pea-sized section just flakes off and is skin toned again. Terrible.
This brow pencil looks 5
anastasiad26 from undisclosed
This brow pencil looks so good on my eyebrows. It looks bold and very pretty and it lasts very long and I love it.
I haven't used this 4
pattyg39 from undisclosed
I haven't used this product for awhile but it's good. Easy to use and blend out the brow.
Love this eyebrow pencil! 5
ashleyc736 from undisclosed
Love this eyebrow pencil! It's very affordable and comes in different colors! I would definitely recommend! With I could receive more samples to try!
I love this for 5
chittygirl69 from undisclosed
I love this for my very brows because otherwise it looks like I don't even have a pair..lol my eye color is hazel and it needs no improvement
This one is nice 5
daniellenyc from undisclosed
This one is nice and thin to create the perfect brow arch and flawless look that every girl wants for their gorgeous brows. It's a must have and I jist run the the drug store and pick one up locally. It's great to keep in your makeup bag especially on the go.
Like the color of 3
lanaa20 from undisclosed
Like the color of the pencil but it breaks pretty easily so you can't push too hard on the pencil
The Revlon ColorStay Brow 5
kelseys5089 from undisclosed
The Revlon ColorStay Brow Pencil is a staple in my makeup bag. I use this product every day! It is super affordable and definitely compares to other higher end products! I would recommend this brow pencil to anyone looking for a quality product for a low price.
It gets the job 5
ptreadaway from undisclosed
It gets the job done effectively and never comes off during the day. Works great for me.
This product works so 5
mac9 from undisclosed
This product works so well! It's so affordable and it lasts throughout the day! Highly recommend
I really like this 5
ashleyp432 from undisclosed
I really like this pencil it goes on perfectly. The way it's shaped it glides right on.
This pencil is easy 4
jwood82 from undisclosed
This pencil is easy to use and blend. It stays put very well. I am naturally super blonde so I felt even the blonde one was just too dark for me though. I also felt that it just didn't have enough uses in it.
This is the best 5
kaitlins59 from undisclosed
This is the best drug store eyebrow product on the market. I've tried many, and always come back to the ColorStay pencil. The shade range is good, and the product itself is exceptional. I have repurchased this at least a dozen times, and will continue to do so in the future.
I love this brow 4
nicolemorrow3881cbe3 from undisclosed
I love this brow pencil. Good quality at a great price. The tip is small so it's easy to make your brows look natural. Good color match and easy to blend. Spoolie on the other end makes it easy to perfect your look.
It is the perfect 4
hollymarieswearingen from undisclosed
It is the perfect balance of slick and firm. The packaging was simple and basic. I would add a couple more shades to improve this product. It is a long lasting product that does not easily wipe off. I repurchase this product all the time!
Love the application process 4
katieb041516 from undisclosed
Love the application process for this brow pencil. Goes on more like a cream. Definitely worth the cost which is not expensive. Lasts me a long time. My eye color is blue.
This was a good 3
addyrhody from undisclosed
This was a good product for people who like a thicker eyebrow look. Personally wasn't a fan on myself because it was very heavy and made me feel like my eyebrows were huge. But for someone who wants thicker eyebrows this is the product for you!
Really having experience this 2
prattpam from undisclosed
Really having experience this much my daughter did one brow and I just didn't really need to try it more so I know the look
I love how this 5
jasminet79 from undisclosed
I love how this pencil glides on to my eyebrows and doesn't have that much pigment which allows it to look more natural when you apply. I recommend!
It was okay. Easy 4
laurac23 from undisclosed
It was okay. Easy to use but unfortunately didn't last as long as I wanted and could not find a good match for my shade. It went on smooth and filled in my scar area as good as can be expected (scars don't hide well). I may purchase again but not my go to.
Not my favorite. It's 3
claudiaheaea from undisclosed
Not my favorite. It's too waxy and the colors don't have enough pigment and don't last at all. It is very fine tipped, though
pretty basic eyebrow pencil 4
suburbansyndicate from undisclosed
pretty basic eyebrow pencil easy to use but it's your typical eyebrow pencil nowadays there are so many better products out there to do your brows but this is a great quick cheap alternative
